3 ms·
Can you point to one of these suits and its outcomes? The USFS opens up every national forest in California to timber harvesting, every year, and has done so s
by jeffbee 5y ago
Can you point to one of these suits and its outcomes? The USFS opens up every national forest in California to timber harvesting, every year, and has done so since I can remember. You only have to spend about 1 minute hiking a national forest in California to hear the saws and trucks.
Here, for example, are all the currently-available timber sales in the Plumas Nat'l Forest, which is currently extensively on fire.
https://www.fs.usda.gov/wps/portal/fsinternet/cs/resourcelist?ss=110511&navtype=110511&cid=FSEPRD607802&navid=130120000000000&pnavid=130000000000000&position=TimberSales*&groupid=Y&ttype=detaillist&pname=Plumas%20National%20Forest%20-%20Resource%20Management https://www.fs.usda.gov/wps/portal/fsinternet/cs/resourcelis...
- Trisell 5y agoHere is an opinion article for Montana of one such group. This is typical of most of these groups. They prevent logging by getting injunctions against any logging project on National Forest Land. https://mtstandard.com/news/opinion/editorial/allow-the-forest-service-to-do-its-job-without-frivolous-lawsuits/article_09585582-1be6-5831-bcd3-542d617a078a.html https://mtstandard.com/news/opinion/editorial/allow-the-fore...
- jeffbee 5y agoWell OK, you said they had sued every logging plan without exception. That seems like an exaggeration. I'm looking at a USDA document right now that says 50 million board feet were harvested in California in the first 90 days of 2021, and last year totaled 2.5 billion board feet nationwide. Maybe that's not as much as you'd like, but it is still the case that timber is harvested in every forest, every year. The entire purpose of the USFS is to provide wood products to America. They aren't parks.
- Trisell 5y agoI was being hyperbolic to make a point, but you have at best proven that some suits do seem get overturned and some logging does happen. I will say that I think more logging, under regulation, should be allowed as the current 2.5b BF doesn’t seem to be enough considering the vast acreages that the federal government controls in the west. And given fire load of dead and down trees that I’ve seen over the years in our National Forests. To quote the article I posted. “Frivolous lawsuits over the past 20-30 years have nearly eliminated logging from forest management, and our forests have suffered and much of the current wildfires around us are the results. What once were healthy, diverse ecosystems with early successional and mature forests are now too often monocultures of insect and disease-ridden dead and dying trees primed for catastrophic wildfire.”
- newbamboo 5y agohttps://sempervirens.org/about/story/ https://sempervirens.org/about/story/ Santa Cruz mountains burned last year and it could have been less devastating to f there were more thinning allowed. Thinning != clearcutting. Often there are interests besides the environment that come into play. People live in these forests. Trees prevent landslides. It’s complicated.
- wumpus 5y agoHomeowners in that area are required to remove brush and fuel around their houses by insurance companies. Why do you think thinning (cutting down live trees) is needed? The link you give doesn't talk about thinning, and is (unusually) mostly talking about old growth forest. Is an organization preserving old growth forest actually calling for cutting down live trees?
- newbamboo 5y agoIt’s not a great example of an area that would benefit from thinning but it is an example. Fires in coastal zones in California are very different from those in the Sierras where thinning is more important. Parent asked for an example though and so the Santa Cruz mountains fires last year came to mind. Logging of any sort, even on your own property, is strictly prohibited. Most of the area was cleared a hundred years back, the old growth is in isolated areas like big basin. It’s important to understand that coastal California fires are less due to over abundance of fuel and more due to human encroachment. Certainly the Santa Cruz mountains were due for a big one given the abundance of fuel and increasingly dry climate. Like I said it’s very complicated. The sierras in contrast would undoubtedly benefit from logging/thinning. We have now the largest fire on record with the Dixie fire. Comparisons to the past miss the point. We can’t just go back to how things used to be with occasional fires taking out small areas, making the ecosystem more heterogeneous. Fires are bigger and hotter now, the fuel is more abundant and drier.
- wumpus 5y agoGreat that you have all of the answers, do you have any sources to back up the need for thinning?