3 ms·
>It’s going to have to be a part of our climate changed future to deter criminals. How's that strategy working out for deterring murderers and drug dealers?
by gruez 5y ago
>It’s going to have to be a part of our climate changed future to deter criminals.
How's that strategy working out for deterring murderers and drug dealers?
- yumraj 5y agoWe don't have data to say that it's not working.
- coding123 5y agoIt's still happening... is that data?
- majormajor 5y agoNot really. Rates exist between 0% and 100%. How many deterred murderers do you think need to exist for it to be worth prosecuting and harshly punishing murder? Though even after knowing your answer to that question... I'm not eager to live in your experiment's "murder is fine" group...
- btkramer9 5y agoIt will probably work as well as it does for murderers. There's not really a demand for murder so there's not continually new people filling their shoes when they get arrested. Drug dealers on the other hand will never go away no matter how many you arrest. There will always be more people willing to buy drugs and a new dealer ready to step up and make a profit.
- wahern 5y ago> Drug dealers on the other hand will never go away no matter how many you arrest. There will always be more people willing to buy drugs and a new dealer ready to step up and make a profit. Singapore and Saudi Arabia might object. Punishments always have some marginal effect; the question is how severe they need to be to achieve the desired effect magnitude, and whether the direct and indirect costs are acceptable.
- ZanyProgrammer 5y agoWhen murderers and drug dealers make centuries long and very undesirable changes in the global climate, let me know.
- ZanyProgrammer 5y agoOf course you also assumed "draconian punishments" equates to "lack of due process". As if punishing murderers is inherently wrong and goes against your very finely tuned civil liberties instincts.
- bishoprook2 5y agoTo be fair, if you execute a murderer they're not going to do it anymore.
- ncmncm 5y agoAnd, if you execute somebody who is, in fact, not one, you become one.