3 ms·
> For instance, the "it only scans photos uploaded to iCloud" element isn't just an arbitrary limitation that can be flipped with one line of code, as some folk
by XorNot 5y ago
> For instance, the "it only scans photos uploaded to iCloud" element isn't just an arbitrary limitation that can be flipped with one line of code, as some folks seem to think; as Erik Neuenschwander, head of Privacy Engineering at Apple, explained in an interview on TechCrunch[1]:
>> Our system involves both an on-device component where the voucher is created, but nothing is learned, and a server-side component, which is where that voucher is sent along with data coming to Apple service and processed across the account to learn if there are collections of illegal CSAM. That means that it is a service feature.
The first paragraph does not follow from the detail in the second at all. Setting aside how abstract the language is, what about adding more complexity to the system is preventing Apple from scanning other content?
This is all a misdirect: they're saying "look at how complex this system is!" and pretending that, particularly when they built and control the entire system including it's existence, that any of that makes changing how it operates "difficult".
- chipotle_coyote 5y agoThe system isn't entirely on-device, but relies on uploading data to Apple's servers. Hence, why I said that it's not an arbitrary limitation that it only scans photos uploaded to iCloud. The system literally has to upload enough images with triggering "safety vouchers" to Apple to pass the reporting threshold, and critical parts of that calculation are happening on the server side. I think what you're arguing is that Apple could still change what's being scanned for, and, well, yes: but that doesn't really affect my original point, which is that this is a policy/legal issue. If you assume governments are bad actors, then yes, they could pressure Apple to change this technology to scan for other things -- but if this technology didn't exist, they could just as easily pressure Apple to do it all on the servers. I think a lot of the anger comes from they shouldn't be able to do any part of this work on my device, and emotionally, I get that -- but technologically, it's hard for me not to shake the impression that "what amount happens on device vs. what amount happens on server" is a form of bikeshedding.
- brokenmachine 5y ago>"what amount happens on device vs. what amount happens on server" is a form of bikeshedding There's a massive difference between a search carried out on a device someone "owns" and carries with them at all times, and a server owned by someone else. To claim otherwise is absurd. Hence all this backlash.