3 ms·
> In "The Coddling of the American Mind" they cite studies showing that universities are more left-leaning than they've ever been. What do they mean by 'left-l
by wolverine876 5y ago
> In "The Coddling of the American Mind" they cite studies showing that universities are more left-leaning than they've ever been.
What do they mean by 'left-leaning'?: My professors might have been left-leaning, but I rarely knew their politics. The question is what the students are learning.
Also, conservatives have moved far rightward, which might make others relatively more leftish.
Also, reactionaries politicize lots of things, such as climate change. Education and research isn't affirmative action for conservatives - they need to prove their ideas. Climate change denial lacks the science behind it; it shouldn't be taught. That doesn't make climate change education biased toward liberals.
How does the book address those issues? Also, why do you trust that book (an honest question - I haven't heard of it)?
- bopbeepboop 5y ago> Climate change denial lacks the science behind it; it shouldn't be taught. That doesn't make climate change education biased toward liberals. To paraphrase: “Our institution doesn’t believe this so our institution shouldn’t teach this!” Also, you’re making a false dichotomy: it’s possible that both conservatives and liberals misrepresent climate change. “Climate change education” often doesn’t have science behind it either — it’s fanciful projections from the most shocking numbers they found in an actual report, made into sausage through the citation grinder. That climate change denial shouldn’t be taught is also why the fanciful, extreme left wing form of “climate change education” we see in universities shouldn’t be taught. Teaching that fanciful view in universities is liberal bias, even if teaching denialism would also be wrong.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> Also, conservatives have moved far rightward, which might make others relatively more leftish. I don't think this is true, I think the left-wing media has fixated increasingly on the far-right or exaggerating the extent to which individuals on the right are "far-right" which gives the impression that the right is drifting, but it's just the media changing how it represents the right. To be clear, the right is changing, but it's not perceptibly drifting to the right. > Also, reactionaries politicize lots of things, such as climate change. Education and research isn't affirmative action for conservatives - they need to prove their ideas. Climate change denial lacks the science behind it; it shouldn't be taught. That doesn't make climate change education biased toward liberals. 2 things: 1. We don't even need to invoke conservative beliefs (certainly we don't need to cherry-pick the most overtly anti-science of conservative beliefs), we can look at moderate liberal beliefs, like colorblind approaches to combatting racism which are equally vilified and actively suppressed. 2. If we're talking about "ideas competing in some marketplace" then why are the left so frequently resorting to cancellation of intellectuals rather than debate? E.g., consider all of the petitions to have professors fired or to have papers deleted from journals. And I'm not talking about dumb kids circulating petitions to have their professors fired, but university faculty circulating petitions to have their colleagues fired for ideological (not factual) transgressions. But every time we talk about this, left-wing folks pretend that the debate is whether or not to allow creationism or climate denial in the classroom. This seems transparently disingenuous to me.
- ethbr0 5y agoI would summarize the drift as far-right voices are getting louder (in terms of air time / reach) and centrist-right voices are getting quieter. On the left, far-left voices are also getting louder, but I don't think the centrist-left voices have gotten quieter as much as their centrist-right counterparts. The end result is that "the right" seems more right (in terms of speech) while "the left" seems... conflicted (in terms of speech). Even if that's masking the underlying counts and beliefs.
- wolverine876 5y agoRight-wing support for Trump and his far right policies dominates the GOP. Moderate or even conservative Republicans, who even say that the election was legitimate, are cast out and can't win primaries.
- Stupulous 5y agoIf a journalistic institution's goal is to advocate for a side, they are motivated to report on when the other side is doing something radical and not when they're doing something sensible. The opposite for the side you're supporting. I don't know if it's more or less charitable to suggest that they're primarily driven by revenue. The incentives are basically the same in that model, except the lean is audience-generated rather than centrally controlled. You'd expect more extreme positions on both sides, which is consistent with what you're saying. A combination of both best fits the evidence, I think. You write controversial articles about both sides to get clicks, and write about the center of your side to get political support. So you get people on both sides with very skewed views (the far) of the other, and who think of their own side as idealogically diverse (the far) but grounded in reality (the center). If the media landscape is primarily liberal, you'd expect it to look the way you're describing it. I really like that conclusion, because it's perfectly consistent with my experience. I don't really have evidence to support this, though, and I'm not sure how to go about getting any.
- ethbr0 5y agoThat's a great perspective, and seems both logically consistent and supported by current reality. The "your centrist, but no other" political motivation (even if not economic) is a piece I missed.