4 ms·

He may not have a bachelor's but he does have an MD, which is a higher degree and one that confers some expertise on medical matters last time I checked. > ask

He may not have a bachelor's but he does have an MD, which is a higher degree and one that confers some expertise on medical matters last time I checked. > asking a random computer science graduate to tell you how to fix your Windows domain A random computer science graduate who does a bit of research should be able to tell you everything you need to know about your Windows domain. Certainly, they'd be better suited than asking an accountant.

MisterBastahrd 5y ago
An MD is a generalist's degree. It doesn't confer anything but that he graduated from med school and knows a bit about human physiology. Infectious diseases are AT LEAST as far out of his wheelhouse as Windows domain servers are to computer science graduates, aka, anything that he even pretends to know about the subject is something he read online.
- jimmygrapes 5y ago
  Do you think a computer science graduate cannot be an expert at Windows domain management as well?
  - MisterBastahrd 5y ago
    Do YOU think that a CS grad can call upon his CS background and magically be an expert on Windows domain management on par with people who do it for a living? Because THAT is what we are talking about here. Rand Paul is an eye doctor, not an infectious disease specialist, and not an epidemiologist. The experts on this topic have spoken AND written AND researched the subject. Any credible information about it would have come FROM them, and THEY say that masks are something that we should do to stop the spread of an infectious disease.
    - iammisc 5y ago
      He is an opthalmologist not an optometrist. A md degree gives you the ability to practice medicine. Paul will have been trained on the whole body. The eye speciality is an added specialization. As an MD he should be able to do everything from basic first aid to general diagnosis to delivering a baby in a woman even with major complications should he have to. He may have to do some research and reading but he is authorized to do such things
      - MisterBastahrd 5y ago
        That's like pretending that the lead developer on MS Word and John Carmack are equally qualified and capable to speak on 3d graphics algorithm optimizations because they both know computer things. The best Paul can hope to do is to read the results research that these experts ACTUALLY PERFORMED. He's not on their level and his opinion on the matter has zero importance other than his vote in the Senate.
        iammisc 5y ago
        If the lead MS word developer listens to Carmack's thoughts and points out problems, he's more than qualified.
        MisterBastahrd 5y ago
        "listens to Carmack's thoughts" Because hearing a high level overview is anything even remotely like having foundational knowledge, much less a deep expertise. I said equally qualified. You don't get to have the argument you want by disregarding the core of it simply because it disagrees with your politics.

MisterBastahrd 5y ago

An MD is a generalist's degree. It doesn't confer anything but that he graduated from med school and knows a bit about human physiology. Infectious diseases are AT LEAST as far out of his wheelhouse as Windows domain servers are to computer science graduates, aka, anything that he even pretends to know about the subject is something he read online.

jimmygrapes 5y ago
Do you think a computer science graduate cannot be an expert at Windows domain management as well?
- MisterBastahrd 5y ago
  Do YOU think that a CS grad can call upon his CS background and magically be an expert on Windows domain management on par with people who do it for a living? Because THAT is what we are talking about here. Rand Paul is an eye doctor, not an infectious disease specialist, and not an epidemiologist. The experts on this topic have spoken AND written AND researched the subject. Any credible information about it would have come FROM them, and THEY say that masks are something that we should do to stop the spread of an infectious disease.
  - iammisc 5y ago
    He is an opthalmologist not an optometrist. A md degree gives you the ability to practice medicine. Paul will have been trained on the whole body. The eye speciality is an added specialization. As an MD he should be able to do everything from basic first aid to general diagnosis to delivering a baby in a woman even with major complications should he have to. He may have to do some research and reading but he is authorized to do such things
    - MisterBastahrd 5y ago
      That's like pretending that the lead developer on MS Word and John Carmack are equally qualified and capable to speak on 3d graphics algorithm optimizations because they both know computer things. The best Paul can hope to do is to read the results research that these experts ACTUALLY PERFORMED. He's not on their level and his opinion on the matter has zero importance other than his vote in the Senate.
      - iammisc 5y ago
        If the lead MS word developer listens to Carmack's thoughts and points out problems, he's more than qualified.
        MisterBastahrd 5y ago
        "listens to Carmack's thoughts" Because hearing a high level overview is anything even remotely like having foundational knowledge, much less a deep expertise. I said equally qualified. You don't get to have the argument you want by disregarding the core of it simply because it disagrees with your politics.