6 ms·
>Because you can print whatever adults in the room decide need to be printed to hold the economy up. You cannot do this with a deflationary digital asset, nor o
by gruez 5y ago
>Because you can print whatever adults in the room decide need to be printed to hold the economy up. You cannot do this with a deflationary digital asset, nor one tied to smart contracts.
Sounds like a feature to me. Printing money is effectively a socialized loss for everyone who's holding the currency.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoA currency is a socioeconomic compact between capital and labor, intermediated by subject matter experts (ie the central bank) and government. > Sounds like a feature to me. Printing money is effectively a socialized loss for everyone who's holding the currency. The economy functioning is of greater benefit to the whole than the value to currency hoarders (remember, it's a currency, it's meant for exchange not for value storage and it is optimized for that role) maintaining its value. If you want to preserve wealth, own property/assets you expect people to trade their time or capital for into the future. People don't buy stonks or bonds for the ticker in their account, they buy the appreciation of the underlying or its cashflow. Most people buy real estate to live in (utility), for the appreciation of the property, or for the rental income cash flow (caveat is folks like the Chinese buying up international property to store their wealth outside of the reach of the CCP).
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y ago>>>>> The economy functioning is of greater benefit to the whole than the value of currency hoarders maintaining its value. If you want to preserve wealth, own things you expect people to trade their time or capital for into the future. Retirees on a fixed income; immigrants, the poor, and people with no access to credit would like to have a word with you
- toomuchtodo 5y agoHave the word with me. That's what cost of living adjustments (social security or other systems) & prudently investing a lifetime of retirement savings (in a safe mix of investments to support both growth and safety) and improved underwriting and funding for those folks (respectively) is for. It's not an issue with the currency, that's not what currencies are for. If you're expecting the value of a currency to never change, you are asking a fish to climb a tree.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y ago>>>>> That's what cost of living adjustments (social security or other systems) Isnt that also... Insolvent? >>>> prudently investing a lifetime of retirement savings Would you deem people that invested on bonds of the US govt, GM, that they invested prudently? >>>>If you're expecting the value of a currency to never change, you are asking a fish to climb a tree. Change implies movement in both directions. Yet what we are seeing is a clear, pronounced, increasing onedirectional slope
- emn13 5y agoWhile I'm sure you have a point that some people are getting shafted by lack of inflation compensation, what does that imply for stablecoins vs. conventional banks and/or central banks? That issue could occur in any system with expanding money supply, and you want a system in which the money supply expands in some sync with the economy, because otherwise it's attractive to just hoard paper (or crypto, or whatever) wealth and not invest. In any case, isn't this primarily a political problem (or where the issue is private: a problem of a poorly phrased or one-sided contract)?
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI actually dont know enough about stablecoins to opine. They may be fraud for all i know. My issue was with the casual dismissal of inflation as some kind of necessity for a functioning economy. My point is that is a priviled worldview of a typical elite that has never experienced poverty or real inflation in the flesh. Dismissing it as some kind of magic drug with annoying side effects shows lack of empathy for real consequences at the bottom 5th. Are stablecoins better than central banks? Again, I dont know enough about stablecoins. But surely whatever answer that is out there does not include inflation or central banks as they exist today.
- emn13 5y agoThe fact that some inflation is beneficial clearly is the commonly received wisdom, including by whatever experts I could find; I couldn't find any trustworthy source arguing the opposite. A casual dismissal of inflation being necessary is therefore warranted - at least unless there's some extraordinary level of evidence provided, or if my skimming of publically available opinion is somehow wrong (sure, could be!). It's the official policy of the Fed, for instance. Additionally, note that the money supply is ever growing - faster than inflation because the economy is growing. Now, there are apparently extra factors to consider here, including concepts like the velocity of money, which mean that money supply isn't trivially linked 1-to-1 to the economy's expansion and inflation. I'm no expert on the matter, to be clear, but that's my impression trying to search even for refutations of that stance - if your impression of commonly held expert opinion is different, it'd be interesting to compare links to check whether our media bubbles differ somewhere. We cannot rule out that stablecoins might serve us well. But just because we have imperfect information does not mean all possibilities are equally risking; the risks from conventional monetary policy (including variations such as modern monetary theory) are simply much better understood because we have examples and history to learn from. The original article makes the case that stablecoins aren't really all that novel as a financial instrument (even though their technical underpinnings might be), and the argument appears sound to me (a non expert) and the source reliable (with a reputation at risk were their analysis clearly wrong). As such, why should we ignore risks we understand, and take on additional risks we don't understand? At issue here isn't really the fact that it's a cryptocoin, but rather how it functions in the financial market. The article explicitly calls out that the technical implementation may have benefits, and a knee-jerk ban could be overzealous. The issue is essentially financial, not crypto related, and I don't see any clearly open questions that might argue for allowing unregulated stablecoins, let alone a refutation of the premise that stablecoins have risks. Posing questions makes it sound like we should wait and see; but we should not wait to answer those questions given what we do know. Policy could _always_ be better informed in the future; that does not mean delay is _always_ the best choice.
- wins32767 5y agoI hear that poor people and those with no access to credit also do particularly well when the economy goes into depression (as would happen with massive bank failures).
- CryptoPunk 5y ago>>A currency is a socioeconomic compact between capital and labor, intermediated by subject matter experts (ie the central bank) and government. Currency is an asset with a particular use-case. Its consumers do not enter into some elaborate agreement (compact) in order to use it. They use it because it's useful. Currency predates the government: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/05/210506174103.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/05/210506174103.h... It arose as an emergent property of market interaction, i.e. distributed processes, not centralized authorities. EDIT, responding to below: No, the distributed processes of the market are a collective intelligence that vastly outperforms any single entity at the task of effectively managing the money supply. See Selgin's articles on free banking: https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/29/there-was-no-place-like-canada/ https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/29/there-was-no-place-like-can...
- shadowgovt 5y agoCorrect. The centralized authorities protect the economy against some failure-modes that a distributed process is vulnerable to (currency scarcities, tampering, panics, large-scale theft). They introduce other problems. Whether one thinks they introduce more problems than they fix is pretty much the defining factor on where one stands regarding the utility of fiat currencies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- emn13 5y agoI understand the point you're making, but I'd like to add that even if you accept that potentially stablecoins might avoid some problems a (politically tainted) central bank has, the issue isn't merely one of accepting that possibility, it's also one of lack of evidence and novelty. Having a bunch of private actors potentially run a huge experiment in which the economic fallout will not be born by them if it goes sideways is entirely unreasonable. I mean, that's kind of the whole problem with banks and their dodgy behavior, and this is no better; if anything it's even more risky since it's even less well understood and there's even less oversight, and fewer ways even a democratically elected government could intervene should the need and popular mandate arise. I'm all for running that experiment, but then with proper oversight, accountability, transparency, disaster planning, etc - and as much as possible without the conflict of interest caused by having those running the system own large stakes of it too; that's just asking for shady business.
- xur17 5y agoBut this means that all users of USD are providing an insurance pool for the banks for free. Doesn't quite seem fair. There are some decentralized stablecoins (stablecoins backed by crypto assets + market rules that ensure they keep the peg) that have explicit insurance pools + rewards for being part of that insurance pool. For example, Liquity [0] allows users to deposit the stablecoin and earn rewards + favorable liquidation positions (a 10% discount) in return for being the first layer that purchases liquidations. Not exactly sure what the equivalent would be in the traditional finance world, but I could imagine some sort of higher interest savings account that isn't FDIC insured, and takes losses first. [0] https://www.liquity.org/ https://www.liquity.org/
- cinquemb 5y ago> There are some decentralized stablecoins Most people clamoring for regs around stablecoins haven't gotten a chance to wrap their minds around this yet… nor have most of them considered the $ demom "cash and cash equivalents" that are on banks balance sheets not domiciled in the US, who have even smaller cash flows than some centralized stablecoin issuers folks love to pick on…
- wins32767 5y agoWe've run this experiment before. Look at the number and severity of recessions/depressions prior to fiat currency and after.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoI don't believe there has ever been non-inflationary money before in the whole history of humankind. Add the saying goes, "bad money drives out good." In this case it probably means that crypto coins will mostly be held as an asset while national currencies are used for most transactions. Looking around, that certainly appears to be what is happening.