4 ms·
This jives in interesting ways with Southeast Asian folklore, which has held since time immemorial that semi-mythical divine beings called "Lemurians" were the
by zozbot234 5y ago
This jives in interesting ways with Southeast Asian folklore, which has held since time immemorial that semi-mythical divine beings called "Lemurians" were the true ancestors of modern-day humans, and the bringers of civilization and culture to that part of the world. Could it be that ancient Denisovans were in fact the Lemurians of popular lore?
- frutiger 5y agoWouldn’t it be the other way: Sapiens would be the semi-divine beings bringing civilisation to the local Denisovans?
- taylorfinley 5y agoThat framing gets my anti-colonialist emotions stirring. I guess it depends which myth you're more likely to subscribe to, the 'white savior' or the 'noble savage' (please don't mistake this post for advocating those tropes) Edit: Getting downvoted to hell because people are so sensitive and think I'm implying early homo sapiens were light-skinned. That's silly and I probably should have just not posted anything in a conversation like this where everyone is looking to be offended. That said I'm leaving this here for context.
- inglor_cz 5y agoIt is well possible that Sapiens were black and Denisovans white.
- jhgb 5y agoIt's completely irrelevant since those notions didn't even exist back then.
- Acrobatic_Road 5y agoGiven that denisovans evolved in asia, I don't see why they wouldn't have had lighter skin.
- frutiger 5y agoYeah the Sapiens arriving into the Philippines were almost certainly dark skinned. You might want to check your biases.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- taylorfinley 5y agoThat's so blatantly obvious I didn't even think to explain that I was attempting to draw a parallel between homo sapiens thinking homo sapiens are the 'civilizing force' and europeans thinking europeans are the 'civilizing force' Edit: for context, I am from Hawaii and as such deeply interested in the Polynesian migrations. I have taken anthropology courses on human migration patterns across the Pacific. I would laugh at anyone who suggested the early homo sapiens migrations were light-skinned.
- decremental 5y agoI read threads like this and just think "I no longer have any connection to this world."
- thatguy0900 5y agoMore like we no longer have any connection with people who spend too long getting polarized by the internet. Go to the area in question and ask people their thoughts on how their creation myths tie into sapians, denisovians, and colonialization. I would assume you'd get alot of confused stares.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- s5300 5y agoYou're in a place with some of the most neurodivergent people, often on the Autism/Asperger's spectrum (myself included), who also feel the need to be dwelling/posting on an online forum such as this. That said, discussions will often get exceedingly hard to understand or relate to, especially on any "normal" emotional level... Don't think anything going on here is much related to the world we live in as a whole. It's like, a representation well under 0.25% Go outside, talk with normal people if you've had a little bit much HN
- pram 5y agoMaybe applying contemporary ideology to legendary prehistory events that happened 30,000 years ago is boldly moronic. Makes you think.
- taylorfinley 5y agoClearly I need to break this down in to very simple terms, since people think they understand my post and clearly don't and are labeling me 'bodly moronic' because of their own misunderstanding. One person speculated that a mythical story might be evidenced by this finding, that the Denisovans might have been the civilizing divines spoken of in legend. Another person said, wouldn't it be the Sapiens that were divine? I called out my own anti-colonial bias, recognizing that my frame has me inclined to believe the first framing ('denisovians were the divines in the legend'), and then speculated that there's a spectrum of opinions one could have and which group you label 'divine and civilizing' and the other 'not-divine and un-civilized' depends on your own biases. But go on and downvote me and call me names because you've misunderstood my point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- garmaine 5y agoYou are getting down-voted because you are posting a knee-jerk emotional response. The poster you are originally replying to isn’t making any kind of comparison to European colonialism, you are. Then you are getting upset at your own comparison. That is not productive. For the record I interpreted the original post as saying “the legend speaks of another race coming and bringing civilization. Since the timeline is such that the denisovans were there first and the sapians came after, wouldn’t it make more sense that this is a legend told by the denisovans about sapians?”
- wolverine876 5y ago> you are posting a knee-jerk emotional response You have no idea what their emotions are. Please don't go there. If something doesn't make sense to you, just ask.
- ertian 5y agoHe explicitly says that the 'framing' gets his emotions stirring.
- tomjakubowski 5y agoNo. The time Sapiens and Denisovans would have gotten together was well before any humans had developed agriculture or civilization. Neanderthals were also in the mix in Southeast Asia.
- prox 5y agoLemurian is a theosophic invention afaik, so not really an ancient myth.
- vmh1928 5y agoThe Leprechauns of South East Asia. So what does that make the Leprechauns of Ireland? A remnant of Denisovans that fled west?
- tomjakubowski 5y agoI thought that Lemuria/Lemurians was a hypothesis developed by Europeans in the 19th century. Wikipedia doesn't mention anything about its presence in traditional folklore. Is there a similar myth indigenous to Southeast Asia that you might have mixed up with Lemuria? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemuria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemuria
- screye 5y agowould be hilarious if Hanuman was a denisovan.
- fsckboy 5y agoquoting from https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/jibe https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/jibe "Jive" and "jibe" have been used interchangeably in the US to indicate the concept "to agree or accord." While one recent dictionary accepts this usage of "jive," most sources consider it to be in error.
- int_19h 5y agoMy favorite bit of folklore along those lines is that of the Hadza: "One telling of Hadza's oral history divides their past into four epochs, each inhabited by a different culture. According to this tradition, in the beginning of time the world was inhabited by hairy giants called the akakaanebee "first ones" or geranebee "ancient ones". The akakaanebee did not possess tools or fire; they hunted game by running it down until it fell dead; they ate the meat raw. They did not build houses but slept under trees, as the Hadza do today in the dry season. In older versions of this story, fire was not used because it was physically impossible in the earth's primeval state, while younger Hadza, who have been to school, say that the akakaanebee simply did not know how. In the second epoch, the akakaanebee were succeeded by the xhaaxhaanebee "in-between ones", equally gigantic but without hair. Fire could be made and used to cook meat, but animals had grown more wary of humans and had to be chased and hunted with dogs. The xhaaxhaanebee were the first people to use medicines and charms to protect themselves from enemies and initiated the epeme rite. They lived in caves. The third epoch was inhabited by the people of hamakwanebee "recent days", who were smaller than their predecessors. They invented bows and arrows, and containers for cooking, and mastered the use of fire. They also built huts like those of Hadza today. The people of hamakwabee were the first of the Hadza ancestors to have contact with non-foraging people, with whom they traded for iron to make knives and arrowheads. They also invented the gambling game lukuchuko. The fourth epoch continues today and is inhabited by the hamayishonebee "those of today". When discussing the hamayishonebee epoch, people often mention specific names and places, and can approximately say how many generations ago events occurred." [1] There are some obvious parallels here with our modern scientific understanding of human evolution. If it's not just a coincidence, we're talking about an oral tradition that is tens of thousands of years old at least. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadza_people#Religion,_myths,_and_tales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadza_people#Religion,_myths,_...