4 ms·
Remember when they were wringing their hands as they hemmed and hawed ("oh, gosh, we do host a bunch of other garbage, how do we word this?") about removing con
by mc32 5y ago
Remember when they were wringing their hands as they hemmed and hawed ("oh, gosh, we do host a bunch of other garbage, how do we word this?") about removing content by a certain ex-politician they loathed. It took them a while to work up the nerve to censor the then president of the US.
Then, it was the ex-president's allies and they established rules about what was and wasn't acceptable in public discourse. What would be truth and fiction. What was conspiracy and truth. What was Covid truth and not (disregarding the often contradicting policies from WHO and CDC)
And everyone on one side f the aisle was like, yeah! Get 'im! Damned liar(s)! It's their platform, they can do what they want. It's not the government so it's not censorship. They only censor bigots.
And how do they treat things in Thailand, Hong Kong or Myanmar, who is the official government and who is the insurrectionist, who is truth and who is usurper?
Well, here we are, very much closer to the plateauing/basining(?) of the slippery slope as we find ourselves at the bottom --with the willful approval of a great proportion of the population because, you know, slippery slopes are fallacies.
- krapp 5y ago>Remember when they were wringing their hands as they hemmed and hawed about removing content by a certain ex-politician they loathed. It took them a while to work up the nerve to censor the then president of the US. No? Donald Trump's official Youtube channel is still up and running[0]. And you seriously think the only reason other social media platforms didn't ban Trump for four years is that they needed to "work up the nerve?" Not because he went a little unhinged and started ranting conspiracy theories and undermining the integrity of the election? [0]https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAql2DyGU2un1Ei2nMYsqOA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAql2DyGU2un1Ei2nMYsqOA
- mc32 5y agoThat was one example everyone knows about. Talk about Ivermectin, or previously, WIV lab release hypothesis... all censored at the time. (now they have allowed some discussion again, but the damage is done and agenda realized).
- krapp 5y agoWhat damage was done, and what agenda realized? I thought censorship alone was the agenda.
- notheretoo 5y agowhat do you mean “what damage was done”?
- krapp 5y agomc32 claimed damage was done, and I'm asking for clarification as to what specifically that damage was.
- notheretoo 5y agoIvermectin? Actual studies now prove it effective. YouTube banned people for talking about it and people died because of it. How’s that? There are too many one sentence questions on these issues of censorship. I would say they provide no value to the conversation.
- krapp 5y ago>Ivermectin? Actual studies now prove it effective. YouTube banned people for talking about it and people died because of it. How’s that? I haven't seen the studies you're talking about, but the FDA claims Ivermectin hasn't yet been proven effective, and the WHO says it should only be used in clinical trials. But assuming for the same of argument you're correct, your claim is that the only available source of knowledge about Ivermectin anywhere would have been videos which were deleted from Youtube, making it impossible for anyone to avail themselves of this miracle cure due to Youtube's "censorship", and that there are people who avoided taking any of the other existing and effective COVID vaccines and who died of COVID as a result, and that Youtube is therefore to blame. That's pure speculation based on an already far-fetched premise.
- snet0 5y ago
- hoppyhoppy2 5y agoI think they were referring to the removal, almost a week after January 6th, of Trump videos and the suspension of uploads to his YouTube account. It looks like the newest videos on there are from 7 months ago. YouTube deletes Trump video and suspends new uploads: A new video on the president’s account violated YouTube policy on inciting violence. https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2021/1/12/22218757/youtube-trump-account-video-deleted-uploads-suspension-indefinite https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2021/1/12/22218757/you...
- krapp 5y agoEither way, Youtube didn't ban him, which contradicts the premise that they were just looking for an excuse to ban him because they loathed him. If that were the case, his content wouldn't exist on the platform anywhere. It doesn't seem like much of a slippery slope if it goes down then comes back up again.
- josephcsible 5y agoHow has it came back up again? Are you saying that some social media site that banned Trump has since unbanned him?
- serf 5y ago>It doesn't seem like much of a slippery slope if it goes down then comes back up again. once a precedent is set, a transient acceptance of the action is established as a prior act. you don't re-cork that genie, that's the whole idea of the slippery slope argument. forever-more when YouTube considers an action towards something it can always now be said .. "Well in the case of X we did Y." The 'slippery slope' isn't referring to the actions committed themselves, it's referring to a pattern of acceptance and renormalization that occurs after which biases the decision-making group into further actions of a similar vein.
- Serenacula 5y agoI do feel compelled to point out that the slippery slope argument is in fact a type of fallacy. Like, if you look up a list of fallacies there it is, the "slippery slope argument".
- poopypoopington 5y agoHe tried to stage a coup, using their platforms. This was after he broke Facebook, Google and Twitter's TOS countless times. Stop trying to shift the goal posts to suit your argument.
- mc32 5y agoYou're looking at one person --that's the problem. People only see things in front of them. This affects more than one person (this was entirely predictable). He was the excuse. That is all. Now that they got "permission" to suppress ideas as they wish, they, surprise! They are.
- TrumpRapedWomen 5y agoTrump absolutely should have been banned from Twitter far sooner than he was. Thousands of people have been banned for far lesser things.
- rualca 5y ago> You're looking at one person --that's the problem. People only see things in front of them. It wasn't a single person. It was the vast majority of a political party, involving people in government, military, law enforcement, and useful idiots required to fill in a mob.
- TrumpRapedWomen 5y agoIt is very disingenuous to ignore WHY Trump was banned from Twitter and YouTube. He violated their policies over and over and used them to incite a riot at the US capitol. He should have been banned a very long time ago.
- mc32 5y agoThey had a policy not to interfere with speech of heads of state (and other lesser officials) regardless of what they said (see Iranian pols and ISIS sympathizers prior to them taking steps to address the latter). They also allowed others on their platform to say more incendiary things without censoring them. But all this was perfect for them. They were in need of a reason to shape their content more and control discourse. So congrats on that. We now have a system which controls policies and yet suffers bullying every day --but never mind that, at least we got the bad liars we don't like off the platform.
- TrumpRapedWomen 5y agoTrump violated the Twitter terms of service hundreds of times. I am shocked at how much support a very harmful moron like Trump gets on Hacker News.
- rualca 5y ago> And everyone on one side f the aisle was like, yeah! Get 'im! Damned liar(s)! It's their platform, they can do what they want. It's not the government so it's not censorship. They only censor bigots. I'm not from the US thus I have no dog in the race, but even I am fully aware that the rhetoric regarding "it's their platform, they can do what they want" is a very specific realization of the much broader and weaponized argument of "it's their business, they can do what they want" that has been used extensively for years by the political party that supported the incumbent candidate. The "it's their business, they can do what they want" is an argument used extensicely to whitewash the attack and persecution of minorities and political rivals, as is epitome by the infamous "gay wedding cakes" meme. So ultimately what this argument illustrates is that there is a political and ideological movement in the US which is adamant in demanding they should be immune to the rules they actively force upon others. Up until that moment, the incumbent's party was very adamant on the concept of arbitrarily denying access to goods and services to what they perceive as political and ideological reactionaries. That sentiment suddenly shifted once the consequences also applied to them.