43 ms·
I still don't understand the entire premise here. Who cares if a driver can deliberately defeat these things? That's not the threat model! A driver nag is an
by ajross 5y ago
I still don't understand the entire premise here. Who cares if a driver can deliberately defeat these things? That's not the threat model!
A driver nag is an attentiveness reminder. You're driving a car. You're expected to be paying attention. No one else is responsible for safety. So the car wants (for both safety and liability reasons) to make sure you're doing what you're supposed to do. And it works. The car nags me and I tug the wheel to prove I'm there. Most of the time I'm paying attention anyway, but sometimes it's because I got distracted. It works.
If a driver deliberately wants to behave unsafely, there's no way to stop that, because there's an infinite number of ways drivers can behave unsafely. Do we want a system to detect when drivers speed up on yellow? Tesla could absolutely implement that. Why aren't we demanding it? Prevent drivers from approaching cars in adjacent lanes with higher than a 30mph speed delta? Could do that too.
Prevent accelerating in the wrong direction on a road?
Possible.
But no, all that stuff would be dumb, because it doesn't correspond to an actual safety problem with the hardware. We recognize it's driver behavior at fault, and we don't want our cars regulating behavior.
Why is this different?
I submit it's different because "Actually Elon Musk is an Asshole and TSLA went to the moon". Which isn't a very good premise for automobile safety designs.
- mattmcknight 5y ago> I still don't understand the entire premise here. It's because the premise is so weak. I can put a brick on the gas pedal, so no car is safe!
- thereisnospork 5y agoDon't say that too loudly, carpets became just such a Boogeyman not long ago
- haberman 5y agoNot to mention cruise control has the same "vulnerability": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1q0FihkTfk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1q0FihkTfk Is there any evidence that drivers are abusing Autopilot etc. any more than cruise control and causing a higher rate of accidents due to inattentiveness? I was especially disappointed in Consumer Reports, which insinuated that these methods of "fooling" Autopilot were somehow connected to a fatal crash in Texas. https://www.consumerreports.org/autonomous-driving/cr-engineers-show-tesla-will-drive-with-no-one-in-drivers-seat/ https://www.consumerreports.org/autonomous-driving/cr-engine... You have to get 11 paragraphs in before you get to this: > Our evaluation does not provide specific insight into the Texas crash, but safety advocates and researchers at CR say that it does show that driver monitoring systems need to work harder to keep drivers from using the systems in foreseeably dangerous ways. By this standard, cruise control should never have launched in any vehicle until technology was capable of verifying driver attentiveness with eye tracking.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Who cares if a driver can deliberately defeat these things? That's not the threat model! Faking a "malfunction" and then suing could be part of the threat model to the car maker and/or the insurance companies that provide liability coverage.
- theshrike79 5y agoPriuses had a bunch of fake "stuck accelerator" incidents a while ago.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Why is this different? Because the big shiny text that people pay $10,000 for says "Autopilot". Between the name and the large price tag, it conveys that it's higher than L2 autonomy. Putting in the fine print that it's not, doesn't change things.
- lostsock 5y agoYou don't pay an extra $10,000 for autopilot, that's the amount for Full Self Driving
- HWR_14 5y agoError in what I called it. The point not only holds up replacing Autopilot with Full Self Driving, but is actually strengthened.
- frumper 5y agoWho buys Full Self Driving for 10k and thinks you can’t pay attention? The only people I ever see say that are people that don’t have it.
- ajross 5y agoWhich is the most ridiculously meta argument. I have people all over the internet (amusingly never in real life) tell me to my virtual face that I clearly don't understand the product that I paid ten thousand dollars to buy, and that it doesn't do what I know damn well it does. But I do, I did, and it does. So there.
- froh 5y agoI dont get it. do you confirm the argument that buyers of tesla autopilot understand its an advanced driver assist system which at this time requires drivers attention? or you do not? asking becuase the message yours responds to says exactly that: people whoy actually buy autopilot do know very well that it is a system that requests and sometimes even requires driver's attention. so if you confirm that, then how is a meta argument, ridiculously so?
- sorokod 5y agoWho cares if a driver can deliberately defeat these things? This is really to do with the expectations. Consider the safety belt, there is an expectation that with the safety belt on, the driver will not go through the windscreen in case of an accident. It is not the case that the driver has defeated the seat belt feature by not using the seat belt. A reasonable person will not have the expectation of having the safety provided by seatbelt without put it on. Things are not as clear cut for assisted driving as can be seen in this thread.