3 ms·
> Third, evidence shows anti-intellectualism is connected to populism, a worldview that sees political conflict as primarily between ordinary citizens and a pri
by rayiner 5y ago
> Third, evidence shows anti-intellectualism is connected to populism, a worldview that sees political conflict as primarily between ordinary citizens and a privileged societal elite. Exposure to randomly assigned populist rhetoric, even that which does not pertain to experts directly, primes anti-intellectual predispositions among respondents in the processing of expert consensus cues.
The formulation of "populism" here reveals something critical. Populism has always existed ever since there has been an elite. What's new, in the U.S., is that scientific institutions are perceived as being part of that "privileged societal elite."
It's obvious why this is happening: governance is becoming more technocratic. Before, policies were justified by reference to values or power struggles. Increasingly, they're being justified by reference to "experts" and "science." There is more and more of a sentiment that scientists aren't just doing science, they're playing a key role in elite governance of the masses.
Ultimately, this is bad for science and scientific institutions, and it's in the interest of scientists and experts to fight these trends. Too often, experts allow politicians to hide behind them to avoid making political decisions, or allow political decisions to be framed as scientific ones.
A scientist can, e.g., explain how a mask mandate will affect propagation of a disease. But it must be a politician that synthesizes that information with other information, weighs the political considerations, and decides to impose mask mandates. When a Governor says "I'm imposing a mask mandate because that's what the scientists say" they're actually throwing scientists under a bus. They're being made accountable in the public eye for a judgment call that's not really their's to make, and collateral consequences they have no control over. E.g. if the cops are abusive in enforcing the mandate, backlash will flow back to the scientists because they've been made the figurehead of the whole endeavor.
It doesn't help that the banner of "science" is being applied to social studies that have nothing to do with science. But those social studies theories are being invoked as if they had the credibility of science, in the context of debates that are fundamentally political in nature.