11 ms·
The future of long-haul trucking in Europe is electric
- Baeocystin 5y agoSome numbers for the US for comparison: https://www.capstonelogistics.com/blog/trend-watch-2019-length-of-haul-shift-reshapes-trucking/ https://www.capstonelogistics.com/blog/trend-watch-2019-leng...
- ljf 5y agoQuote from this link : Declining Length-of-Haul Today, the average length-of-haul is just 62 percent of what it was in 2005, decreasing from 800 miles to 500 (Fleet Owner). And the rate of decline appears to be accelerating. Since 2012, average miles driven between pickup and delivery have declined by 26 percent in reefers, 10 percent in flatbed trucks, and 9 percent in dry vans (Overdrive).
- apendleton 5y agoIt seems like there ought to be an "... in Europe" at the end of the headline, at least given the evidence they presented. Truck haul lengths are getting shorter in the US as well, but > Close to 80% of road freight activity in Europe is performed on trips below 800 km doesn't really apply in the US yet, where the average haul length is still 848km as of 2019[1]. Battery-electric trucks still might end up being the winner here, but there are still lots of hauls in the US where the battery-weight/range tradeoff is likely to be a significant obstacle with current technology. [1] https://transportfutures.net/navigator-blog/length-of-haul/ https://transportfutures.net/navigator-blog/length-of-haul/
- dang 5y agoOk, we've added that to the title. Thanks!
- Johnny555 5y agoThat article is about the European trucking industry: Close to 80% of road freight activity in Europe is performed on trips below 800 km I suspect that in the USA, the distances are much longer, though I'd really like to see more of our long-haul freight being hauled by rail rather than truck. A lot of the cost of trucking is externalized -- one study says "Freight trucks cause 99% of wear-and-tear on US roads, but only pay for 35% of the maintenance". Trains are already around 3 to 4 times more fuel efficient than trucks... start electrifying rail lines and emissions could be cut even more. Charge trucks their share of that road wear and trains would become more competitive even if they take longer. Trucks won't go away, they'll still be needed for the last mile (or last hundred mile) delivery from the train terminal to the customer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Sevii 5y agoA lot of freight is already transported by rail in the US 18-30% depending on who you ask. This seems about on par with or bigger than the fraction of fright that travels by rail in Europe. Part of the difference is that rail in the US is used mostly for fright whereas people use trains to get around more in Europe. Passenger focused rail vs fright focused rail. 30% according to railroads.dot.gov. https://railroads.dot.gov/rail-network-development/freight-rail-overview https://railroads.dot.gov/rail-network-development/freight-r...
- User23 5y agoIt's easy to forget what a big deal rail is in the USA, because the freight lines successfully lobbied Congress to allow them to eliminate the passenger cards they used to be required to add to the end of their freight trains. Back when that was the case passenger rail travel in the USA was cheap and ubiquitous, because it went everywhere the mail did. E.B. White has a wonderful little essay[1] about it. The full text can be found in the excellent Essays of E.B. White[2]. [1] http://www.sheilaomalley.com/?p=91313 http://www.sheilaomalley.com/?p=91313 [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/394616.Essays_of_E_B_White https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/394616.Essays_of_E_B_Whi...
- dchuk 5y agoI work deeply in heavy duty trucking technology in the US, and literally recently talked to many operators of large fleets about electrification. The only real opportunity for electrification is on short haul, less than ~300mi routes. For electrification to work in long haul (multi-day routes), they carriers will need to re-work how they actually plan freight lines to introduce many more hand off points along the route, which is going to drive up costs all around. It's solvable, but there's a lot of work left to do. The majority of freight in the US is still basically hauled via brute-force human planning.
- xwdv 5y agoIsn’t this an NP hard problem?
- dotcommand 5y agoSeems like a straightforward electric truck mileage/range problem.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoFor Europe the distances are less daunting - that 300mi (500km) gets you from Paris to Frankfurt, or Milan to Frankfurt.
- UglyToad 5y agoI didn't see it mentioned in the article but is swapping out the battery entirely an option being investigated, i.e. you roll into the truck stop and some process takes the depleted battery and inserts a charged one. It was discussed on the past for cars but I'd assume it's easier to design for trucks due to their specialised use?
- dchuk 5y agoI actually asked that exact question as well recently :) The problem is that the truck batteries are absolutely massive (4k+ pounds), so while I'm sure it's technically possible, practically speaking, moving around and storing batteries that big and heavy is just not realistic today.
- mdorazio 5y agoAs others have already mentioned, this really applies to places like Europe where truck routes are quite short. In the US I'm bullish on hydrogen-powered trucks (fuel cell). It's a technology that doesn't make much sense for passenger vehicles, but does make sense for heavy duty commercial vehicles that can have planned stops and fleet-managed stations.
- PhantomGremlin 5y agoIn the US I'm bullish on hydrogen-powered trucks (fuel cell). Natural gas (CNG and LNG) trucks haven't exactly set the transportation world on fire, even though they make much more sense than hydrogen. Natural gas is still routinely flared, it's too much trouble to try to collect it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Routine_flaring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Routine_flaring So, instead, you propose to take that very same natural gas as a starting feedstock and turn it into hydrogen? Then build a new infrastructure to distribute that hydrogen across the country? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforming Non starter. Natural gas is already distributed all around the country. Literally hundreds of thousands of miles of existing pipeline cris-crossing the country. How many hydrogen pipelines can you point to? If not pipelines, how do you propose to deliver hydrogen to where it is needed? I suppose there is some argument to be made to use excess PV solar and wind turbine energy to create hydrogen, but so far that hasn't happened at scale.
- unbalancedevh 5y agoI don't see this being a big player in the US any time soon. I'm having a hard time imagining the infrastructure required to service recharging all the batteries at truck stops every night, even if the range problem gets solved.
- OldHand2018 5y agoAll of the new large battery factories that I've seen make the news are being built as joint ventures between a battery company and an automaker for the exclusive use of the automaker - and the capacity is probably never going to be sufficient for the automaker to sell batteries to 3rd parties. Do you really gain "economies of scale with passenger cars" if you have to build your own battery factory for your long-haul trucks? Which would never be of the same capacity as the automaker factory?
- Symbiote 5y agoSeveral European car manufacturers are also truck manufacturers, although there are several that aren't.
- OldHand2018 5y agoAh, makes sense then
- Animats 5y agoThe near future of short-haul trucking is electric. The boring but useful Ford Transit goes electric next spring, along with the F-150 pickup. Many companies who have a fenced yard full of company trucks parked all night are likely to go for that. A Level 2 charger at every space, and the fleet sits there and charges at night.
- rascul 5y agoI believe you're thinking of the wrong class of vehicles. Trucking refers to the big 18 wheelers and such, not the little four wheeler trucks and vans. The Tesla Semi is an example, which may end up being great for short haul trucking. https://www.tesla.com/semi https://www.tesla.com/semi
- PhantomGremlin 5y agoTrucking refers to the big 18 wheelers and such, not the little four wheeler trucks and vans. This reminds me of some truck weigh station on some Interstate back east. (It's been years so I don't remember exact details). WEIGH STATION AHEAD ALL TRUCKS MUST STOP NO PICKUP TRUCKS
- Animats 5y agoThe Freighliner eCascadia (a semi-truck) and em2 (a straight truck) have been talked up since 2018, but apparently will not ship until 2022. Freightliner is a no-nonsense truck builder in a no-nonsense business. They probably will ship useful trucks. Although probably not with the silly purple LED lighting effects on the nose they stuck on the prototype. Unless something goes badly wrong, electric trucks are going to be all over the place next year.
- FpUser 5y ago>" will likely reach cost parity with diesel as early as 2025 if the right policy incentives are in place" Weasel terms instead of honestly telling that we will increase the cost of owning and operating regular trucks until they will become uncompetitive. Nothing's wrong with it if the end benefits outweigh the economic harm. Just please do not insult people's intelligence. P.S. There is a good chance that sometime in the future batteries tech might improve to the point that makes them competitive for truckers as well but this remains to be seen
- jet_32951 5y agoPerhaps if the catenaires are only in the rightmost lanes the experience of "elephants fucking" (e.g. a truck moving at 92 kph is overtaking one moving at 91 kph) could be mitigated.