4 ms·
I hadn't read the book itself, but had got a different message. I thought that most of these people happened to run successful businesses in poorer communities
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I hadn't read the book itself, but had got a different message.
I thought that most of these people happened to run successful businesses in poorer communities (often immigrant) where their peers were all relatively poor. They therefore didn't get caught on a treadmill where expected gifts and living standards drive everyone to spend all their money on keeping up with the Joneses. Most of the community have little money, not because they're stupid or wasteful just because they're starting from very little. So the outlier has no real need to spend the money and just banks it in their business against downturns and over time it builds up.
Interesting as a phenomenon, but it sounds they were drawing very broad conclusions from that for their book.
- zhdc1 5y agoThomas Stanley was a marketing by professor who made a name for himself teaching others how to sell to the rich. The Millionaire Next Door was largely written to dissuade people of the notion the hyper consumerism and associated advertising was an effective strategy for reaching a majority of upper wealth households. Wealthy households are generally frugal compared to their level of net worth. This is particularly true for wealthy households at the lower end of the scale (e.g., the millionaire teacher who got that way by investing 15% of their net income consistently over 30-40 years). Immigrants and business owners do have an advantage, and he goes into detail about how living in less wealthy neighborhoods is a wealth building advantage, but his main argument is that thrift, savings, and simple math are the main drivers of wealth.
- mojuba 5y agoThat, and also I think communities setting consumerist standards (houses this size, cars this make and year) are mostly suburb type. In big cities it's easier to hide your real worth since people mostly socialize outdoors and for example the car-show-off effect is minimal. When you meet someone in a big city chances are they won't even see what type of car you own. These things become less relevant in this type of environments, at least from my experience. The big city is the place where you can save on things you probably don't need. Move to the city, find reasonable accommodation which I believe is possible even in places like London and Paris, and just don't buy or do things that you don't see contributing to your life goals much. Just enjoy the vibrant and inclusive environment that's a big city. Socialize, exchange ideas, and save save save.
- peter303 5y agoThe book has two messages: (1) Spend less than you earn. Thats why your unassuming neighbor could be well off. (2) Businesspeople build wealth faster than employees, even if they fail a couple times along the way.