5 ms·
Look, Tether might be a scam in the sense that they don't actually have the backing assets they claim but that doesn't invalidate the rest of the market or the
by Spivak 5y ago
Look, Tether might be a scam in the sense that they don't actually have the backing assets they claim but that doesn't invalidate the rest of the market or the trades done with them any more than your bank having <10% cash on hand of customer deposits.
They are absolutely running afoul of banking regulations but that's not exactly catastrophic for the whole market. Unless there's a bank run the only thing Tether actually needs to do is keep the trading value of their coin near $1.
- peytn 5y agoMy bank isn’t wash trading its reserves to drive a speculative bubble…
- Spivak 5y agoAnd neither should Tether. If any meatspace bank was found to be doing that they would be raked over the coals by the SEC but it doesn't make people trading in USD suddenly worthless.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> If any meatspace bank was found to be doing that they would be raked over the coals by the SEC but it doesn't make people trading in USD suddenly worthless Lebanon’s central bank was found to be engaging in funny business. Its currency crashed. Tether is akin to the central bank of USDT, not another player in the system.
- turminal 5y ago> Tether might be a scam in the sense that they don't actually have the backing assets they claim Tether is a scam on a whole other level than this
- Spivak 5y agoBut like how? I get why the SEC might have words for Tether the company but I don't get how users of tether have been scammed. You buy coin at around $1 and sell at around $1. Like from an end-user perspective as long as the thing actually functions as a stablecoin for some time interval you care about what else is there?
- turminal 5y agoThe problem is those two companies that bought most of it have the power to prematurely end that time interval whenever that makes financial sense for them.
- Spivak 5y agoHypothetically speaking if Tether had been squeaky clean and open about holding a fraction backing assets in cash. These companies could have still bought a crap ton of it and caused a bank run if they wanted. That's just how fractional reserve works.
- svachalek 5y agoYou can sell around $1 as long as people believe it's worth $1, which it's not, so there's no guarantee they will continue to believe it forever. It's supposed to have enough backing to actually represent a $1 which would mean that faith wouldn't be part of the equation, but that's not the actual situation.
- Consultant32452 5y agoIf you read this out of context it looks like you're bashing the dollar.
- headmelted 5y agoNot to sound patronising but this perspective sounds very myopically focused on crypto “narratives”. We’ve seen bank runs before. We’ve seen failed currencies. These aren’t unprecedented events. With that said, the old Buffett quote “it’s only when the tide goes out that you see who’s been swimming naked” has never been more apt than to this situation. To take your hypothetical example, you’re correct that the user in question is able to trade on their token to someone else for another asset quickly - but as the article states, issuances outstrip redemptions by 20:1. That means almost all of these tokens are still in circulation. Someone is on the hook for those losses. The thing is, who’s liable? If the whole marketplace is a fugazi then it’s probably up to the exchanges to organise haircuts as they deem appropriate. That isn’t even the real problem though. What’s the value of [COIN] if 95% of the market cap is suddenly revealed to be fake money? I mean, sure, you can assume everyone will just shrug that off and hold what they have while you sell, but it seems really unlikely. tldr; this information suggests that most of the value in most of cryptocurrency tokens does not and has never existed.
- amznthrwaway 5y agoYour bank has a balance sheet that adds up in the entirety, with maybe 10% liquid. Tether claimed they were 100% liquid backed, then kept changing that as it became obvious they were lying. It is extremely likely that they are insolvent (assets not adding up to 100%).
- bostonsre 5y agoIt's all fine and good until there is a run on tether and they can't actually give customers their money back. They will throttle customer withdrawals, the issue will be magnified, and I would guess tethers would be selling for pennies on the dollar on the secondary market.
- ceejayoz 5y agoYup. https://tether.to/legal/ https://tether.to/legal/ > Tether reserves the right to delay the redemption or withdrawal of Tether Tokens if such delay is necessitated by the illiquidity or unavailability or loss of any Reserves held by Tether to back the Tether Tokens, and Tether reserves the right to redeem Tether Tokens by in-kind redemptions of securities and other assets held in the Reserves. Tether makes no representations or warranties about whether Tether Tokens that may be traded on the Site may be traded on the Site at any point in the future, if at all.
- bostonsre 5y agoThat is pretty hilarious... "we reserve the right to be a scam".
- Spivak 5y agoThis discussion is so weird because you're to the letter describing banks and bank runs, which does make sense because Tether and other stablecoins are banks, albeit without FDIC insurance. What is actually bad about Tether that doesn't apply to USD and the current largely functional banking system?
- ceejayoz 5y agoBanks pass audits, have specific capital requirements, and you've even helpfully highlighted the FDIC insurance that protects individuals from their fuckups.
- Spivak 5y agoThis doesn't follow since the argument would apply to Tether even if they weren't doing shady things. If you don't think unregulated stablecoins should exist in general that's valid but it doesn't answer the question of what specifically Tether is doing. Like rake them over the coals for lying about having assets they didn't but if Tether had been from the start open about holding only a small fraction in cash would it be a problem?
- IncRnd 5y ago> Tether might be a scam in the sense that they don't actually have the backing assets they claim > They are absolutely running afoul of banking regulations > the only thing Tether actually needs to do is keep the trading value of their coin near $1. How do you propose Tether do that if they don't have financial backing to create a watermark below which the value won't fall? Increase the scam?
- Spivak 5y agoIs anything other than 100% cash backing a scam to you because that seems like a stretch? Oh lawdy did they defraud people by claiming to be 100% cash backed when they weren't but I don't think fractional reserve is a scam in general. At any given moment you just need the ability to pay out the people who come to you and ask which is already teeny tiny (as evident by banks needing less than 5% cash reserves of deposits) and made even smaller since people don't typically cash Tether out directly and do it at exchanges.
- IncRnd 5y agoI think you are looking at this through rose-colored glasses. Not everything you read on the Internet is true, and Tether is likely to not even pay a small fraction of what they have made. It is almost certain they have stolen an incredible amount of money, using a song and a dance, and made people shill for them - because hey tbey have all the bad parts of banks and none of the good parts - so what's the problem? > as evident by banks needing less than 5% cash reserves of deposits You may not be aware, but when you deposit money into a bank, deposits are insured, so it doesn't matter if they have 1% on hand. You will eventually get your deposit back. That is not even close to what Tether is.
- Spivak 5y agoYes but FDIC insurance exists because bank runs actually happened! It wasn’t like before FDIC banks kept 100% cash reserves.
- 5y ago