6 ms·
More Is More: The End of Minimalism
- hirako2000 5y agoBlablabla. More is certainly not more and this article demonstrates it very well. Get to the point, provide value, readers can get hold of millions of novels if they want to read descriptive storie, and with a well crafted plot coming from authors who work on stories.
- meowster 5y agoThe same could be said about many articles posted here. Personally I only read the first few paragraphs before closing the page. Anyway, I upvoted it because it offers something interesting which I was not aware of, and made me curious as to its change. (I didn't downvote you, but I assume it's because the comment doesn't really add anything. The complaint isn't that constructive, and is not aimed at the right people. I think most of the people here can figure out how to read which includes determining it they should continue reading something, and not fall into the sunk-cost fallacy of "I atarted reading this, so I have to finish.")
- cpach 5y agoΜηδὲν ἄγαν https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_mean_(philosophy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_mean_(philosophy)
- pessimizer 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation In the limit, moderation and maximalism are identical. Half of infinity is infinity.
- villasv 5y agoHow can someone write an article like this and don’t include a single picture of how maximalism looks like today?
- FridayoLeary 5y agoMaximalism looks like privately owned rockets to take people to the moon.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agohttps://hommes.studio/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/the-art-of-designing-maximalist-interiors-7.jpg.webp https://hommes.studio/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/the-art-of-...
- lucumo 5y agoThat actually has a certain kind of charm. The patterns fit together well and the accents support the overall feel of the room. This can go awry very fast if done with less care, but then again, so can a minimalist room. Minimalist rooms can quickly start to look like a chipboard warehouse if no care is take to prevent it. Of course, it helps immensely that this room has no "life clutter" in it. Imagine adding a few discarded Amazon boxes waiting to be recycled...
- whytaka 5y agoInteresting for a second but tiring just a moment after. After the appreciation for labour wears off it becomes suffocatingly garish.
- derbOac 5y agoI actually really like the rooms in some of these maximalist photos, but that doesn't mean I'd want to buy the stuff in them, or design my living space that way. I've learned through experience that a lot of it is really appealing in the moment, but some things I change my opinion about relatively quickly, or I'm much more variable in my opinions of. If I know that about something, I don't want to have it. I was with a significant other once who had really similar tastes as me, but we differed a lot in our buying preferences. They were a lot more maximalist, and I was more minimalist. I went along with many their purchases because I did like the stuff after all, and loved them, but I noticed over time we were much more likely to get rid of the items they wanted, the "maximalist" items, and keep the stuff that was more minimalist. It wasn't just because we kept what I wanted either -- they got tired of it and wanted to change it for something else. The minimalist stuff they didn't initially see as exciting or interesting, but they also never got tired of it. Minimalism isn't just about reducing unnecessary stuff in some sort of purity ritual, it's about learning and focusing on what consistently and reliably works for you emotionally and functionally. Simple tends to work well a lot of the time, and even though it's not as fun and novel, it tends to stay loved. In this regard, I think something can be minimalist if it reflects something that will work for you over the long run, that you won't get tired of and will last.
- flir 5y agoSurprising to see a recent article on maximalism that doesn't mention Boris Johnson's adventures in redecorating.
- mx-e 5y agoThe point to real minimalism isn't throwing perfectly good stuff out, but not buying unnecessary stuff in the first place. Everything else is just a fad. So after throwing everything out, people now buy new stuff ? Great trick, great for the planet, slow clap!
- firecall 5y agoFor me, the minimalism aesthetic and the Marie Kongo school of chucking stuff out and not horsing are two different things! You can chick away half your things but your home could still look cluttered and ‘terrible’.
- friseurtermin 5y ago> minimalism: Marie Kondo says that we should remove all the things that "don't spark joy" > maximalism: our homes should be places full of stuff that sparks joy! I'm no expert on interior design but that seems to be the same thing. Minimalism was co-opted by the very consumerism it initially criticized, with corporations telling us that we need more (white, square, lifeless) stuff. If your room only has a ornamental bed your inherited from your great-grandparents and a thrifted wardrobe in it, i would still consider that minimalist
- li2uR3ce 5y agoTBH I never found the obsession over discovering if something brought joy to... spark joy. Once you realize that you'll eventually throw this out too... YOLO?
- fumar 5y agoThis article would benefit from photographic examples. I prefer simple and understated interior architecture. My mind feels better without high clutter but that isn’t to say I need minimalism. Again, without examples, I have a hard time visualizing both extremes.
- joshghent 5y ago> maximalism may be more about filling in a void of loneliness and isolation This quote summarises the true intention - buying stuff makes you happy. We all get a kick out of this but that is not going to provide lasting happiness. As others have pointed out, minimalism isn’t about the number of things you own. And in a way, if you’re “minimalistic” you are also “materialistic” - truly caring about the things you own.
- flyinglizard 5y agoThe things I own enable me to enjoy long lasting and very fulfilling activities. I don’t have any shame in that. Try riding mountain bikes without having a mountain bike, or taking off-road trips without a 4x4 or playing computer games without a graphics card. I enjoy and appreciate my stuff very much.
- galangalalgol 5y agoyou can research the best model of the things you use for those activities and get whatever the new best tech is, or you could go get a used one from someone and fix it up. You can get stuff and still minimize waste. Except for graphics cards, good luck, new or used...
- whytaka 5y agoI care about materials as a minimalist in that I feel burdened by them. Today, I’m donating a bunch of clothes that still fit me but I don’t wear them anymore. It doesn’t even take up much space but I feel like I’m shedding weight.
- nynx 5y agoI know people who buy a lot of stuff that they don’t need and doesn’t make them happier. I’m not sure why people do that — probably a result of advertising.
- wincy 5y agoI’m going insane because my kids are constantly getting toys. Not even from me and my wife, just people. My uncle, their grand uncle keeps coming over with literally moldy toys. He won’t listen to me because he’s dying of cancer and like, what am I gonna do? Tell him he can’t see the kids he loves to dearly? He’s a weird hoarder and I’m not gonna be able to change someone who is dying’s mind about anything. I also just don’t have the willpower to deal with their screaming and crying when I toss toys or donate them. Our youngest daughter is special needs in a wheelchair and can literally die if she gets too upset. Honestly writing this has made me resolve to fill some boxes and donate some stuff to Goodwill. I’ll just have to do it at night when they’re asleep or something. I wish I was as good a parent as I am an engineer.
- remirk 5y ago> I wish I was as good a parent as I am an engineer. From the information in your comment you seem like a great parent to me. Or maybe you are just a good parent, but an exceptionally great engineer ;) You seem to be perfectly aware of things you need to take into consideration. And you have even come to a solution. Sometimes things are just hard, but that doesn't say anything about your parenting abilities.
- beardyw 5y agoHere was me thinking minimalism was a school of art, visual, music, architecture etc. John Cage 4′33″ anyone? Turns out it has become a form of (non) consumerism. The good thing about minimalism is there is a nearby limit - zero. Not so with maximalism.
- bonoboTP 5y agoFad cycles like this will never go away. When a guest comes to visit and they are impressed by the interior, there are several things going on. First, you signal that you know what's the hot new thing, so you are socially connected, regularly visit similar homes. Second you signal loyalty to the tribe by being willing to adjust your living space to ape the hot new trend. Third, you signal financial stability/wealth because you can afford to keep up, to throw away functional stuff every few years. Just as predictable is the sneering and shaming of such behavior, decrying it as shallow etc. by people who can't keep up with this, or dislike the game. Then the most effective way to counter it is to make it about morality, to feel pride in not keeping up etc. But that won't solve anything, the fad may even temporarily follow that: see billionaires dressing in "normcore", rich people feeling kinda embarrassed by being seen rich. However there is still a big difference in Zuckerberg's normcore and the average person wearing cheap clothes. Just as there 8s a huge difference between a rich minimalist and a person whose apartment is almost empty because he can't afford to furnish it properly.
- nomdep 5y agoAre you telling me that are people that live their adult life that they still were in high school? That’s incredibly sad
- bonoboTP 5y agoWelcome to life. Who has more money, better cars, fancier job title, house in a better neighborhood, more academic publications and h index, more attractive partner, more impressive bookshelf, bigger muscles, better vacations etc. Yes people care about such things well after high school. But many won't admit it. Admitting caring about status is itself low status.
- elevenoh 5y ago"Fad cycles like this will never go away. When a guest comes to visit and they are impressed by the interior, there are several things going on. First, you signal that you know what's the hot new thing, so you are socially connected, regularly visit similar homes. Second you signal loyalty to the tribe by being willing to adjust your living space to ape the hot new trend. Third, you signal financial stability/wealth because you can afford to keep up, to throw away functional stuff every few years." Which cities is this most common/prominent in?
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThis is more fun if you pretend it's about CISC vs RISC.
- srswtf123 5y agoThis is an ad, meant to convince you to buy more stuff, its ok everyone is doing it now!! I call BS. Consumer culture is a cancer; best to excise it.
- darkpine 5y agoI agree. The article is practically an ode to consumerism. Much better to find the middle ground of making do with the things we already own, not throwing everything out a la minimalism, or buy buy buy a la maximalism so trumpeted here.
- notafraudster 5y agoThis is a bit of a strange critique. The publication is a long-form literary magazine, kind of like the Canadian Harper's. Neither of the writers is a brand person, they're both independent small scale writers, and if you check their past bylines none of them seem to overlap with the kind of thing you're talking about. No product is linked, this isn't like one of those GQ pieces where they want you to click through and buy the thing. Mostly it's sort of abstract and introspective, about processing feelings, and less about any kind of product. Let's say, hypothetically, that Big Consumer Culture wanted to Give You Permission To Buy Stuff, does it seem like this is the venue and manner they'd use to present this idea? The article discusses coverage of minimalist house makeovers as fueling the minimalism they think is in decline: wouldn't the people trying to push consumer culture use the same coverage of maximalist house makeovers more effectively than a small long-form essay in a Canadian literary magazine? Wouldn't they have a thing they want to sell? Wouldn't there be graphics or pictures or video engagement? Wouldn't it be attached to some kind of promotion? It's sort of hard to unpack the who, what, when, where, how of your pitch here.
- pessimizer 5y agoI don't have any strong opinion on this, but the fact that you're arguing against the idea that all consumer culture got together and decided to exclusively advertise their new plan through this particular article is not an direct or productive reply.
- 5y ago
- xondono 5y agoMinimalism is a weird thing. Pretty much no one would consider my home minimalist, with my whole living room to the brim with lego and spaceship posters and plants and flowers, but I would buy them a new if they weren’t there, and there’s not a single thing in there that doesn’t make me feel better. Like most things in life, “minimalist” it’s just a tag, a label because people like to form tribes.
- whytaka 5y agoI wouldn’t discount it as a mindset. I am a minimalist despite having decorations in my home. And if I’m part of a tribe, I’m pretty sure I’ve been excommunicated because I don’t make friends over this stuff. What I do do tho is just keep things tidy. Dispose or donate things I don’t need anymore. Limit my material purchases to art I appreciate all the time and tools I use all the time. I just feel cleaner spiritually for it.
- anm89 5y agoAre you saying that minimalism is weird because you don't value it? I can't see any other point you are making. To me, being an adult who has to plaster their rooms in printed images of children's toys to have a sense of well being sounds like a version of hell but I don't care much that you do it because I don't have to ever go inside your house. So, I'm happy you like your Lego posters. I don't think many minimalists are too bummed out at the concept that some person somewhere likes a bunch of posters. But it's not much of a critique of minimalism in general.
- raman162 5y agoI feel like this article misses the true point of minimalism. It's not about having monochromatic houses and boring designs (fine if that's what you're into). Minimalism is about avoiding excess junk that you don't need. You can still choose to have multi colored rooms and decor and be someone that adopts minimalism. I agree that our homes should be expression of ourselves but we shouldn't accumulate for the sake of accumulating.
- lucumo 5y agoThese are two different things. There's minimalism as a life philosophy, and there's minimalism as a design style. They go well together, but, as you point out, you can also have one without the other.
- chefandy 5y agoI think you mean sparse or unadorned rather than boring– boring minimalist designs miss the point of minimalism. The idea is to create beauty using the form of the objects themselves and how they interact with their surroundings rather than adding purely decorative elements. A picture of open ocean or desert can be beautiful, entirely unadorned, and a picture of a carnival can be boring as hell. I'd certainly call Gottfried Böhm's Brutalist church sparse or unadorned in contrast to St. Basil's Cathedral, but I'd call it anything but boring. (Personally, I find them both breathtaking.) Same thing with minimalist lives, ideally!
- acituan 5y ago> Minimalism is about avoiding excess junk that you don't need This is a very shallow heuristic. “Stuff you’ll need over a lifetime” has a very long tail that requires a balance in trade-off between just-in-time availability vs waiting two days of Amazon shipping; throwing things away once done vs inventorying them at home etc. Turns out one is particularly shitty for the environment while being revitalizing for the current economy; throw-away-ism is not feasible at the planet scale; there is only so much raw material you can extract and process without paying attention to recyclability, very little of which is factored into pricing. “The true minimalism” would be a lifestyle change that minimized throw-awayism too, while the popular minimalism is a petite bourgeois fashion that hinges on it. A good example to this ideal is ISS; it looks cluttered but that's as good as a minimalist space can get when you have to inventory everything you'll need locally and have true constraints on bringing in useless mass of materials onboard.
- dougmwne 5y agoNot totally sure this belongs on HN, but it was at least informative and well written. It's not at all about philosophy, but about design trends. I was sort of vaguely aware that Scandinavian simplicity was getting long in the tooth and that vintage, humorous, and eclectic was back in. I think it would be interesting to consider if we could end up seeing this reflected in UI and graphic design.
- whytaka 5y agoLots of website designs have featured this genre of “cluttered beauty” for many years already. Personally I hate it. It makes everything so difficult to read. IMO it’s unlikely to be featured in interface design as I’m sure past the branding advantage, it’s just bad for accessibility.
- laurent92 5y agoFirst, there were Windows apps, with menus, entirely browseable by keyboard shortcuts for every menu, contextual help with F1 everywhere, universal and automatic support for Tab, Esc, Enter, speech support, applications were complex and as you grew better at them, you could browse them faster than a clerk buying an airplane ticket on Amadeus (the ancient text interface where each keystroke is a complex command). Then we had apps and webapps. People loved them. They had no keyboard shortcuts, no menus, “tab” didn’t lead anywhere, colors were not uniform, concepts neither, and “usability” meant “fewer functions”. There was no way to write on your resume that you were expert at any of them. And they replaced each other fast. Let’s hope we’ll reinvent advanced user interfaces.
- theonlybutlet 5y agoUmmm no thanks, you can keep your anxiety-inducing clutter.
- haberman 5y ago> Marie Kondo, the decluttering phenom who encouraged millions to “spark joy” by throwing out heaps of perfectly good things, was met with substantial ridicule when she began selling “essentials” like silicone head massagers and $61 paperweights on her website. I think this is a misquote of Marie Kondo. She says to get rid of things that don't spark joy. It's just permission and encouragement to part ways with things that you keep around but never use or enjoy. So the $61 paperweight isn't a contradiction at all, not if it's owner really likes it. Especially if it replaces two other things that they didn't really care about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nus07 5y agoMy brother-in-law and his wife are so called minimalists who moved back east from California. Buying a 5 bedroom 750k house wasn’t minimalist to start with .But they had to go car free and so needed to be in a walkable and hip part of the city.Then they had a kid and kept asking me and my wife as well as my parents for favors and stuff just so they didn’t have to buy or do things. Meanwhile scoffing at me and my wife for thrift shopping since we were buying stuff we needed. I am sorry but minimalism is re-using and not wasting stuff as much as you can . Collecting experiences by traveling every weekend contributes hugely to pollution by airlines . A 750k open design house , going car-less, not buying a used lawnmower but paying someone to mow your lawn is extreme American privilege and a fad . Minimalism is doing with what you have and trying to recycle and re-use and right to repair .
- Zababa 5y agoSomething that's not mentionned: one of the nice thing with what we usually associate with minimalist spaces is that they are very easy to clean. Maximalist spaces are the opposite. Maybe that's not a concern for some people, but for me it weighs a lot in how I organize my space.
- coldtea 5y ago>Marie Kondo's decluttering dominance is over. Make way for maximalism, where the more stuff, the merrier Apparently the dominance of fluff journalistic pieces, describing meaningless trends nobody really cares about [1], however, is not over... [1] Both Kondo's method and minimalism is a 5%-of-the-population endeavor at most, mostly for Bo-Hos and the top/upper middle class those journalists belong or try to get to.