4 ms·
> Either way, after a few plays it was destined to disappear due to regular wear and tear on the record's groove. Is vinyl really that delicate, or were record
by criddell 5y ago
> Either way, after a few plays it was destined to disappear due to regular wear and tear on the record's groove.
Is vinyl really that delicate, or were record players in the 60's put more downforce on the needle?
- sumtechguy 5y agoOne of the two surfaces is going to be 'softer'. Either the needle or the disc. Usually the disc lost out.
- spijdar 5y agoOn top of that, because of the way audio was recorded to vinyl, the higher frequency a sound was, there would be a disproportionate amount of wear/friction, I think. Either way, in this case the article is referring to the ultrasonic tone, and not to the records overall.
- Someone 5y agoThe explanation for that is simple: the groove is a 1:1 copy of the sound wave, so higher frequency sounds have smaller details in the groove. Those details wear away faster than larger ones. All mechanical record players have to pick a middle ground between picking up the sound wave and keeping the record surface pristine. To prevent wear, you want the needle to exert as little pressure as possible. That calls for a large needle that’s only lightly pressed onto the record surface. Unfortunately, that is exactly what you don’t need if you want to reliably pick up the signal. To prevent the needle from jumping from peak to peak in the groove due to its inertia, you want to press it onto the disk. Also, for the needle to pick up higher frequencies, it can’t be large (it has to be able to ‘fall’ into the grooves between the tops in the signal, and those are closer together for higher-frequency signals)
- wheels 5y ago> the groove is a 1:1 copy of the sound wave False. There's an EQ curve that's applied to all records that rolls off the bass, which has to be re-added by the preamp. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization
- rwmj 5y agoWhich of course made a change from 78s where it was the needle that wore out on the hard shellac disc.
- wut42 5y agoI think it's both. Many players were not that gentle at the time (and, actually still is nowadays). Edit: I remembered that my dad frequently added a small coin on the top of the needle to avoid skips. So people weren't gentle with the vinyls and the needles either. It could also be that vinyl and RIAA encoding was made mostly for the range of the human ears, and such a high frequency would just wear way faster than the "normal" ones, but I'm speculating there. IIRC, the high frequencies are "higher" in the groove.
- d_tr 5y agoLarger amplitudes and frequencies should give steeper slopes on the groove and therefore larger forces and friction, makes perfect sense. Isn't this why more heavily used vinyls sound a bit muffled?
- lostgame 5y agoWell; that or, of course - general wear and tear or even dust in the grooves. Vinyl is very sensitive.
- d_tr 5y agoSure!
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIn spite of the legend, the needle doesn't get hot enough to melt the groove. But repeated pressure does deform it slightly. And the HF detail in the groove is already so tiny that it doesn't take much to wear/deform it away. Vinyl really is the most ridiculous medium for music. I get the appeal of a large collectible object wrapped in stunning sleeve art, but in terms of audio quality it's the equivalent of a cheap plastic LOMO lens.
- numpad0 5y agoI have heard a different explanation for coin trick, that you could add weights to match the heaviest cartridge/shell setup in your collection, so that any of it when installed exerts desired tracking force without having to balance the arm each time. I wonder whether having end mass at the shell helped or if both were cases of such first world problems.