5 ms·
The idea of: > For example, we have an "Early Ganker" tag for the gamers who tend to gang in the early game. [...] We provide these tags based on only publicly
by bee_rider 5y ago
The idea of:
> For example, we have an "Early Ganker" tag for the gamers who tend to gang in the early game. [...] We provide these tags based on only publicly accessible data on the official game publisher API. For example, any gamer can search for the opponents’ game data and conduct a similar analysis.
also seems questionable to me. Is it common/practical to do this kind of thing in these games? It seems to me that, while it might be technically possible to get the info, it should be impractical for a human to actually do the analysis, in the timespan allowed by a pregame lobby, right?
I guess it could also depend on how much preprocessing they do... hypothetically we could imagine a game where every match is recorded and saved to a public user account, and a "coaching" AI system that extracts users tags by watching these offline, and then just queries them at match time. This analysis would pretty clearly be information that players wouldn't normally be privy to, despite being available through legitimate means.
- EamonnMR 5y agoIs an AI that aimbots by predicting player moves with uncanny accuracy really that different from a regular old aimbot?
- bee_rider 5y agoAnother interesting point in the spectrum could be, what about a program that marks up the screen or minimap with detailed heatmaps of likely player positions based on historical data? If that's not obviously cheating, make it time dependent, make it player dependent, etc. If that is obviously cheating, what about producing those maps and not providing an in-game overlay?
- snet0 5y agoI think it's very simple: if you'd describe its usage as a "skill", it's probably fine. Obvious "navigating this cheat menu UI takes some practice" cases aside. If a professional team uses data analysis and then teaches their players something like "at 30s, on this map, this player rotates from here to here in 70% of games", that's just good training. If they have this data being live-streamed to their second monitor, it's cheating.
- EamonnMR 5y agoI don't see as very different from a wallhack if it's any good if it's an in game overlay. I suppose if it's an offline thing that you can study but need to apply yourself that's no more of a cheat than any other prep.
- reportgunner 5y agoI would say that a skilled player doesn't need to see the heat maps in real time, it would be enough to see them once or twice and they will remember because it "makes sense" to them that the heat maps are the way they are.
- andrewzah 5y agoThose kinds of maps are already available for study outside of the game for DotA2, eg. here’s the analysis for a game I played. These are incredibly useful for learning and analysis after the match. https://www.opendota.com/matches/5501229759/laning https://www.opendota.com/matches/5501229759/laning
- bobobob420 5y agoNope it’s not and that’s why 100 percent if this tool is doing what it is saying, I would consider it cheating. I have tons of hours in Valorant and if this becomes common I will not play the game. I play specifically because of the learning curve and skill curve. There’s already a big enoug problem with Smurf’s and ranked boosting
- girvo 5y agobig enoug problem with Smurf’s Maybe its just because I play on Sydney servers, but I really find this a bit overblown personally -- and I've ranked up from bronze 2 to plat 1 over six months of playing. I think its honestly just that some people have "on" and "off" games, at least from the hundreds and hundreds of ranked matches I've played.
- bobobob420 5y ago1/3 games of Mine has a smurf on my or other team that will admit it or it’s insanely obvious. I play central NA
- interator7 5y agoAs a League of Legends player, it's very common. Virtually everyone that I know that plays this game has some sort of overlay(LolWiz, Porofessor, Blitz.gg, etc.) that provides unimaginable level of detail about the enemy team and my team before the game even begins. I can find out what the enemy players like to do("invade", or initiate cheese fights early), roam to other lanes in the map, and more. I know what their winrate on their champion is, how many kills on average they get before 10 minutes, whether they don't ward(a crucial component of the game that opens them up to ganks if not done correctly), and who they may be connected to voice call with. If anything, it seems like Senpai.gg's tool isn't doing enough.
- bee_rider 5y agoHuh, well this supports my decision to not get into MOBAs.
- eertami 5y agoIn Dota at least you can make your data private and your picks/habits cannot be tracked by third party websites or applications. I feel like gaming stats should have way better privacy options in general.
- berkozer 5y agoThat's certainly right. We don't provide any suggestion based on private data. For example, gamers cannot see the tags of an opponent if the opponent opted out to be private.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoI think if people care about their data it should just be anonymized instead of hidden. Data from games is such a good way for people to get into programming and data analysis (Speaking from personal experience). It's easily accessible, real and has a decent level of complexity. Would be a shame for it to go away because people want to hide their data.
- andrewzah 5y ago