20 ms·
Widelands is a free, open-source real-time strategy game
- rswskg 5y agoThis game is hard. It's settlers 2 but with many many more ways to mess yourself up. Sadly the community is mostly german, otherwise I'd be an active participant. It's a great game and a great advert for open source gaming.
- ducktective 5y agoYou mean the development language is German?
- movedx 5y agoLOL! Sorry - I just picked a German programming language. Damn. I think they meant the community is mostly German. Germans tend to have very good English skills, but if most of the people around you in the (game's) community are native German speakers why speak English and struggle along? That's probably what they meant.
- scns 5y agoThis. Text in the community forums.
- scbrg 5y ago> Germans tend to have very good English skills, but if most of the people around you in the (game's) community are native German speakers why speak English and struggle along? Because most is not the same as all. Unfortunately, this is sort of a self fulfilling prophecy, as rswskg's original comment indicates. The fact that the community is German speaking means that non German speakers won't join (effectively restricting the pool of potential contributors by ~99%), and thus the German speakers won't have any reason to not speak German.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoWell, the same applies to English.
- rswskg 5y agoThat is what I meant. There are great youtube communities, but it's mostly german.
- npteljes 5y agoThe original Settlers developer studio is also in Germany. Now it makes sense how my version was called Siedlers II.
- kzrdude 5y agoAnd the original settlers board game - Catan - is of course also German.
- morsch 5y agoThe board game came out after the first computer game. The two are not related.
- kzrdude 5y agoOh.. i didn't know! Maybe the relation is still there, inverted?
- morsch 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia, Klaus Teuber started designing the board game years before the computer game was released, so it's probably not a major source of inspiration. He did change the name (adding "of Catan") so people wouldn't mistake one for the other.
- Delk 5y agoDie Siedler (the plural is the same as the singular), but yeah.
- Barrin92 5y agohad to laugh when I saw that it's mostly German. Anno, Settlers, Patricians, we seem to love our simulation games.
- safog 5y agooo those are my favorite types of games as well.. along with things like Frostpunk, Roller Coaster Tycoon, Ceasar, EU4, CK3 etc. I've never heard of Settlers before, any other games of a similar mould?
- onli 5y agoKnights & Merchants is the only game I know that is a bit similar. Settlers always felt pretty unique.
- methyl 5y agoAnd, interestingly, it’s also from Germany. Check out kamremake.com for a rewrite which runs much better than the original.
- botch_san 5y agoI can recommend the cultures games (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultures_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultures_(video_game))
- rswskg 5y agoJust try the settlers. It's lovely, really fun and surprisingly well made for such an old game. I remember first playing it on a 486!
- slim 5y agoLearn german :) it's not that difficult, it's really fun and imho very cool. I learned english by playing betrayal at krondor with a dictionnary for only help (to be honest I was much younger and had plenty of time)
- Tistron 5y agoSeems their website couldn't t handle being on the front page. I found them on github https://github.com/widelands/widelands https://github.com/widelands/widelands where it's described as: "Widelands is a free, open source real-time strategy game with singleplayer campaigns and a multiplayer mode. The game was inspired by Settlers II™ (© Bluebyte) but has significantly more variety and depth to it." It makes me quite excited. I really loved settlers II and I am waiting curiously for the next release of the settlers saga, as I haven't liked the follow-ups. The next instalment is said to be more like settlers II again. Maybe this open and free game is all I really wanted? I will try it out!
- mattlondon 5y agoYep it is basically a clone of Settlers 2. I tried it a couple of years ago and it had a reasonable single-player "campaign" too so that was good. I seem to recall that the campaign kinda "ran out" half way but I guess that is to be expected. Otherwise thoroughly enjoyable if you liked Settlers 2 (but disliked their sequels)
- barbs 5y agoIt looks like version 1.0 was released a couple of months ago so it's possible the campaign is complete now?
- aniforprez 5y agoOn a completely unrelated note, I'm so surprised that static sites like this that are basically just simple advertising pages with text and some internal links just completely fail like this so often when they get a little attention. It's just serving HTML, CSS and some JQuery (looked at the source on Google cache). If they set up even the simplest caching solution with nginx or some other reverse proxy or hosting tool it wouldn't fail so spectacularly. Unless it's doing backend requests, there are extremely simple solutions to keep sites like these up
- praptak 5y agoIt's probably bandwidth. You may serve static html from L1 cache and still get DoSed.
- sebastianz 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20210811083622/https://www.widelands.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210811083622/https://www.widel... https://github.com/widelands/widelands https://github.com/widelands/widelands
- nabakin 5y agoSince we crashed their servers https://archive.is/SEGE7 https://archive.is/SEGE7
- Asraelite 5y agoI hadn't realized they released version 1.0 this June. This was one of the first games I played on Linux so it's nice to see it finally hit that milestone after watching it slowly progress for so many years.
- ovi256 5y agoI've always liked OSS games, for the big reason that they're usually multi-platform, so you can play them on Linux and Mac OS too. I also recommend: Spring RTS (amazing RTS engine, clone of Total Annihilation) UrbanTerror (unfortunate name, reasonable clone of Counter Strike)
- rosetremiere 5y agoNote that Urban Terror is not open source.
- moviuro 5y agoDon't forget: * OpenRA; Red Alert & Command&Conquer clone https://www.openra.net/ https://www.openra.net/ (a personal favorite of mine, first RTS I played) * Warzone2100 https://wz2100.net https://wz2100.net
- TLLtchvL8KZ 5y agoIf we're giving shout-outs I would like to give one to etlegacy* - the assets needed from Wolf:ET are not open but the engine/game/mod etc all are. Very important project for me as I've been playing W:ET since 2005! * https://github.com/etlegacy/etlegacy https://github.com/etlegacy/etlegacy
- fho 5y ago
- thecleaner 5y ago502 bad gateway
- doener 5y agoAdditionally to HN the game is also featured right now at Germany‘s popular gaming magazine GameStar: https://www.gamestar.de/artikel/widelands-siedler-aufbau-strategie-gratis-game,3372397.html https://www.gamestar.de/artikel/widelands-siedler-aufbau-str... That is also where I found the game.
- a20210816 5y agoI've played 0 A.D. lightly for about five years, and am excited to learn of another FLOSS RTS! I did a quick comparison of Widelands and 0 A.D. Overviews from the games' respective sites are [1,2], LibreGameWiki articles are [3,4], and source code repos are [5,6]. It seems Widelands focuses more on economics and transport, and maybe less on combat. Screenshots show Widelands has much simpler graphics. Developmentally, Widelands seems to use GitHub as its main source code repository and issue management system, whereas 0 A.D. uses GitHub as a mirror for its main Trac deployment. Both codebases are roughly 2/3rds C++. Beyond that, Widelands has lots of Lua (27%) and some Python (3%). 0 A.D. has lots of C (24%) and some JavaScript (6%). Has anyone played both Widelands and 0 A.D.? How do they compare? --- [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20210410230450/https://www.widelands.org/screenshots/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210410230450/https://www.widel... [2] https://play0ad.com/category/game-manual/ https://play0ad.com/category/game-manual/ [3] https://libregamewiki.org/Widelands https://libregamewiki.org/Widelands [4] https://libregamewiki.org/0_A.D https://libregamewiki.org/0_A.D. [5] https://github.com/widelands/widelands https://github.com/widelands/widelands [6] https://github.com/0ad/0ad https://github.com/0ad/0ad
- gmueckl 5y agoDisclaimer: I loved the original Settlers II a ton as a kid and it still has a special place in my heart. Widelands is pretty much a clone of Settlers II and stays close to its formula, including the graphical presentation which keeps the ca. 1995 isometric 2D graphics alive. The game is better described as a base builder / city builder game with the goal of expanding one's own territory to cover a certain goal point. Conflict arises because said point is usually in an opposing faction's territory and you have to take it by force. Combat is very indirect with no direct control over any units and thus there is virtually no tactics other than trying to man your posts with more better equipped and better trained soldiers. In essence, your military strength is mostly function of how well your backing industry works. Gameplay in the Settler series feels much like the Anno series after it in that there is a military component that comes into play late in the game. Most of the game is leading up to it, but has you focus on building a thriving colony in its own right. Within the Settlers series, Settlers II is unique in that it has a transport system of paths and cutesy carriers that needs a lot of attention from the player to avoid clogging and collapse. Terrain factors a lot into this, too. Later entries in the series have done away with most of this, which changed the feel of the games a lot. Unless things have changed, 0 A.D. is a straight up RTS with direct unit control and less base building. Moment to moment tactics matter. To me, it seems vaguely inspired by the Warcraft and Age of Empires lines games, but is not sticking very close to any one of these formulas.
- fps_doug 5y agoTime to check it out again. Last time was 15 years ago, iirc. I also like RTTR[1], a re-implementation of Settlers II, requiring the original game for graphics, sound etc. Which is actually a big plus for me, for purely nostalgic reasons. Widelands looks just "wrong" to me subjectively. ;) Unfortunately quite understaffed and some internal issues last I checked on the project. [1] https://www.siedler25.org/index.php?lang=en https://www.siedler25.org/index.php?lang=en
- proactivesvcs 5y agoSeafaring, new tribes, reworked and new campaigns, much improved routing, pack animals for increased road throughput, new start and win conditions; there's been a huge amount of new content since then :-)
- hakonbogen 5y agoInteresting concept, but based on the screenshots, the assets look significantly worse than Settlers 2. Hope this will be improved
- GlennS 5y agoI'm a little wary of games which boast of their "depth". Oftentimes it means "we didn't have a cohesive enough vision to reject any features". All that said, I do like Settlers 2, so I will give this a try.
- gota 5y agoIsn't that width? Dwarf Fortress is the epitome of 'depth' in a game, to the detriment of basic things like a graphical interface, and it couldn't be a better example of a creator's vision
- me_me_me 5y ago> Isn't that width? That depends on the implementation. Number of different features/actions is the game width. Complexity of the features are the depth. A turn based strategy might give you 10000 units that vary slightly, but not in a meaningful way is a shallow width. A roaster of units to choose from that counter certain opponent's units and have bonus interactions with certain friendly units would be example of depth.
- zzbzq 5y agoBreadth and depth Game communities call them both depth, which is a huge error. I played an RTS that claimed to have depth because of the insane amount of armor and weapon types. In the end, the armor/weapon strengths & weaknesses were still just rock-paper-scissors. Having hundreds of them just meant you had to look them up on a spreadsheet, in order to make the simple rock-paper-scissors decisions. This is breadth with no depth. Although confusingly, gamers will still call it "depth," not having the distinction of "breadth" in their vocabulary. Meanwhile simple ancient games like Go can achieve a large amount of complexity with simple rulesets. That's real depth. I think depth is probably hard to invent intentionally.
- me_me_me 5y agoOne could argue that Go from the design point of view is has no breadth nor depth. There are few rules and rules are very simple. Depth of the strategy and the gameplay comes out as emergent property of the game. But that's just splitting hair.
- mrfusion 5y agoAny fun games of this type for the iPhone?
- antifa 5y agoMajesty might be close enough, but I'm unfamiliar with widelands and settlers 2. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/majesty-fantasy-kingdom-sim/id455219788 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/majesty-fantasy-kingdom-sim/id...
- enbugger 5y agoSite is ded
- allgoodner 5y agoI can't seem to open the game; the site keeps on loading; is there any fix for this one? I'm looking forward to trying the game.
- marcodiego 5y agoI think most game styles do not fit the "open source" development model. Mainly because games often need a "surprise effect" when released and that is a poorly fit for open development and also because it is easier to contribute code than convince an artist to contribute art tailored to a very specific style. RTS and games like Wesnoth are an exception: they are born a certain way and slowly evolve through contributions to a point where they sometimes finally became very interesting. I have high hopes for the future of 0ad.
- eloisant 5y agoNot only they need a "surprise effect" at release, but once you played it enough you get bored and move to something else. Harder to keep contributors engaged. Unlike tools (i.e. text editors) that you can keep using for 20 years+ and never want to stop using it.
- herodoturtle 5y agoYeah true - in particular for new / innovative games. Whereas open source versions of old popular games seem to do very well, because it's less about the surprise and more about the nostalgia. See openra for example.
- ksm1717 5y agoI think highly variable, replayable, emergent games in general are a good fit. A random aspect (complex interacting systems, or rng that doesn’t railroad you) is a key component. That’s where some games get the surprise you mention. I think of paradox games, 4x, Minecraft, even Skyrim as possible good fits for open development (notably good for modding too). I don’t believe platformers, farcry type story/action, and multiplayer CoD types would make sense because the game is the same every run. Ie open development is viable when the team can be unopinionated in the way each playthrough will look. Agree that games where art direction is strong and an important differentiator are also not a good fit (thus making a Skyrim and its AAA style probably hard to replicate in an open team)
- go_elmo 5y agoI agree mostly but skill based games that are always the same would be awesome open source, e.g. CS:GO
- mrtweetyhack 5y agoI tried this game a few months ago. concept is good. too many annoyances, bad design. uninstalled.
- 2ion 5y agoThe soundtrack is very good.
- NoboruWataya 5y agoThis is a great game - my first thought when I played it was that it was quite unique, though since it's a clone of another game I guess that's not exactly true. It is, at least, quite different to most of the RTS I have played (like AOE, C&C, etc). The military aspect is very limited, which is exactly what I love about it. In most other RTS I have played, economy is a secondary concern at best and, once you get a decent sized military, really not a concern at all. In Widelands, building and maintaining a strong, sophisticated economy is the central goal.
- cogman10 5y agoYup, that's right in line with settlers II. You need a military to expand your boarder, but ultimately the economy is what will win or lose the game for you.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoDoes this have co-op campaigns by chance? Would be interested in playing through it with my son.
- proactivesvcs 5y agoThere are a handful of co-op scenarios, one involving winning by trading. The "skirmish"-style games can be set to have either "allies", where you operate separate economies but are on the same side, or "shared kingdoms" where you share everything except your starting locations. Shared Kingdoms is lots of fun!
- EvanKelly 5y agoI've always wanted to understand how a game like this actually runs, but always struggled with navigating through a project. I'm adept at reading and understanding code, but struggle to understand aa big project like this. Where does one start when looking at a github like this - where's the "game loop" actually live?
- jstimpfle 5y agoHaven't looked at this particular project, but most code is way too big and has way too much indirection so it's not clear where stuff happens just from browsing the code. I recommend setting up the project in an IDE / debugger and stepping through the code. To substantiate my point, here is an excert from the main function of the OP game. WLApplication\* g_app = nullptr; try { g_app = WLApplication::get(argc, const_cast<char const\*>(argv)); // TODO(unknown): handle exceptions from the constructor g_app->run(); delete g_app; return 0; } catch (const ParameterError& e) { // handle wrong commandline p Before anything of value happens, there is already a function call where it is impossible to find the called code with a simple text search. How the hell are you supposed to figure out where "get" lives (it's probably not prefixed by "WLApplication::" at the definition site)? You need at least an IDE with a solid "go to definition" feature. But likely that won't be enough since a lot of the stuff will only be resolved at runtime. If you want to learn architecture, I would recommend trying to do your own stuff and then to follow along with Casey Muratori's streams. While his streams are extremely verbose, he is a skilled communicator and most importantly he is one of the few persons on the planet who has figured out how to write modular software. (Very little of the stuff that makes modern software inscrutable - like OOP method syntax, inheritance, virtual functions, function pointers).
- IgorPartola 5y agogrep ‘ass WLApplication’ should do it, no?
- jstimpfle 5y agoThat would find you the class, not the implementation of the get() function in it. And what if it is a namespace? So my point is how complicated (and thus unergonomic) the simplest things are made without any evident reason.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agoSite is up.
- pdimitar 5y agoAre any of the recent open source games automatable / easy to script bots for? I've been looking to get into game bot development and I'm very curious what's the easiest way for me to automate an RTS, ideally am open source one -- but the StarCratt 1 OpenBW + SSCAIT project would be fine as well. Does anybody have experience?
- krasi0 5y agoI really recommend getting into StarCraft 1 BroodWar AI development using BWAPI. OpenBW is open source and there's a thriving and helpful community around bot development. A lot of tournaments / competitions and video casts too. You won't regret it. Search for the SSCAIT Discord link. (I am on mobile and don't have it handy).
- pdimitar 5y agoWe've had this chat before. :D (zdrasti) My main interest is: how automatable the whole thing is? Looking at the SSCAIT Twitch stream, it regularly hangs and sits there for hours before somebody manually unlocks it (I presume). Regardless of the game, I'd simply want an ecosystem where you can run your own SSCAIT on your own machine. Also, can OpenBW be run on Linux?