4 ms·
> Alongside, same with the renaming of Nanjing - what if the government renames the incident and it becomes the status quo? What is the source of truth? The "s
by mschuster91 5y ago
> Alongside, same with the renaming of Nanjing - what if the government renames the incident and it becomes the status quo? What is the source of truth?
The "source of truth" should be scientific consensus, not government decrees and policies.
The problem is obvious: it takes a lot of resources to determine what the consensus is on hotly debated topics.
- quanticle 5y agoWhat is the "scientific consensus" on the name of a city? When the government of India decides to rename Calcutta to Kolkata, then has the "scientific consensus" on the name of the city shifted?
- 908B64B197 5y agoIt's what the inhabitants calls it. Calcutta, Pondicherry and Pekin were "best attempts" by Europeans to transcribe the sounds from the locals that were relayed to them by illiterate sailors.
- alisonkisk 5y agoWhich inhabitants?
- quanticle 5y agoThe inhabitants of Calcutta called it "Calcutta" prior to the Indian government renaming it. Now they call it Kolkata. The people of Madras called it Madras before the government renamed it to Chennai. Now they call it Chennai. I think it's incorrect to pretend that there's some kind of "objective" scientific reality at play here. Naming geographic locations is an inherently political act, and choosing which of several names to call a place inherently means favoring some interpretations over others.
- lwouis 5y agoSee my sibling comment. You don't need a consensus. You can list multiple perspectives and have them coexist. That's how we have to do with religion for example. There can't be a consensus there clearly, so we share all perspectives. Facts of life such as what's on Wikipedia should be edited as well as narrated by a variety of sources so that it represents the diversity of humankind
- mschuster91 5y agoThe question if something was a "massacre" or an "incident" or if a Nazi installation was a "concentration/extermination camp" or a "collection camp" is not something that allows coexistence or diversity.
- perl4ever 5y ago>if a Nazi installation was a "concentration/extermination camp" or a "collection camp" I'm not sure if a "collection camp" is an accepted term, or a term related to Holocaust denial, but there is a fact-based distinction between concentration and extermination camps, and a "collection camp" sounds like it might mean a camp that was used to gather people to be sent on to the others. For example, "the Theresienstadt ghetto functioned in part as a transit center for Jews from Czechoslovakia, Germany and Austria on their way to extermination camps and other mass killing centers" Regarding massacres: "The term massacre, being a synonym of "butchery, carnage", is by nature hyperbolic or subjective, primarily used in partisan descriptions of events. There is no neutral definition of what constitutes a "massacre" although some authors using the term may lay down general "working definitions" of what they mean by the term" Things described as massacres seem to range from the killing of 3 people to a million.
- alisonkisk 5y agoEven laying aside "extermination camps", both US and Nazi Germany ran "concentration camps". They were very, very different.
- lwouis 5y agoWhy is that one special? People hold impacting opinions like "gays should (not) marry". Picking a side and saying "this perspective shouldn't exist" represents one group becoming dominant and trying to suppress the other. Some people may think more accurate to talk about "extermination/concentration/ccollection". These opinions should be reflected if want an open conversation instead of oppression of a dominant group. It's tempting to think that our own cultural group is the one in the right and that we need to educate others, but a quick look at History shows the limits of that mindset
- philwelch 5y ago"Scientific consensus" is easily gamed by any authority with enough power to influence the scientific community. In the crudest version of this, any scientists who publicly disagree with the "consensus" are thrown into gulag. In more refined versions, they are excluded or expelled from the field, sometimes by activist mobs. The problem with the more refined version is that it's intentionally difficult to distinguish honest and qualified dissidents from kooks unless you know enough about the actual science. Consensus is a social and political phenomenon, not a scientific one.