3 ms·
These techniques were the best ancient technology could manage, but wouldn't satisfy most people today. The initially described version can bring your house do
by londons_explore 5y ago
These techniques were the best ancient technology could manage, but wouldn't satisfy most people today.
The initially described version can bring your house down to the temperature of high up air (ground level air might be 50C because the surface of the ground is heated a lot by the sun, whereas air 10 meters up is much cooler).
The version with water cooling can bring your house down to the wet bulb temperature of high up air.
But modern people expect a temperature lower than both of those using refrigeration. And then they keep that coolness in using good insulation (neither of which were available in the ancient world).
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> And then they keep that coolness in using good insulation (neither of which were available in the ancient world). Good insultation to keep cool in summer and warm in winter used to be provided by thick stone walls, which have quit some thermal inertia. Just look at traditional houses in Southern Europe, for example. They are cooler than 'modern' houses because of that and because people nowadays insist on having a lot of glass (large windows, large patio sliding doors, etc), which turns buildings into greenhouses (and walls are thinner)... and then people install air-con to compensate.
- cafard 5y agoOr adobe, as used in the US southwest.
- cbg0 5y agoTraditionally houses didn't have a lot of windows because glass wasn't as good as it is today when it comes to insulation. Triple glazed windows are becoming a standard in a lot of places. People also didn't spend that much time indoors because they didn't have anything to do. Times have changed and the needs of the people have changed. Walls being thinner nowadays is due to the advances in options available for construction & insulation, not to mention safety standards. Modern ceramic bricks with air pockets + 10cm of polystyrene on the outside for insulation is insanely efficient for most residential establishments.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI may be wrong but I feel thick stone walls are a bit like having large buckets of water in a greenhouse: They regulate temperature, whereas modern insulated walls don't because they are indeed just very good insulators. As for double or triple glazed windows, they are good at keeping the heat in but in my experience they are not that good at keeping the heat out: sunlight gets in and heats up surfaces, the whole room warms up, and then the heat is trapped. A traditional way to try to keep cool in Southern Europe is to open the windows to create airflow while closing the shutters to keep sunlight and heat out. Now, of course this makes rooms quite shady. Villages completely quiet with shutters closed during 'siesta' are famous to the point of stereotype but that's a real adaptation: Stay cool and avoid efforts during the hottest part of the day.
- geraneum 5y agoI have been there in a few of these buildings that use wind catchers. I can say that, as a modern day human, these work pretty well in their dry weather! I can that see you've never experienced it and maybe your skepticism is a result of that, but your reasoning is not sound. For example, a significant number of "modern people" here in Germany don't have AC in their households. Point being, there are different people in the world with different conditions and not everyone expects the exact same thing. Also insulation is not a product of the modern world. We just now have modern methods for it.