3 ms·
"For something like matching photo hashes, the bar could be lower than e.g. for searching someone's house. The flipside would be that if the warrant is found to
by giantg2 5y ago
"For something like matching photo hashes, the bar could be lower than e.g. for searching someone's house. The flipside would be that if the warrant is found to be inadequately justified (even in retrospect), no data found in it is available for evidence."
The bar is pretty low already. Anything found by warrant that is found to be defective is thrown out already under the fruit of the poisonous tree theory.
Even if the evidence is thrown out, or if the person is innocent, the process can still ruin people's lives, cost money, etc. I recently had an experience with a trooper letting a dangerous dog charge stand even though he knew it was the wrong charge. That charge carried with it pretrial restrictions. This should be a violation of the 8th amendment's prohibition on unusual punishment. There were a few other issues/rights violation with what he and prosecutors did too. Anyways, nobody cared - they even said they are allowed to leave incorrect charges stand. Unless you spend thousands of dollars on a lawyer, you're screwed. Even if you're right, they will not take you seriously unless you have a lawyer. It generally costs more to defend your innocence than pay the fine for lower level offenses.
Giving the system even more power is just going to lead more innocent people being trampled on. I would guess it's only a matter of time before some parent gets caught in Apple's scanning because they have a naked picture of their baby taking a bath or something.