4 ms·
As someone in the banking industry, this is the "right" answer. When I got started in banking I was pretty shocked about how easy it was to "authenticate" yours
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
As someone in the banking industry, this is the "right" answer. When I got started in banking I was pretty shocked about how easy it was to "authenticate" yourself to open a bank account. For example, this breach has pretty much all the things needed to open an account in someone else's name: Name, SSN, DoB, Address. That's pretty much all the KYC services use for validating an account application.
There are, of course, easily added forms of additional verification - for example, Stripe just added their Identity service which lets you take a picture of your driver's license and then match the image against a selfie. But that puts "friction" in front of the application process, so most banks don't do something like this unless other signals make them think the application has a high fraud risk.
If basically everyone's Name, SSN, DoB and Address is easily viewable public info, this will all change.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoSecurity doesn’t appear on a balance sheet, but security expenditures and related depreciating assets certainly do appear. A classic example of measuring the wrong thing.
- madamelic 5y agoOn the other side of that, there is such thing as too much friction. Shortly before BBVA closed them, I was in a back-and-forth to open an account with Simple. First, my ID was too shiny, then it wasn't black and white, then it wasn't color, then they wanted a picture of my apartment building, then ... it was just on and on and on for three weeks. It got to the point where I asked what exactly they wanted and they literally told me that they cannot tell me because it would allow me to commit fraud. I asked if I could talk directly to their fraud team to figure out what exactly: nope. Can't do that, they can't talk to you. So I was expected to either read their minds or play infinite whack-a-mole with them where they say one thing in one email then say the opposite in the next.
- pas 5y agoYes, no problem with that. Eventually a long standing established digital identity is needed. Provided by anyone, state, bank, etc. Opening a new one should be easy though, but risk assessment should be done at every step (as the account gains new trust in whatever system).
- specialist 5y agoCorrect. This achievement then unlocks Privacy technology. Currently, PII must be stored as plaintext. Required for matching records across systems. Once UUIDs are used, all data at rest, at the field level, can be encrypted. cite: Book Translucent Databases 2nd ed.
- mlindner 5y agoT-Mobile doesn't have anyone's SSNs... They're not required to get a cell phone number.
- claytongulick 5y agoThat hasn't been my experience with any major cell provider. They have refused to provide me service if I don't give my SSN. To get around it, I've had to open business accounts with my EIN.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoIt is to provide you with credit. A deposit may work as well. Prepaid doesn't have the issue.
- eitland 5y ago> It is to provide you with credit. Many places it is to prevent abuse. I don't think I have been able yo legally get a phone number in Norway without identifykng myself for years. Maybe if you go to a lawyer they can sort something, but that will be another league for most of us.
- yebyen 5y agoIf you can explain to me how a monthly service where payment is required in full every month requires a credit agreement, I'll (don't know, do something crazy like eating my hat) - this is the standard service provider contract, for some reason it is considered a credit instrument and can land on your credit report. That being said, you are right, there are prepaid options and postpaid with a deposit ($50) that can put you outside of this SSN requirement on T-Mobile. I guess you have to know to ask for them. It is for credit, that's the only reason they can ask for your SSN. Everything is credit based now, and for some people their phone bill might even be their first positive (or negative) mark on a credit score rating.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago