4 ms·
> My personal experience was finding an article that talked about something I was directly involved in, and it was clearly wrong. Snopes can only go by what ot
by teddyh 5y ago
> My personal experience was finding an article that talked about something I was directly involved in, and it was clearly wrong.
Snopes can only go by what other sources have written, since they weren’t there. If you have direct personal experience, it’s certainly likely that your view will differ from the one reported by Snopes, for two reasons: Firstly, your view is by definition limited and personal, and is likely skewed one way or the other. But secondly, all journalists who write about something have similar incentives (i.e. to write an interesting ‘story’), and will therefore likely all choose a similar narrative based on a similar starting point.
I should note that Wikipedia has the exact same problem, since Wikipedia must limit itself to secondary sources.
- TeeMassive 5y ago> Snopes can only go by what other sources have written Or they could do basic journalism: directly contact sources or seek access to first hand material and do cross-refence. It used to be the standard back in the days to have at least three independent sources before publishing a story.
- teddyh 5y agoIf they did that, they would have no references to back up their claims. This is why Wikipedia does what it does; they need to be able to reference every claim.
- meragrin_ 5y ago> Snopes can only go by what other sources have written, since they weren’t there. I have supplied information to correct articles. They were never updated. This information was easy to come by. One in particular involved timelines/history of bills in the US Congress which they were very wrong about. All you have to do is go to Congress's website and look up the history. The "fact checker" could not even bother to do this. They had a narrative to push and the were going to push it. Snopes is garbage for anything political.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 5y agoOK, but that’s a bit vague. Do you have the links to the incorrect Snopes story and links to the articles with correct information?