3 ms·
"The hypothesis that I have is that Apple wishes to distance itself from checking users' data. They've been fighting with the FBI and the federal government for
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"The hypothesis that I have is that Apple wishes to distance itself from checking users' data. They've been fighting with the FBI and the federal government for years, they've been struggling with not reporting CSAM content to the NCMEC, they don't want to be involved in any of this anymore."
However there is close to zero evidence to support this idea. I was just reading something the other day that directly contradicted this; it suggested the relationship has been excellent save for a single, well-publicised dispute over unlocking an iPhone. In other words, the publicly aired dispute was an anomaly, not representative of the underlying relationship.
Even more, unless the pontificator works for Apple or the government, she is not a good position to summarise the relationship. Plainly put, it is not public information.
What does such baseless speculation achieve. Is it like spreading a meme. I dont get it.
"The worst part is: how do I put my money where my mouth is? Am I going back to using Linux on the desktop (2022 will be the year of Linux on the desktop, remember), debugging wifi drivers and tirelessly trying to make resume-from-suspend work? Am I getting a Pixel and putting GrapheneOS on it like a total nerd? FUCK."
Is having a computer with closed source wifi drivers and proper ACPI support more important than having a computer with an open OS that does not include an intentional backdoor.
Maybe the problem is not how to put your money where your mouth is, its how to put your mouth where your money is. What does GrapheneOS cost. Maybe this is not about money.
Options like GrapheneOS, even the mere idea of GrapheneOS, i.e., that there can be alternatives to BigTech's offerings, get buried underneath Apple marketing. Much of that marketing Apple gets for free. It comes from people who do not work for Apple.
Bloggers and others who discuss computers can help change that. They can also help Apple sail through any criticism (and they do).
- nicce 5y ago> However there is close to zero evidence to support this idea But there is. For example Apple used a lot of effort in this area, when they built their hardware security module (HSM), which is basically on every iPhone and iPad. This module is built in such a way, that nobody, not even Apple can access security keys from this device, or reprogram it again. Locked iPhone or password vault stays locked or gets cleaned. One blog about this matter: https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2016/08/13/is-apples-cloud-key-vault-crypto/ https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2016/08/13/is-apple... How about user tracking? Apple is one of the few companies which is not caught yet by selling data to third parties, nor even collecting more than needed to develop their products. Our new fancy iCloud is maybe the biggest evidence? It is maybe the cleverest way to this date to enable somekind of E2EE while getting limited info about the content. Highly recommed reading that PSI paper.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"They've been fighting with the FBI and the federal government for years..." Besides a single anomaly, what is the other evidence.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoIf Apple wished to distance itself from checking users' data, then it could stop collecting users' data in its data centers. This is the highest valued company in the world. It would not put them out of business. Would it even cause any decline in revenue. Lets be honest here. Apple wants user data. (NB There is no reason to "sell user data". For example, Facebook does not "sell user data". Apple and Facebook provide access to consumers. These consumers are ad targets. In the case of Apple, they expected to purchase more stuff after they purchase an Apple computer. Apple intends to be an intermediary in those transactions.)