4 ms·
I'd rather burn the forest than allow logging. Logging always turns into felling the valuable trees (read--old trees that fire leaves alone) and leaving behind
by bsder 5y ago
I'd rather burn the forest than allow logging.
Logging always turns into felling the valuable trees (read--old trees that fire leaves alone) and leaving behind the scrub that feeds the fires.
- billclerico 5y agoThis used to be true, but really no longer is with modern logging practices and regulation
- quantified 5y agoGiven human nature and economic imperatives, I think some skepticism is warranted.
- robbedpeter 5y agoExactly, so we better do nothing at all and cower behind the maybes as the world literally burns down around us.
- quantified 5y agoThat would not be the right approach. What’s a maybe, or perhaps which maybe are you referring to, since there are several possible ones. (Suggest you include a sarcasm indicator if you’re being sarcastic.) Just pointing out that since people are involved, it’s very reasonable to think that there are going to be bad actors acting badly along with any benefit that might come from this. In response to words that said bad actors are gone from the scene. Do you disagree?
- pvaldes 5y agoLoggers can be directly behind some fires also. Is well known that loggers in the south of Europe had been caught starting wildfires with the goal to buy the logs cheaper later (still suitable for paper pulp) or to have an excuse to steal the oldest trees that were perfectly viable but slightly charred. The practice stopped by new laws regulating the sell of burnt wood, but it was popular once (and can be still active in other parts of the planet). Anything that could be claimed as an excuse type 'this tree was ill so it must be taken down' is a temptation for promoting wildfires. And these survivor elder trees are necessary also. Some caterpillars are borers and kill trees in mass, creating a lot of extra fuel. Woodpeckers are among the only animals capable to remove larvae that dig deeper in the trunks. Respecting a few dead trees (here and there) where woodpeckers nest can reduce the final amount of fuel. More dense population of woodpeckers -> less larvae -> more trees surviving the attack -> less extensive patches of new dead wood ready to burn. Another reason to be very careful with the idea of a free unlimited pass to logging after wildfires.
- Trisell 5y agoModern logging does no such thing. These contracts limit the size of trees that can be cut. Prevent clear cutting and force replanting all as a part of good forest management. Clear cutting all trees in the forest are a thing of the past. Loggers have come to understand the need to manage and promote growth and long term usage. Not just clear and cut of years gone by.
- fzzzy 5y agoThat's not what I have seen the loggers in my neighborhood do in the last few years. They still just clearcut and don't even re-plant.
- lostapathy 5y agoDon’t confuse logging in a managed forest with what happens in a “tree farm”. The latter is much more aggressive at logging but also at planing new trees. It’s a business and the land is an asset they are taking care of.
- Trisell 5y agoAre they logging public lands or private. Because those are two very different venues.
- giantrobot 5y agoFires are unconcerned with property lines.
- hinkley 5y agoDrive in a circle around Seattle and sigh at all of the rectangular clearcuts on hilly terrain. Worst of the worst.
- MisterTea 5y agoSounds like land clearing for building.
- kriskrunch 5y agoIt doesn't matter if the flames don't reach to the tips of the largest tree's uppermost branches. These fires burn so hot it kills their roots and even little animals hiding in their burrows underground. Driving through northern California on my way to Washington, a couple of weeks ago, I could see whole forests are dead where the fires went through. Large trees, scrub, everything.