3 ms·
Ask HN: License to enforce open source on models trained from public code?
New technologies like GitHub Copilot or OpenAI Codex use public code to train their models to generate code.
Is there a license to enforce open source upon output trained from public code? Is there a new license in the works? I don't want to prohibit training.
I previously thought that current GPL compatible licensed code was enough but I've seen some cases of it being violated under the guise of fair use, with models outputting code without any attribution and relicensed in non-compatible ways.
AGPL added a requirement to close the server-side loophole, is there a license that covers the new "AI scraping/training loophole" or a new clause perhaps be added to account for AI-training? (i.e. if you train a model using the given code, your model must also allow others to download the source code/training set/model corresponding to the output)
- wmf 5y agoSome experts are saying this can't be fixed because licenses simply don't apply to machine learning. I think the real question is how much money you have to spend on lawyers.
- promisebyte 5y agoHow would proprietary licenses apply or do you only mean current FOSS licenses? For example, Epic lets anyone who sign up access the source code to Unreal Engine on GitHub through a private repo. It's under a proprietary license but I can't imagine Epic being happy if someone were to use it for AI training (although this sounds like a case where money and lawyers comes in).
- wmf 5y agoThey're saying you can train models on super-proprietary code without permission and use the output however you want because fair use.