3 ms·
> it seems to me like there's been a shift across all sectors (not just journalism) away from professional integrity It starts with the meaning of "professiona
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
> it seems to me like there's been a shift across all sectors (not just journalism) away from professional integrity
It starts with the meaning of "professional". I know of two opposite ones:
1. "Professional" as in doing high quality work, no corner cutting, having respect for the problem and the customer.
2. "Professional" as in putting business first, with the implication that any possible corner will be cut, any possible sacrifice on quality will be made, if it makes the business more money.
The second meaning is what I've been seeing increasingly often over the years. It's a frequent sentiment in our industry - it's professional to keep applying subpar tooling and methods to a problem, because upskilling costs money short-term. It's professional to bloat your product and make your users pay an implicit tax, because it's saving fraction of those costs for the company.
> I don't know if it's because the people who used to care care less, or because the people who never cared are being put in charge (...)
I sometimes wonder if the answer is: none of those, things have always been as shitty - it's you and me who are growing up and discovering the world for what it is (and/or growing more cynical in the process).
- strogonoff 5y agoAs a journalist or a publication, you do need money to survive, and if you don’t survive then how can you make a positive impact with fair reporting? The choice is then between ads, financing, and truly surviving off your subscribers by being so expensive that only the top 1% can afford to read you. Any option compromises you in some way, choose your poison to the extent possible. Despite all that being one huge grey area ethically speaking, I still think that without professional reporting all we’d have is a network of mini-influencers misrepresenting reality into their respective bubbles on Twitter/Substack/TikTok, either for likes or to further whatever hidden agenda they or their friends may have. It’s a good thing to have a job description and years of education that ingrain certain principles[0]. It’s doubly bad, though, when you betray those principles; being a journalist is (or ought to be) much like being a cop or a doctor—for the mechanism to work properly, people should be able to trust you to act in their interest rather than own personal gain (and you should deserve the trust). Unfortunately, I don’t see a good way for such a model to persist. We’re losing trust in traditional affordable mass media, often for good reasons. [0] Most importantly, to be cognisant of your biases—which indeed includes selecting which story to report on, selecting which aspects to mention, etc.—and to compensate for them.
- denton-scratch 5y ago3. "Professional" as in it's your job, and you're being paid to do it. 4. "Professional", as in you work within a profession, such as law or accounting, and are an accredited, paid-up member of the appropriate professional body. I'll buy your (1), as in "professional paint job", but your (2) isn't a kind of professional; that's just race-to-the-bottom commercialism.