3 ms·
> Minimalism is about avoiding excess junk that you don't need This is a very shallow heuristic. “Stuff you’ll need over a lifetime” has a very long tail that
by acituan 5y ago
> Minimalism is about avoiding excess junk that you don't need
This is a very shallow heuristic. “Stuff you’ll need over a lifetime” has a very long tail that requires a balance in trade-off between just-in-time availability vs waiting two days of Amazon shipping; throwing things away once done vs inventorying them at home etc.
Turns out one is particularly shitty for the environment while being revitalizing for the current economy; throw-away-ism is not feasible at the planet scale; there is only so much raw material you can extract and process without paying attention to recyclability, very little of which is factored into pricing.
“The true minimalism” would be a lifestyle change that minimized throw-awayism too, while the popular minimalism is a petite bourgeois fashion that hinges on it.
A good example to this ideal is ISS; it looks cluttered but that's as good as a minimalist space can get when you have to inventory everything you'll need locally and have true constraints on bringing in useless mass of materials onboard.
- jka 5y agoIf the long tail contains many items that are rarely used more than five times in a lifetime, does everyone need to purchase their own? (for some items, perhaps - and communal item libraries don't necessarily solve the waiting-time concern, sure)
- peterbraden 5y agoNo, there’s also the possibility of inheritance.
- packetlost 5y agoI think there's confusion on "minimalism" the aesthetic choice and minimalism the life-style choice. Real minimalism is about reducing foot-print (both spacial and ecological) to just the necessities and things that bring you joy. "Throw-away-ism" is consumerism wearing a minimalism shaped mask, which is ironic because minimalism is at least partially a rejection of consumerism.