2 ms·
First, it destroys the entire mechanism of LLC protection. Second, privacy is a human right. You should not be forced to list yourself in a publicly accessible
by mindslight 5y ago
First, it destroys the entire mechanism of LLC protection.
Second, privacy is a human right. You should not be forced to list yourself in a publicly accessible database to own real estate. Needing to pay a trustee to avoid this is bad enough.
Registering the beneficial owners of entities privately with the government is as far as makes sense. Of course then we run into the problem that government isn't terribly incentivized to do enough analysis to catch the large scale evaders.
- munk-a 5y ago> Second, privacy is a human right. You should not be forced to list yourself in a publicly accessible database to own real estate. Needing to pay a trustee to avoid this is bad enough. I think there is a core of truth here - individual persons should not be forever tied to business they've worked for. Everyone should always have the right to "walk away". However - while you're executing actions on behalf of a business you should not have a right to privacy of your actions - you are actively executing them and if you're doing shady or illegal things that should be knowable. Freedom of speech doesn't free you from the consequences of that speech - and I think it's unreasonable to demand to be free from the consequences of your actions. I do whole-heartedly agree with your final point though - it's the beneficiaries that should be on the hook as the first point of contact - agents of the company may be shielded by the company but the beneficiaries should achieve that shield by making themselves clear points of contact.
- mindslight 5y ago> while you're executing actions on behalf of a business you should not have a right to privacy of your actions Generally you don't. Most states require you to publicly declare managers of LLCs, and trustees of real estate. > it's the beneficiaries that should be on the hook as the first point of contact Nowhere did I suggest that beneficiaries should be points of contact, or otherwise available in a public database.