2 ms·
The trouble with news today is that the ratio of publicity and punditry to data collected in the field is too high. Try to find out what's happening in Kabul r
by Animats 5y ago
The trouble with news today is that the ratio of publicity and punditry to data collected in the field is too high.
Try to find out what's happening in Kabul right now. What have we got?
Vast amounts of commentary are available, all resting on a very narrow base of facts. There's a little bit of cell phone video leaking out. Large numbers of people at the airport, out on the tarmac, hanging around planes that aren't going anywhere. Aljazeera has a reporter embedded with the Taliban, and he got a tour of the presidential mansion, showing lots of guys with rifles exploring the place and having meetings.
On the PR side, we have statements from the US State Department that the US embassy has been evacuated, civilian flights out of Kabul have stopped, military flights are continuing, the US has a few thousand troops at the airport, and more troops are coming in. There's a Taliban Twitter feed.[1] "The situation in Kabul is normal".
So what do we really know.?
- General agreement that there was no substantial fighting in Kabul.
- General agreement that the US holds the airport and the Taliban holds most of the rest of the city.
That's about it for hard facts. Yet there's a huge volume of published bullshit on all major media of all persuasions.
[1] https://twitter.com/Zabehulah_M33/status/1427101139481268227 https://twitter.com/Zabehulah_M33/status/1427101139481268227
- Joeri 5y agoI don’t have to watch the coverage to also know they’re not going to talk about the wider context in any useful way. No real insight into why the taliban saw so little opposition, no discussion of how drug money underpins much of their power and what the geopolitical ramifications of that are, no reflection of why the major international governmental bodies are unwilling or unable to go to afghanistan and other places and protect human rights, and how we could reform the system of the world to actually be capable of protecting human rights. In short, all we’re going to get is a lot of poorly informed discussion of what is going on right there right now, which is probably the least important aspect of this whole situation for anyone not actually living there.