4 ms·
> In none of these situations would an ISP connect its customers via IPv6 only or would anyone provide any service that requires IPv6. It's so much cheaper and
by tialaramex 5y ago
> In none of these situations would an ISP connect its customers via IPv6 only or would anyone provide any service that requires IPv6.
It's so much cheaper and faster already today that it makes sense to do v6-only internally and deliver IPv6 to the large fraction of customers who can have IPv6 and deploy a transform layer for the (gradually shrinking) class of have-nots.
Your IPv4-only competitors are spending more money to deliver a worse service. Maybe they'll wake up and realise, but the story of the past couple of decades suggests most such outfits are not too bright and when offered IPv6 on new links they'll smugly decline. Meanwhile you get to keep the difference. Your competitor thinks this service costs 86¢ per dollar revenue and you're only spending 84¢ per dollar revenue that's a lot of extra profitability.
Fighting this is a losing battle, and I imagine that decades from now somebody is going to write a book about how it was cognitively possible for "leaders" to champion an idea that couldn't possibly work, that they intellectually knew couldn't work, and all the actual evidence said wasn't working, and yet they believed in it anyway. Or that book might be about climate change denial, either way.
Eventually by the way - and 90% global is close to and even perhaps at the threshold where that's plausible for some of them - many general ISPs won't bother providing actual IPv4 networking. If you want IPv4 you're a niche customer, go find a bespoke IPv4 Internet Service Provider. If you're IPv6 capable but you want to reach an IPv4 host you'll go via a translation box automatically. As the interest in global IPv4 shrinks, the transit companies will lose interest in that service too, and eventually - decades from now - the IPv4 Internet literally goes away, the RIRs stop "managing" the now largely unused space and the residual pockets of IPv4 cease to interoperate.
- goodpoint 5y ago> It's so much cheaper and faster already today that it makes sense to do v6-only internally Absolutely not. Routers, OSes and applications still have much better support for IPv4 than IPv6. Replacing large routers, fighting bugs and running pure IPv6 on internal networks is very expensive.
- fulafel 5y agoThere haven't been ipv4-only routers sold in such a long time that they've been retired from service by now. v6 was a new router feature something like 15 or 20 years ago (and same for operating systems).
- 2fastpost 5y agoIPv6 support is such a low bar. Now try IPv6 support and feature complete without bugs and get back to me. I’ll wait.
- goodpoint 5y agoAs 2fastpost wrote, basic IPv6 support is far from enough. Also I'm not talking about routers worth 50 euro/$, but DC and carrier grade, worth 500K euro/$
- fulafel 5y agoDo many reasonably recent 500k routers have bad ipv6 support? ISPs and many enterprise sized orgs have been running v6 for a long time, so it's not like it's a checkbox feature that hasn't had a lot of testing.
- goodpoint 5y agoThe question is: Do many reasonably recent 500k routers have more bugs or performance limitations around IPv6 than IPv4? Of course they do. They are hugely complex systems and troubleshooting and tuning is prioritized based on customers needs.
- ipv6_or_nat 5y agoCan we have source to go with the IPv6 is “cheaper and faster” claim? Like actual facts stated in dollars and milliseconds. I’m also going to humor you on the IPv6-only thing. Can you actually point to a single ISP that is even considering IPv6-only?
- tialaramex 5y agoWhat did we read right here on HN recently about IP blocks changing hands for about $40 per address? IPv6 addresses are approximately 100% cheaper than that. But it doesn't stop there, you also no longer need subnet planning -- where under IPv4 it's very important whether this new subnet is 60 machines or 64 machines, in IPv6 you don't care and so nobody needs to manage that. Which translates to lower costs in your network team. Negligible when your "network team" is just the CTO doing a Google search, but significant at scale. Your route costs fall too. Because of exhaustion (and because years ago nobody had any idea what they were doing, not having had an Internet before) IPv4 is now badly fragmented, which means a trivial route ("All the East Coast stuff") may become six or sixteen or sixty separate address blocks, but IPv6 blocks were deliberately assigned so as to reduce fragmentation, chances are "All the East Coast stuff" is one or two blocks. As to speed, Facebook reports IPv6 is about 10% faster for them. They did exactly what I described, they're v6-only internally and have translation at the edge for "legacy" IPv4 clients.
- 2fastpost 5y ago> What did we read right here on HN recently about IP blocks changing hands for about $40 per address? IPv6 addresses are approximately 100% cheaper than that. This is just silly. If you are an ISP then you already have an IPv4 allocation. If you don’t then you join the waiting list and/or apply for a /24. Once you have your allocation, RIR fees are the same regardless of IPv4 or IPv6 allocations. > But it doesn't stop there, you also no longer need subnet planning -- where under IPv4 it's very important whether this new subnet is 60 machines or 64 machines, in IPv6 you don't care and so nobody needs to manage that. Which translates to lower costs in your network team. Negligible when your "network team" is just the CTO doing a Google search, but significant at scale. If you believe this is in any way meaningful then I have a bridge to sell you. > Your route costs fall too. Because of exhaustion (and because years ago nobody had any idea what they were doing, not having had an Internet before) IPv4 is now badly fragmented, which means a trivial route ("All the East Coast stuff") may become six or sixteen or sixty separate address blocks, but IPv6 blocks were deliberately assigned so as to reduce fragmentation, chances are "All the East Coast stuff" is one or two blocks. You can’t buy smaller routers just because you deploy IPv6, so I have no idea what cost saving there are to be had here. > As to speed, Facebook reports IPv6 is about 10% faster for them. I fail to see how this is universally applicable to all ISPs. > They did exactly what I described, they're v6-only internally and have translation at the edge for "legacy" IPv4 clients. Having an IPv6 core is not the same thing as being IPv6-only. Speaking of IPv6-only, you have yet to name even a single ISP that is even considering going IPv6-only. Cat got your tongue?
- TideAd 5y agoI bet the managers who are running IPv4-only places know what's coming, they just hope to get lucky and see it delayed long enough that they get another job someone else is holding the bag.