4 ms·
If you can capture an asteroid full of palladium or whatever then that's worthwhile even if all you do is take chunks of raw asteroid down to Earth for processi
by lmm 5y ago
If you can capture an asteroid full of palladium or whatever then that's worthwhile even if all you do is take chunks of raw asteroid down to Earth for processing. But then once that's in place then it becomes worth doing some basic refining in orbit so that you're not shipping a bunch of dirt down at thousands of dollars per kilogram, and eventually it becomes worth moving more and more of the manufacturing chain up into orbit for the same reason. That's the most plausible way I can see to bootstrap things.
- dTal 5y agoSurely shipping stuff down is basically free.
- lmm 5y agoPutting stuff on a ballistic reentry is free, but will burn up a certain amount of your material and is very hard to do safely. Maybe China could bring one down in their big desert and not worry too much about whether it hits anyone who lives there, but many nations would balk at that, and it complicates the retrieval. Otherwise the atmosphere helps you somewhat, but you've still got to fit a heatshield and some way to decelerate. The mass limit for parachutes is pretty low, so we're probably talking about a lifting body and some proper engines - maybe air-breathing engines, which are going to be significantly cheaper (especially fuel-wise) than rocket engines but by no means free. Maybe thousands per kilogram is an overstatement, but the cost is significant and there's only so much you can do about it (short of building a space elevator).