10 ms·
I've decided not to work with Aubrey de Grey or SENS
- apsec112 5y agoLinked for reference, without endorsement: Aubrey de Grey's response: https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=6528005127224941&id=100000465546952 https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=6528005127224941... SENS's response: https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=4242081739160861&id=138424229526653 https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=4242081739160861... More info from Laura Deming: https://mobile.twitter.com/LauraDeming/status/1425365212484431880 https://mobile.twitter.com/LauraDeming/status/14253652124844...
- JabavuAdams 5y agoHitting on a minor, who you know is a minor (17 years old) when you are in a position of power over her is more than just a little mistake. DeGrey admits this. Imagine if a coach or a teacher did this. That alone is a serious serious breach of ethics, and gives some insight into a person's mind and potential other activities.
- stuaxo 5y agoAs someone pointed out, the age of consent in the UK is 16. But that's really not the point, everything else you said is. And just because it's legal doesn't mean that it's socially acceptable, for all those reasons.
- JabavuAdams 5y agoI don't remember exactly, but in Canada I believe it's significant whether the other person is in a position of authority over the minor. This is to prevent grooming and/or the implicit threat of reprisal if the minor doesn't comply.
- JabavuAdams 5y agoI've crushed on co-workers; I've had crushes on professors; I've had crushes on classmates. Attraction in a work/study environment is real. The thing is ... you don't have to do or say anything, guys. Just keep that stuff locked down like a non-creep and it will eventually pass. Writing love letters to 17 year olds who work for you? Come on. You should know/do better.
- RangerScience 5y ago> keep that stuff locked down Careful with this. IME, everything you feel gets expressed eventually. You either make some choices about that expression, or it leaks out of you - usually in toxic ways (passive aggression, overly controlling behavior, snipe-comments, etc.) Have close friends (and a therapist!) that you can talk to about just about anything. A lot of times, feelings are signals for exploration; "here be learning", as it were. Aubrey even names it, without realizing it (IMO) when he says "could treat [me] as an equal on every other level". I'm betting that if Aubrey had taken the time to feel and understand, he'd have realized that Deming (at that time) wasn't someone he could actually treat as an equal on every level. (And, probably, that he had a need for more people in his life that he could).
- zozbot234 5y agoFrom reading his email to her, it's clear that he did realize this, but somehow he also thought he could get away with writing a suggestive email to her about his "adventurous love life" [sic]. (To be clear, referencing such things in a written work email would be regarded as grossly unprofessional no matter what the circumstances, but Laura being 17 and working for him at the time makes it quite outrageous.)
- RangerScience 5y agoWas the email published? All I've got to go off of is the snippet from the OP.
- 5y ago
- rbanffy 5y agoHitting on someone who’s much younger and less experienced than you may be legal, but is still wrong. The power the more experienced person can exert on the less experienced one is dangerous and can easily be misused. It often is.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoIt's not just that it can be misused. Hitting on them is misusing it. It's putting them between a rock and hard place. Nothing good can come of that.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoWhen you make mistakes, you don't double down and DARVO.
- kbenson 5y ago> DeGrey admits this. To be absolutely clear (and play devils advocate to a degree), he did not admit to that. What he actually says is: Laura references an email I wrote - inadvisedly, for sure, and which I unreservedly regret - to her when she was 17, but she explicitly states that "I wrote it off as a mistake" He notes she initially wrote it off as a mistake, and the email was inadvisable. He's walking a fine line here, where he's not outright saying she was correct in thinking the email was a mistake (it's also a bit unclear what this means from her, a mistake on his part or a mistake in her interpretation, but I assume the former), and he regrets is, but the reason for that regret is left for us to intuit. You assume (as I do) that it's because he actually was attempting to solicit a relationship, but it's left such that it could plausibly be explained later as him regretting that he was so loose with his words that it could be interpreted that way. I mention this not because I think he's innocent of that specific accusation, but because he's worded this very specifically, and while I think the implication is that yes, he did hit on her, he hasn't actually admitted that, and make statements that he has just confuses the issue to some degree and causes backlash in those that see statements like this and then read the source later, and notice the discrepancy and side with the person in question because "people are obviously out to get him by twisting his words". His words are fairly damning when laid out exactly as they are, so better to use them that way, IMO.
- JabavuAdams 5y agoYou are technically correct. I could have been more precise in my wording. As you say, though, it doesn't change my (or your) conclusion.
- kbenson 5y agoThat's right. I just think sometimes these are left in as escape hatches, or possibly landmines, for critics. E.g. You and others say he admitted it, later he clarifies what he meant which makes prior statements of others incorrect, which can then be pointed to as evidence of all sorts of things, like a concerted effort to defame or ignore the reality or people lying, which just muddies the waters, and provides a smokescreen for the person to hide behind. The only defense against things like that are to stick to the facts and be clear and correct based on what other people have said and what we think that actually means. e.g. "I think the implication is clear, even if it's not outright admitted." Anything else helps them by giving them ammunition to lob back later.
- RickJWagner 5y agoExactly. Like the Clinton/Lewinsky thing-- it was the start of exposing a predator. (Clinton's accusers came out of the woodwork after that, many with firm evidence, some with settlements in hand.)
- bigbillheck 5y ago> Clinton's accusers came out of the woodwork after that It's not as if there weren't accuser pre-Lewinksy either.
- varelse 5y agoA minor that he had mentored since she was 14. If that isn't solid evidence of poor judgment I don't know what is. Also incredibly and disgustingly creepy.
- CJefferson 5y agoThat defense post is.. really strange. It seems to suggest the complainants have been brain-washed (by secret behind the scenes people?) and also claims the fact there arent lots of other complaints as evidence of innocence -- there doesn't have to be an "iceberg" of complaints for you to be guilty. Lots of people get convicted of just one crime.
- KittenInABox 5y agoThat defense pose is really strange, and in some aspects really disgusting. "In order to orient you"? "Laura references an email I wrote - inadvisedly, for sure, and which I unreservedly regret - to her when she was 17"? Even if this is the watered-down, best-light scenario, this is very weird. And then tries to use Laura's words against her- she previously dismisses it as an honest mistake and then changes her mind when presented with apparent new evidence. And somehow portrays this as them being deceived. Why would anyone try to trick two women into making allegations that a guy is a creep? They fully well know that these allegations will blow up their careers and are very likely to be unsuccessful in influencing Aubrey de Grey's career long term. If one wanted to smear Aubrey de Grey, she-said-he-said creepiness is one of the least effective ways to do it because a wide swath of the population aren't bothered enough to affect someone's career over it-- the only reason consequences are newsworthy is because they're so uncommon.
- zo1 5y ago> "Why would anyone try to trick two women into making allegations that a guy is a creep? They fully well know that these allegations will blow up their careers and are very likely to be unsuccessful in influencing Aubrey de Grey's career long term." From the look of the Twitter feed of one of the accusers, it doesn't look to be doing anything but promoting them and putting them up as brave, etc.
- zozbot234 5y agoCeline Halioua isn't "anonymous", she's a successful aging researcher and her complaints are if anything, even more damning for Aubrey and the SENS folks: https://www.celinehh.com/aubrey https://www.celinehh.com/aubrey
- JulianMorrison 5y agoRe the idea that because someone interacted casually "the next day", they don't have a case: it's very normal for people who've been harassed to initially shrug things off, because it's just too jarring to their world-view to swerve their opinion of someone from "friend and mentor" to "creep". And it's very normal to come to understand that something was actually sexual harassment gradually, or when a third party says "no wait seriously that isn't right" and makes you face it. And then it's normal to be ambivalent about speaking up and take your time to do so.
- aeturnum 5y agoBeing able to act without fully processing trauma is a deeply important evolutionary adaptation. Our brains will compartmentalize things to help us cope and survive and continue on, because our ancestors who didn't do it automatically were more likely to die. That's not to say we all react the same to trauma, but a common reaction is one of tiny adjustments and a slow dawning of the fullness of the experience. We also are surrounded by people who are well meaning but make mistakes and our socialization prepares us to be forgiving of them. To give time for repair. Abusers use those social structures (consciously or unconsciously) to give themselves space to do what they like. It's a big move to fully separate yourself from someone, and abusers see that if they can make it more comfortable to simply live further away from them, that they can continue without changing or facing the damage they have caused. I really encourage anyone who doesn't understand why assault or abuse reactions look this way to imagine what actions they might take if their current boss were to suddenly grab their genitals without warning or permission. There's an element of the personal violation that, I think, is difficult to appreciate - but the practicalities of addressing it are, I think, obvious once you start to imagine it. Who would you tell? What consequences would you suffer? How outlandish might you seem to peers, other managers, etc? Personal violations like this are deeply treacherous and the people who commit them take advantage of that fact to keep doing it.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoMore importantly, it may be necessary to act as if nothing happened to avoid retaliation.
- codekilla 5y agoBravo!
- nudpiedo 5y agoI believe this should be flagged. I wonder for how long can society take serious accusations like this one or other #meetoo public ones which ended up never suing anyone but just doing bad pres. These are cost free for the supposed victims and if no evidence is presented, it is at least, bad press against the accused part (and if it was an innocent person, for whatever reason including missunderstandigs or a malicious try to exploit a famous person, become the victim). In many countries there is a thing called "right of honor" (the right to not be difamated) and would turn things against the accusing part if no evidence of the claims is presented. I don't have any connection with Aubrey de Grey or SENS, but I think we should not believe any of such accusations unless these are properly reported to the police or whatever. If they are true victims, sue the person. Otherwise we all will contribute to feed the cancel culture by propagating rumors. P.D. I expect to get downvoted as with all social justice topics. Dear Talibans: I don't mind as I believe I stand for what's right.
- bigbillheck 5y agoHe admitted to sending that email to a 17 year old.
- nudpiedo 5y agoNot sure what the content of the email was, but in such situation this person should go to the police first rather than make a campaign.
- ericpruitt 5y agoIn some places, the age of consent is 17 (or lower), so without physical coercion, Aubrey may not have a legal leg to stand on depending on the content of the message.
- nudpiedo 5y agoAlthough that’s right I still totally ignore the content of that email and if it was ilegal that should be put in the knowledge of the legal tutors and authorities. The other thing is that this person as she turned an adult continued the contact with this person, so I don’t really think a public scandal is justified.
- rbanffy 5y agoNot really sure why this was flagged.
- radu_floricica 5y agoIn an era that should have equal opportunity a non-issue, we're move straight into the opposite direction. Aubrey de Gray may be canceled. But the the most salient lesson here? Don't mentor young women, especially if they're remotely attractive. It's far from being worth the risk. You think I'm exaggerating? What could kill a successful career these days? If you'll excuse me a flippant comparison, even a double digit chance of having caused Covid isn't doing it. But an accusation of misconduct years ago can. Just ponder the odds a bit. So what would motivate somebody to risk this? "Just don't be a creep"? Shit, if you think you can interact a couple of years with a pretty woman and are 100% certain you'll never flirt, you're... I was about to say "a better man than I", but on second thought, that's inhuman. Not the "not flirt" part, plenty of men succeed. But the being sure you won't, not with multiple women, over many years. I'm giving myself much better lifetime odds of not crashing my motorcycle. So again... what's to gain for a successful professional in academia or business, to work with and mentor young women, when it's literally the only major risk on one's career? There are enough bright young men that are much safer.
- KittenInABox 5y ago> Shit, if you think you can interact a couple of years with a pretty woman and are 100% certain you'll never flirt, you're... I was about to say "a better man than I", but on second thought, that's inhuman. Excuse me? In this situation you're claiming you think it's inhuman not to see a minor as an object of sexual attraction?
- pjscott 5y agoMoral arguments aside, there's an interesting empirical question here: how many straight men actually feel no attraction to (pubescent) teen girls? That sounds like a set of preferences that would have a hard time evolving, and one that would have been seen as fairly odd in most historical periods I know of.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoHis demeanor…who could resist someone that looks like catweazel.
- hinkley 5y agoIt’s hard to participate in a conversation like this without sticking your foot in it or dogpiling. Something has always seemed a bit off to me about Aubrey’s need to grasp at youth. To hear accusations that he was grasping at other people’s youth as well is not that shocking. I could use other adjectives but let’s stick with a safer one: vampiric.
- psyc 5y agoBoth a lech, and a lich. Hmm.
- cblconfederate 5y agoI would like to preemptively distance myself from this guy even though i never met him. Need to keep this as public record
- mircea 5y agoI loathe to think that this could have been used as a weapon. I'm quoting in full a comment on the TFA: > As always, follow the money! Laura Deming runs a venture capital firm in the longevity space together with Celine. Celine also runs her own anti-aging biotech company for dogs. They are trying to damage SENS and Aubrey De grey, to get publicity to their own company. People will do anything to get rich. It has always been like that. By making this into a public scandal, they know that they will get the attention from the right rich donors/investors that are interested in the anti-aging space. The reason I am very suspicious of them is the way they exaggerate by calling Aubrey De Grey a sexual predator, when all he did was some joking and testing the grounds to see if there was mutual interest. She was 17 when he sent the e-mail. 17 is legal in the UK. I have seen many 17-year olds that could easily pass as grown adults. Also, the way the e-mail seems to have been written was not pushy at all. There was no threat or anything like that either. Totally blown out of proportion. These women are going to become responsible for billions of lives, when they cause delays to the anti-aging research in this way. They are greedy and egocentric, and should be shamed away from this field. — Sophie
- JulianMorrison 5y agoAn adult, a mentor, with authority over a minor, can't avoid their sexual advances being a threat. They can't avoid it even if they didn't mean anything by it. So they just shouldn't do that.
- sinenomine 5y agoI find it peculiar and surprising that this PR event is happening just at the moment of Aubrey finally having received a good round of financing and publicity.
- pseudalopex 5y agoHe prompted it by contacting her.[1] And it wouldn't be even a little peculiar or surprising even if he didn't. Publicity reminds other people of their own experiences with the person. [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/LauraDeming/status/1425365297180004357 https://mobile.twitter.com/LauraDeming/status/14253652971800...
- Geekette 5y agoThe linked post by Celine Halioua is also disturbing: "At one such dinner, I was sat next to Aubrey by a SENS executive. I was told to keep him ‘entertained’; Aubrey funneled me alcohol and hit on me the entire night. He told me that I was a ‘glorious woman’ and that as a glorious woman I had a responsibility to have sex with the SENS donors in attendance so they would give money to him. I left that dinner sobbing. ... Another SENS executive harassed me so severely that I eventually dropped out of my PhD to escape him (a legal investigation upheld my many accusations against him). I later learned I was far from his first victim, that SENS knew this, and yet they knowingly sent me to work underneath him. ... SENS is aware of all of this. The Board was brought testimonies from other women in the beginning of 2021. These testimonies include physical sexual abuse. SENS did not act. Only after Laura and I came forward two months ago did SENS initiate an internal investigation."
- zozbot234 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28155929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28155929 is flagged but has some informative comments