2 ms·
Remember that Tolkien was a scholar in Medieval languages and also studied more modern folklore to some degree, and drew much material from those sources. Some
by wolverine876 5y ago
Remember that Tolkien was a scholar in Medieval languages and also studied more modern folklore to some degree, and drew much material from those sources. Some elements in D&D might come from the same sources or from more recent writers who drew from the same myths. That is, similarities between D&D and Tolkien are not all due to Tolkien's influence.
While Tolkien is clearly an influence, there are many, many others too; to a degree AD&D seems to me to be a collection of all the myths Gygax knew or found. There is much in the Monster Manual that isn't in Tolkien (the medusa, demons and devils, etc.). Apparently some creatures in the Monster Manual came from a bag of plastic toys, which the authors used for inspiration and created backstories.