5 ms·
Got a source for that? I can say with confidence that I personally know dozens of people who have moved out of state with granted but unvested RSUs from their c
by paxys 5y ago
Got a source for that? I can say with confidence that I personally know dozens of people who have moved out of state with granted but unvested RSUs from their companies and exactly 0 have paid any taxes to California for them.
- itake 5y agoI can say with confidence that the people you personally know are committing tax fraud.
- MR4D 5y agoYou might want to double check your confidence - unless I’m reading it horribly wrong, Investopedia supports the previous post, not yours. [0] - https://www.investopedia.com/articles/tax/09/restricted-stock-tax.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/tax/09/restricted-stoc...
- rahimnathwani 5y agoIf you want to know about California tax law, and you have three options: A) An article on Investopedia, that has a section about taxes in general, but not about California tax in particular. B) A comment from someone on HN talking specifically about California tax law. C) A publication by the California Franchise Tax Board. Which would you pick? If you chose B, check out my earlier comment. If you chose C, check out https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/misc/1004.html https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/misc/1004.html Not sure why you would choose A, as it's neither specific to California taxes, nor is it an authority.
- pc86 5y agoDoes it feel good to be this needlessly hostile to random people on the internet?
- nick__m 5y agoWhat is so hostile about the previous post ? P.s. I am not a native english speaker so I must be missing something.
- psychlops 5y agoHow dare you be so hostile! Try to tone it down next time!
- sxp 5y agoIt has 8 lines. 7 of those are metacommentary (aka "noise"). 1 is useful information ("data"). It would be more efficient to have a higher signal-to-noise ratio in comments. Especially when responding to someone who is politely asking a question requesting more information.
- nick__m 5y agoThank you for the polite response!
- jedmeyers 5y ago> What is so hostile about the previous post ? We have sensed irony and/or sarcasm in your post, thus it was rightly deemed hostile by the HN post monitors. Please make an attempt to be more polite next time, especially when communicating with high karma individuals.
- sxp 5y agoFor RSUs, your link says "California will tax the wage income to the extent services were performed in California from the grant date to the vesting date." Where did you get the 33%/25% for years 3 & 4?
- jedmeyers 5y ago1 year in Cali out of 3 years after grant before vest = 33% 1 year in Cali out of 4 years after grant before vest = 25%
- jjav 5y ago> If you want to know about California tax law, and you have three options: This is missing the best and most appropriate option: D) Consult with tax accountant/lawyer very familiar with California. If non-trivial money is involved, anything else is playing with fire.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoRight, but that option would have been difficult to execute at 8pm on Monday, when I wrote my comment.
- paxys 5y agoAgain, provide a source for that confidence.
- BooneJS 5y agoMy FAANG employer and my CPA both agree I owe tax on RSUs that “partially vested” while a resident. An example of 48 shares of RSUs that vest 1/48 every month for 4 years (48 months), and I lived in CA for 6 months after they were granted (not vested, granted). In months 1-6, all were 100% California taxable. In month 7, I owed 6/7ths of the normal California tax. In month 8, it was 6/8ths. In month 48, the final vest, will be taxed by California at 6/48ths of a full resident. My new state also taxes them, but I can deduct taxes I pay to California so I don’t get double-taxes.
- 01100011 5y agoThis sounds well informed: https://www.upstartwealth.com/blog/will-you-owe-ca-tax-after-you-leave https://www.upstartwealth.com/blog/will-you-owe-ca-tax-after... If I'm reading it right, I should move the hell out of CA as fast as possible and skip waiting until next year as planned.
- newman314 5y agoThanks for the link. This was helpful.
- rahimnathwani 5y agohttps://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/misc/1004.html https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/misc/1004.html Search for the phrase 'one reasonable method'. To me, in the contrived example I outlined, it seems reasonable to pay CA tax only on the first year's vest. But, from reading the linked page, I'm not sure whether the CA tax authorities could be made to see it the same way. Of course, your friends are free to declare and pay taxes as they see fit, given their understanding of the law, their risk tolerance etc.
- paxys 5y agoMost of that page deals with ISOs and NSOs, which are very different from the case you described. The section "E. Restricted Stock" is itself about Restricted Stock Awards (RSAs) NOT Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), the latter of which is what I imagine most non-executives reading this are getting. In case of RSAs you actually "own" the stock during the vesting period (including having voting rights), so it makes some sense to be taxed on it for that period. See https://carta.com/blog/breaking-down-rsas-and-rsus/ https://carta.com/blog/breaking-down-rsas-and-rsus/.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoIt's unclear whether RSUs are covered by section E: - RSUs are a type of restricted stock, which suggests that they would be covered by section E. (supporting my earlier assumption.) - The examples in section E talk about 'purchase date' instead of 'grant date', suggesting they're talking about RSAs. (supporting your point.) However: RSUs must be covered by that publication somehow. If they're not covered by section E, then which section covers them?
- paxys 5y agoRSUs are, I imagine, not covered by this page because – unlike ISO/NSO/RSAs – RSU vesting schedules are simply a vague promise by the employer and not something legally binding or formally recognized by tax authorities.
- 5y ago
- emu 5y agoMy employer withheld California tax on restricted stock grants for me exactly as described here when I moved out of California years ago. Other states even have forms for you to submit this calculation to them, see for example New York's IT203-F Schedule B. But you still have to apportion the income between states like this whether there's a form to do it on or not.
- WalterBright 5y agoI wouldn't get tax advice from random people on the internet. If you make above a certain amount of income, and if you have stock options you likely are, it is worth your while to hire a CPA to do your taxes and get tax advice from. It might sound expensive, but the alternative is worse. Consider a friend of mine during the 1999 stock bubble who had stock options. The bubble burst, and he owed taxes on the bubble amount, even though he never sold the stock. He was bankrupted, lost his house, and moved in with his family to a trailer. He had no idea about the tax consequences of his options.