5 ms·
You can make a contract on the phone; hell, two people in the middle of a meadow can make a verbal contract that's completely valid (provided there's an "exchan
by denton-scratch 5y ago
You can make a contract on the phone; hell, two people in the middle of a meadow can make a verbal contract that's completely valid (provided there's an "exchange of considerations", and the contract is "fair" - depending on jurisdiction).
The problem with verbal contracts is that it's hard to produce evidence about such contracts, if it comes to enforcement.
Email would be OK, if the agreement were assigned to the custody of some mutually-trusted party. It's no good if the parties to the agreement each save their copy of the text/plain agreement on their own corporate mailserver.
- kragen 5y agoMost of the time when there's a court case over these things, the disputed facts do not include which email was sent at what time and what it said. If the other party does choose to dispute those facts, it's true that you would have a hard time proving that you were in the right without some sort of witness like what you're describing; but usually they don't. (It's neither necessary nor sufficient that both parties trust the witness at the time; what matters is whether the court believes the witness if a dispute arises.)
- dctoedt 5y agoThe Statute of Frauds requires some societally-significant contracts to be in writing, and makes oral contracts in those categories unenforceable. The law-student mnemonic is MY LEGS — a written contract is required for agreements concerning: Marriage (e.g., prenups); Year (contracts that cannot be performed within one year); Land; Executor (when the executor of a dead person's estate agrees to pay the decedent's debts out of the executor's own pocket); Guarantor (of another's debt); Sales (of goods for $500 or more). [0] Nit: Strictly speaking a written contract is a "verbal" contract, because in this context, verbal means, in essence, using words, as opposed to, say, gestures or drawings. ("Verbal" derives from the Latin verbum. [1]) [0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/statute-of-frauds.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/statute-of-frauds.asp [1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/verbum#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/verbum#Latin
- only_as_i_fall 5y ago>The statute of frauds was adopted in the U.S. primarily as a common law concept—that is, as unwritten law. I found that part pretty amusing
- kemitchell 5y agoVery, very few signed, written contracts get deposited with a neutral. Parties keep signed “file copies” among their records. For big or important deals, one or the other’s lawyer compiles and shares a “closing binder”. Mostly these are PDFs, on file servers and mail servers. Practical evidence is not technical proof. Methods of technical proof don’t cover all the potential legal challenges. The goal is establishing terms before judge or jury. Do that and the court can enforce.
- lmilcin 5y agoSigned contracts have a signature. This has been an acceptable way to ascertain authenticity of the document for a long time. Signatures are surprisingly difficult to forge. I have developed my signature so that nobody can replicate it fluently. I also use special one off archival ink that nobody else in the world has. Emails do not have any default mechanism like that, especially if they only rest on servers of the interested parties. Emails are just bytes and can be easily edited.
- kemitchell 5y agoSignatures typically appear on printed documents. More and more often, they appear on separate signature pages, which don't include any terms or the signature of the other side. Authentication is not document integrity. Printed documents are also easily edited. Print and PDF pages are easily exchanged. I've seen contracts where parties initialed each page. Don't ask me why. I don't think I've ever seen a contract of more than one page signed on each page. I own several bottles of Noodler's ink. If I ever sue on a paper contract, I expect I'll be sending a scan or a photocopy into evidence. There's nothing magical about pen and ink, new or old. We just have a longer history with it. Everything's just evidence.
- number6 5y agoEverything a Signaturen does is better done by an digital signature. It's crazy how one party signs a PDF, scans it, and sends it via mail to be signed and scanned by the other party. Legally no party then owns a signed copy because they just got send a copy of the signature which is void. Doesn't matter in court: these contracts are enforced. We have done it. In the end only the invoices really matter.