3 ms·
It's very hard to come up with genuine instances of software patents protecting small developers from larger competitors. The little guy usually can't afford th
by chc 15y ago
It's very hard to come up with genuine instances of software patents protecting small developers from larger competitors. The little guy usually can't afford the money and time to patent things, much less enforce them. But even disregarding that, assuming your patent isn't overly broad (in which case it should definitely not be valid), your competitors can just work around it and then steamroll you with their money and strong development teams.
Essentially, a competitor that could steamroll you without a patent would be able to steamroll you with a patent.
The one case I can think of where it would be reasonable for a patent to protect you is if a company offers to buy your product, looks at the code, and then has its developers create a knock-off based on your code. And even then copyright law is probably sufficient (analogous situations arise in other industries where copyright is the only law).
- justinsb 15y agoStac Electronics is an example of Microsoft doing exactly what you described; it was patent - not copyright - law that allowed Stac to collect damages.
- chc 15y agoIt was under patent law that they happened to file this suit, but similar copyright suits have been filed (this is why movie studios don't accept spec scripts and a prominent game developer deleted his Twitter account). And it's still pretty rare.
- brlewis 15y agoWhen chc mentioned "The little guy usually can't afford the money and time to patent things, much less enforce them", I assumed (s)he wasn't talking about little guys like Stac Electronics, a publicly traded company for whom a $9.7 million sales quarter was evidence of declining business. http://articles.latimes.com/1994-06-22/business/fi-7159_1_patent-dispute http://articles.latimes.com/1994-06-22/business/fi-7159_1_pa...