4 ms·
Strict consistent hierarchical classification is ultimately impossible. It's used in domains where access is based on physical location (as with libraries), th
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Strict consistent hierarchical classification is ultimately impossible.
It's used in domains where access is based on physical location (as with libraries), though there are numerous alternatives to subject-based grouping used (especially with closed stacks).
If you ever want to see librarians in a heated discussion, tell them of your plans to develop a consistent hierarchical topical classification scheme.
That said: there are useful classifications. None are perfect, serve all needs, please all parties, or are fully consistent. But most are better than a haphazard mess.
- mdoms 5y agoYour comment could not be more irrelevant. OP said "websites were organized according to a hierarchy" - a hierarchy, not THE hierarchy.
- dredmorbius 5y agoTry it sometime. You'll find that: 1. It's harder than it looks. 1. The hierarchy is stubbornly inconsistent. Take the example of MP3s, or more generally, audio files vs. text vs. images vs. multimedia. Do you classify all audio indepednetly of any text, regardless of whether it's, say, a history of WWII in the Czechoslovakia? Is a historical study of military technology used in Czechoslovaki during WWII filed under history (WWII), geography (Czechoslovakia), technology (military), or military science (technology)? What happens when countries change or borders shift (Holy Roman Empire -> Austria-Hungary -> Czechoslovakia -> Czechia)? Or when a region is disputed (West Bank, Taiwan, Kashmir, Oregon Teritory, Malvinas, ...)? Is Ireland part of the British Isles? Is it "mythology", "fiction", "religion", "theology", "philosophy", "cult", or "mass delusion"? Even if it's a single person's classification, conflicts rapidly emerge. Increase the number of catologers, or add multiple readers/users, and you'll start getting complaints and exceptionally strong disagreements. I'm not opposed to the practice. I've attempted it myself numerous times. I'm working on several approaches presently.
- causality0 5y agoDude I just want content to be preserved in an organized way instead of a stream of consciousness where anything that isn't on the front page disappears into the void forever.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI get that. How about tag-based systems as an alternative to a hierarchical one? The tags can be presented as a hierarchy, if you like. Or better, as several different hierarchies, or perhaps alternatively, as a web or space with multiple entry points. Depending on how you slice it (and where that slice begins and ends) you'll end up with different organisations, though each will have at least some internal consistency.
- jhgb 5y agoThat's essentially a DAG, isn't it?
- dredmorbius 5y agoNo. The hierarchical ontology is a DAG. It's got a root, it propagates from the root to leaf nodes, and there is no recursion. A fully tag-based system is neither directed nor acyclic. My view is that the better ones appear as DAGs withiin a localised area, but that constraint falls at a broader level. The main problem with tag-based systems is that they tend strongly to be "folksonomies", where terms are not controlled and there can be multiple variants of spelling, naming, etc., often reflecting both personal, geographic, and temporal preferences / ideosyncracies. That's where a controlled vocabulary or defined set of relationships / associations (perhaps probabalistic) helps. E.g., "Yerba Buena" -> "San Francisco", "Frisco" -> "San Francisco". The Library of Congress Classification and Subject Headings make for an interesting study. They're quite extensive and have evolved over more than a century. They have their own inconsistencies, ideosyncracies, and controversies. Part of their strength is the surrounding infrastructure establsihed to support and address these. There are of course other classifications.