3 ms·
> IMO, "nation building" is always an impossible mission. The objective should have been to attack, destroy the enemy, and leave - immediately. Punishing the sp
by mschuster91 5y ago
> IMO, "nation building" is always an impossible mission. The objective should have been to attack, destroy the enemy, and leave - immediately. Punishing the sponsors of the 9/11 attacks, not entrenching an ideological split.
That's bollocks. I'm German, had the Allied Powers followed the Morgenthau plan Germany would be essentially an Afghanistan today - an agro state and nothing more. But you all followed through with Marshall, and that was perhaps the ideal example that nation building works.
It is just very complex, requires understanding of cultural differences, and patience. The Western countries didn't even have a proper post-immediate-hostility strategy (partially because Bush's cronies clearly hadn't invested a single second of thought beyond "how to fill the coffers of the MIC) in Afghanistan, much less a plan on how to give Afghanistan-the-country an economic perspective beyond farming opium.
Afghanistan has a lot of precious natural resources: minerals, metals, oil and gas. Had the Western countries invested in kickstarting mining these, providing locals with employment and the government with a steady stream of funds, the situation would have been very difficult today. Especially since a population that has security, stability and income doesn't go and look for the next fundamentalist terrorist for a perspective!
As a result: I refuse to put blame on any ANA soldier or civilian for deserting against the Taliban. Why fight for a country that has literally no way to survive on its own?
And fwiw, the lack of a modern "Marshall Plan" clone is also what led to the shitshows that are Libya, Iraq, Lebanon and Syria. You can't just go into a place, depose a dictator and then hope that the situation will turn out all right on its own. If you want democracy, you have to make it appealing to people!
- foobarian 5y ago> But you all followed through with Marshall, and that was perhaps the ideal example that nation building works. I don't know about this. I may call it "nation re-building" - Europe already had highly developed societies, infrastructure, and institutions. But coming into a less developed country and trying to insert those institutions by force - or even worse replace them - sounds unlikely to work. I wonder if maybe the Americans started actually believing the nation building stuff after saying it over and over for 5 decades...
- rayiner 5y agoYou’re completely overlooking how unprepared Afghans are for secular democracy. Germany and Japan had well developed states before World War II. Afghanistan had never been more than a pastoral tribal society. They’re hundreds of years of development away from the democracy we tried to impose on them. See: https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/the-afghanistan-occupation-and-the https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/the-afghanistan-occupation...
- mschuster91 5y ago> You’re completely overlooking how unprepared Afghans are for secular democracy. Provide people with tangible benefits they gain from democracy and then it will come as naturally as they flock to the Taliban simply because they promise to get rid of the Western countries. The West didn't do anything to actually promote democracy and provide a perspective for the people, and then we all wondered why the Taliban were able to take over the entire fucking country in a matter of two weeks.
- rayiner 5y agoThat’s not how it works. Democracy isn’t something you can gift like Prometheus giving humans fire. It’s something that must rest on a society’s cultural foundation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Future_of_Freedom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Future_of_Freedom Britain dropped some criminals in Australia and they created a prosperous democracy. Because the people had a millennium of cultural development under its belt to support democracy. Meanwhile democracy has failed in Iraq and Afghanistan despite massive US support. In my home country of Bangladesh, we’ve had civilization for over a thousand years. The British spent 200 years in the country building institutions and culture. We have a lovely constitution. And even then we can’t maintain democracy. We’re basically back to a one party state now. The Afghans have never even had a real national government of their own. Their society is at a feudal stage of development. It’s like trying to bring democracy to England circa 600 AD.
- random314 5y ago> The British spent 200 years in the country building institutions and culture. That is a sorry description of colonialism. Your theory of "cultural development" also doesn't explain how Germany chose through elections to turn itself in to a Nazi state. As an aside, Zakaria is a talking head, part of the news as entertainment complex - sticking to the mainstream narrative as close as possible while trying to appear insightful at the same time. He is neither a historian, economist or sociologist and is a known plagiarist. Why would anyone want to read his books?
- linuxftw 5y agoGermany is still occupied by Americans. We're still defending you from the same foreign adversary, Russia. If the US pulled out of Germany in 1965, what would have become of the place? IMO, it's clear. The communists would have been conscripted into war, West Germany would have surrendered rather than fight their countrymen. This is exactly what happened in Vietnam and it's what is happening in Afghanistan now.
- rrss 5y agoregardless of whether the US had a continuous military presence in west Germany, it is implausible to me that east Germany / the USSR could have taken over west germany without starting WWIII. West Germany was a NATO member state by 1955.
- linuxftw 5y agoThere is no NATO without the US occupation of Europe. If the US pulls out of NATO, it will fold like the Afghan security force.
- sofixa 5y agoThat's just bullshit. France had nukes in 1965, and still does today. Baring a communist revolution in France, US troops in Europe made no practical difference. And they don't today.
- 5y ago
- rrss 5y agoThe U.S. did spend sort of a lot of money in attempts to develop infrastructure and industry in Afghanistan. But it mostly achieved nothing because of the widespread corruption (both of Americans and afghans) and lack of an overall plan that made any sense (as you noted). Here’s a report on what $500 million to develop mining achieved: https://www.sigar.mil/pdf/audits/SIGAR-16-11-AR.pdf https://www.sigar.mil/pdf/audits/SIGAR-16-11-AR.pdf There are probably something like hundreds of these reports, all with similar conclusions - spent a ton of money, didn’t really achieve anything meaningful, made some crooks richer, and the taliban either a profits from what little was achieved (for “protection services” and such) or just blows it up. We can dream that this could have been better, but I’m unconvinced that the US in the 21st century is capable of achieving any different outcome.