3 ms·
Also, Total Factor Productivity will include the effects of everything a society does that can be measured in monetary terms. Dumping poison in rivers would pr
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Also, Total Factor Productivity will include the effects of everything a society does that can be measured in monetary terms.
Dumping poison in rivers would probably show up as an "efficiency gain" at least until it causes ecosystem collapse and widespread illness and death, similarly so would clearcutting forests.
I would expect at least some attempt to ground the claim in something real before leaping to a headline grabbing "computers aren't productive" (except for that bit when the productivity went up faster than previously) conclusion.
For starters, do we care about TFP (the article implies we do) and if so has whatever we predict it to provide as a benefit also followed a similar graph? If not, then who cares if computers or anything else makes the graph go up.
Secondly, how can we tell if computers have made it shoot upwards, but some other unconnected change has mostly negated that impact.
It all feels very shoddy.
The first time this came up in economics neatly lines up with when the graph suddenly changes direction upwards:
"You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics." Solow, 1987