4 ms·
One problem in these discussions is the curve of value delivered by an individual developer in a particular situation is short-and-wide and while I agree the se
by sokoloff 5y ago
One problem in these discussions is the curve of value delivered by an individual developer in a particular situation is short-and-wide and while I agree the senior developers are on a curve shifted to the right, there’s a massive amount of overlap.
Most company’s best 5% 25 year-old developers are probably creating more value than their median 50 year-old developer, even though that median senior dev is creating more value than the median 25 year-old.
- nicoburns 5y ago> One problem in these discussions is the curve of value delivered by an individual developer in a particular situation is short-and-wide I kind of disagree with this, although I don't think it's age that separates developers. But developers who can work independently are a lot more valuable than those that require close supervision, and those developers are considerably more value than those who are actively destroying value.
- sokoloff 5y agoIf I understand your comment correctly, I think we're agreeing (that there is a wide range [high variance] of value delivered across the population: think of a bell curve that's "smooshed" down to be short and wide).
- nicoburns 5y agoQuite possibly. I realised after I posted that I wasn't quite sure what the axis of your plot were (I'm still not).
- sokoloff 5y agoX axis is value delivered per engineer, increasing with X. Y axis is a histogram of “number of engineers producing that value”, increasing with Y. This, but for value instead of IQ: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:IQ_curve.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:IQ_curve.svg
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoYes, when you look at those differences any performance drop due to age is going to look tiny in comparison. What I have found though is a lack of willingness to put up with bullshit. Stuff I accepted as normal in my twenties I'd just walk away from now. This is probably good for the employer but maybe not for your immediate manager.
- spaetzleesser 5y ago“ But developers who can work independently are a lot more valuable than those that require close supervision, and those developers are considerably more value than those who are actively destroying value.” True. But most people reach that point after a few years or never.
- eastbayjake 5y agoYes, you hit the plateau of that curve pretty quickly. You can't just be an individual contributor and justify 3% raises every year for 30 years, when you hit that plateau on raw skill you need to start finding ways to player-coach the generation(s) of more junior developers behind you. I don't think that necessarily means you have to move into management, but it does mean broadening your definition of impact beyond LoC/commits/tickets.
- sokoloff 5y ago1.5 to 3.0% of those 3% raises are inflation/cost-of-living adjustment, which seem like they should be able to continue forever.
- Aperocky 5y ago> broadening your definition of impact beyond LoC/commits/tickets. Is this the 'classic' expectation for a dev? Where I work the least technical person is the PM and everyone else comes together to determine what gets done and how it gets done. Everyone knows the tech side and decisions gets filtered down to the rank and file. Taking initiatives are expected - I know this is likely the exception not the norm, but I hope future workplaces are more like this and less like that.
- Tarucho 5y ago>One problem in these discussions is the curve of value delivered by an individual developer in a particular situation is short-and-wide and while I agree the senior developers are on a curve shifted to the right, there’s a massive amount of overlap. This can also be said of managers. Then why aren´t they discriminated by age too?
- spaetzleesser 5y agoBecause they are smarter and work the system. Same for sales guys, lawyers and so on. They work the system to their advantage. Developers are one of the few groups that believes in a just meritocracy.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoAgree about the value curve. Most developers do stuff that can be learned in a few years and then they just repeat the same thing with slight variation. There are really not that many jobs where you get challenged to grow throughout your career. It’s just repetition (like most other jobs)
- sokoloff 5y agoAlso known as "1 year of experience, 12 times" (or "2 years, 6 times")
- Retric 5y agoI frequently hear that, but in practically every other profession doing the exact same thing for 20 years is still valued. And the underlying reality is you can’t do the exact same thing for 12 years in the computer field. Experience is all the little edge cases that cropped up over time.
- canadian_tired 5y ago"Experience is all the little edge cases that cropped up over time." Absolutely. I will be using this one.
- Tarucho 5y agoThis is not exclusive to dev work. Same can be said of managers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoAnyone in the trades is doing such a job. If you're a plumber, or electrician, or cabinet maker, or framing carpenter, or a mechanic, even if those 12 years (or 20 years or more) seem similar to people outside the field, you're learning all the time. It never stops, until you do.
- spaetzleesser 5y ago
- Retric 5y agoI’ve worked with a lot of young developers and never met a 25 year old developer that’s creating more value than the average 50 year old developer with 20+ years experience. In theory sure it’s possible, but in practice it simply doesn’t happen even close to 5% of the time. The thing is most people quit the field long before putting in 20+ years. So, I suspect it’s less about the experience than the filtering process.
- France_is_bacon 5y agoSo senior devs are better than 95% of 25 year olds. Since finding a "best 5%" is almost impossible, because who knows until you hire them and they work there for a while, the best bet is to hire people who are older. Also, for a bone fide best 5%, they are going to work at the cool companies, and never will work at a sewer processing government utility company in their IT department, or work at for a local chain of tire stores with 50 locations and an IT staff of 3 people. So, one might as well not even worry about the top 5%.