3 ms·
> It appears to be personal and emotional; not based on any empirical data I don't think that's true. I think you're conflating ageism with bias against someo
by jedberg 5y ago
> It appears to be personal and emotional; not based on any empirical data
I don't think that's true. I think you're conflating ageism with bias against someone who worked at one place for a really long time.
As a hiring manager, I'd be excited about talking to someone 50+ and the experience they can bring to the table, as well as their unique ability to mentor me as a manager because they have so much experience being managed.
But I'd be wary of someone who worked so long at one place, because I've worked with people like that, and it usually doesn't go well. They tend to believe that the way things were done at their last company is the only way things can be done. They were so senior at their previous company that they always got their way simply because of their seniority, and do not have a lot of experience being the new person.
Someone who worked that long at one place would have a high bar to clear, because I'd need some pretty solid proof that you worked on projects that required you to learn new skills, that you had experience working with different groups of people and different managers with different styles. All of these things I can assume are true with someone who has had multiple jobs.
And lastly, while you have a lot of experience, it's not a diversity of experience, at least not like someone who has worked at more places.
So all told, I'd rather have someone with 30 years of work experience at four or more companies than someone with 30 years of experience at one company.
- skeeter2020 5y agoWell, you still didn't refute his position that this is not based on empirical data, just a few of your limited data points and personal bias (which is neither good or bad; just something we all have). >> , I'd rather have someone with 30 years of work experience at four or more companies than someone with 30 years of experience at one company. Experience means depth and/or breadth, so what you're really saying is "I want someone with 30 years experience, not 30x 1 year of experience. Multiple companies increases the odds that they'll at least have breadth". This is a valid strategy but still a bias. There was a time when many people worked at the same company for their entire career as the desired path, not some form of settling or indicator of limited skills. It's only a generation or two that has not experienced this.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoMost folks don't even bother going back through my posting history, to find out a bit more. I tend to "overshare," because, basically, I don't give much of a hoot, anymore. The folks that matter, know me. No one ever seems to follow any of the many links in my HN profile (except, every now and then, I get spammy LinkedIn connection requests). As it turns out, I happen to have a wide variety of experience, but one common factor, is that all of it has been focused on shipping software (even my side work). So, yeah, I guess I am a "one trick pony," but that one trick, is a lifetime of ship. I've heard that can be useful.
- nonameiguess 5y ago"Company" is a bad proxy for what you're actually looking for. At a sufficiently large company, the experience from one office to another, one business unit to another, even just one team to another, can be drastically different. In situations where the company primarily works contracts for specific customers, the culture and processes of a particular contract might even be set by the customer much more than by the company.
- mgkimsal 5y ago> and do not have a lot of experience being the new person. I'm almost always 'the new person', and have rarely been on projects more than 2-3 years. I operate as an independent - sometimes solo, sometimes with a team. Most team projects have not gone more than 2-3 years, some solo projects have gone longer - 4 or 5 was about the longest. The pace changes over time - initially a lot of work, then some transition to maintenance, slower feature rollout, etc. Then... another project comes along, and ... you're "the new person" again, with more experience about what's worked and what hasn't. I can not imagine working one place for 27 years. It boggles my mind. I've had to learn to accept that I will never get one of those '20 years of service' plaques I saw on TV shows as a symbol of "the company man" sort of thing. It's just not possible. I have had 20+ years of self-employment, in spurts, although the last round has been going on 13 years now.