4 ms·
The section titled "Eviction moratoriums may hurt mom-and-pop landlords and favor corporate ones" is absolutely true, and it will result in even more wealth con
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
The section titled "Eviction moratoriums may hurt mom-and-pop landlords and favor corporate ones" is absolutely true, and it will result in even more wealth concentration.
I have a family member who had the misfortune to rent out a house he previously lived in (he was moving and due to some issues in the neighborhood wanted to rent his old house out for a year before selling) in Feb of 2020. I think his renter paid one month of rent, and then nothing after that. And I looked the guy up, I have sympathy for people who are really on hard times or who lost jobs but this dude is a grifter who is just taking advantage of the situation.
So he's lived there coming on 18 months paying absolutely nothing. My relative was fortunate enough to get a good dose of rental assistance (as this article said, the process was extremely chaotic), but I guarantee he will never be a landlord again. The risk/rewards of a tenant/landlord relationship used to feel well known, but now it feels like the government can basically commandeer your property at will.
So this means you are just going to be left with large corporate landlords who are diversified enough that they can take the risk. And what makes me so angry about this is that, as someone who is generally on the "left" side of the political spectrum, I see all these calls for "cancel rent", as if housing grows on trees and landlords are all some kind of Ebenezer stereotype, instead of being a lot of small-time folk just trying to get by.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI see it too, and the answer seems to be that if we just socialism hard enough, everything will work out alright. This time, this time it will work.
- uglygoblin 5y agoThis is reductive and the reality is the system typically fights hard against socialistic policy so we end up with half solutions like a moratorium instead of the government paying the rents on behalf of the tenants. Now you claim "Socialism. Bad." because of it.
- at_a_remove 5y agoHey, speaking of reductive ... your interpretation of what I said is a great example of that. As the parent poster said, most landlords are small-timers, but they get caricatured as New York slumlords scarfing down caviar while their tenants flinch over continually sparking bare wires flicker from a partially torn down kitchen wall. We have seen how the legislation passed for relief got warped to pay out to the big timers (just think of those hotel chains) instead of focusing on the smaller folks. But when I bring up points like this, I just get the "well, if we abolished private property and everyone had a government-issued home ..." And the parent poster has had experience with that kind of comeback.
- antifa 5y agoCan you be more specific about what you mean by this? There's something like 1 to 4 socialists in congress, which makes them a powerless fringe minority, so it's confusing that you would talk about them as if they were in charge.
- spaceflunky 5y ago>but now it feels like the government can basically commandeer your property at will. This is one of the scariest outcomes of the eviction moratorium. It is basically solidified the fact that you own nothing and the government can take and do with "your" property as it pleases when it pleases. >you are just going to be left with large corporate landlords who are diversified enough that they can take the risk. Again, so very true. Why do people think that big corporate landlords are going to be better than the small mom and pops they killed off? Soon everyone who rents will be paying to large kafkaesque monolith who makes you wait on the phone for 5 hours every time you have a problem.
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago> This is one of the scariest outcomes of the eviction moratorium. It is basically solidified the fact that you own nothing and the government can take and do with "your" property as it pleases when it pleases. Well, but it's property you've rented out to someone else. IMO, once you've done that, it doesn't truly belong to just you, even if the deed is in your name. Someone else has set up their life in your space—and that's why most localities have laws about when you can evict someone and the process you have to go through.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> which is why most localities have laws about when you can evict someone and the process you have to go through. Never has there been a law that says you cannot evict somebody after 18 months of not paying rent. I think people who continue to blame business owners are being rather obtuse and dishonest about their stance.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI agree, I just think extrapolating "you own nothing and the government can take and do with 'your' property as it pleases" is going more than a little far! Honestly, a better example of that would be eminent domain, which existed long before COVID. (I so happen to be in favor of eminent domain too, but now we're getting truly off topic!)
- alexgmcm 5y agoI don't understand how they expect tenants to be able to backpay all the rent if they weren't able to work due to the pandemic. If they were prevented from working or lost their jobs due to the Government lockdowns it only seems fair the Government pays their rent.
- tartoran 5y agoInstead the government orders the landlord to caugh up the money. I think these landlords should sue the government and recover their losses
- josephcsible 5y agoFor the first few months' worth of rent, sure. But for recent rent, when they've been allowed to return to work but chose not to, no way.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoHow about this: Either the government lets you evict them, or the government pays their rent. But if the government prohibits evictions of non-paying tenants, and doesn't itself pay, how is that not "private property be[ing] taken for public use, without just compensation", and therefore a violation of the Fifth Amendment?
- josephcsible 5y agoThat definitely fixes the problem for the landlords, but I don't really like the idea of my tax dollars subsidizing deadbeats. What if the government paid the rent for now, but then came after the renters for it later with the same force that the IRS does?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIt fixes the problem with the Constitution. The rest is "merely" a matter of the normal government functions of deciding who to take money from and what to spend it on, which will get sorted out in the normal political way.
- badjeans 5y ago> I see all these calls for "cancel rent", as if housing grows on trees and landlords are all some kind of Ebenezer stereotype, instead of being a lot of small-time folk just trying to get by. So letting property should just be risk-free profit? Being a landlord is a business and businesses fail all the time.
- josephcsible 5y agoBusinesses fail all the time, even though other kinds of businesses aren't required to keep providing products/services to people who stopped paying for them.
- throwawaycities 5y agoI think the idea is that landlords did accept a risk that if tenants did not pay they would have the legal remedy to evict them. It was the government that took away their legal remedy without any due process. Comparing it to any other business, imagine the government coming in and saying you will continue having to operate your business but your customers no longer have to pay.
- Decker87 5y agoWhere did you get that from?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 5y agoFor what it's worth it's not like there's absolutely zero recourse. If the person is a grifter, in the sense that he actually does have money and just doesn't feel like paying, he can usually be pursued in civil court for the balance and a judgement can be entered. Sure if the person has no assets at all or declares bankruptcy then that won't help. But in that case he's in the category of people that don't have any money. I think a lot of people are unaware that there is a distinction between an eviction proceeding, which is a proceeding seeking the equitable remedy of dispossessing someone from a property, and a proceeding for damages, where you try to recover the money they should have paid you. Eviction proceedings are typically in a specific housing court and rules are often stricter and have a lot of local subtlety. For example sometimes you can only pay a portion of what you owe to dismiss an eviction proceeding, and so on. That doesn't necessarily change the amount of money actually owed though, which can still be recovered the normal way with a regular old lawsuit for breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and so on.
- joshgrib 5y agoI think a good (or at least simple) solution for this problem is to increase taxes on non-primary residences, as a simple case the tax rate could be: 20% + 10%/extra house So if you own 9 houses you're paying 100% in taxes, making it untenable to be a large-scale landlord. This should cause a bunch of housing to go on the market with people wanting to avoid that tax risk, also driving housing costs down
- josephcsible 5y agoHow do you suppose this would work with, e.g., high-rise apartment buildings?
- joshgrib 5y agoYeah that's definitely one of the holes, I think it would have to be as condos that are for sale - and not solely as units to rent. Not a foolproof plan, but we could at least make it a law for normal single-family housing as a start and then figure out what makes sense elsewhere. Housing definitely seems complicated enough that you can't have one simple solution and we'll need a bunch of things that each help out a little bit
- throwaway24124 5y agoSurely if this guy is a known grifter it would've come up in a background check or credit check when he applied for the apartment. There is always a large risk that a tenant fails to pay rent, even before covid. If anything, your family member benefitted from the government offering rental assistance. It sounds like he wasn't fully aware of those risks when he decided to become a landlord. Being a landlord has never been a risk-free investment, but landlords love to pretend they are the victim anytime that risk doesn't pay off.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> Being a landlord has never been a risk-free investment Never in a million years would any reasonable person think the government would come in and say "I don't care if they don't pay you for 18 months, you have to keep a roof over their head and play landlord to a complete deadbeat". That is a contingency so far out of the norm it is a bit ridiculous to blame business owners for not preparing. Blaming businesses for "not being prepared" for massive, completely unexpected government overreach is pretty lame.
- vb6sp6 5y agoIt's convenient that we skip over the fact that the landlord did receive money from the feds
- throwaway24124 5y agoNo landlord has been receiving $0 in rent for the last 18 months. Either they accepted rental assistance from the government (covering the full amount of missing rent) or they have declined rental assistance from the government, and have evicted the tenant. The most strict eviction moratorium is in California, which bars "evictions if renters file a declaration about their financial hardships, and if they pay at least 25% of their debt by the end of January 2021." Also, unless the landlord entered a 2 year lease with a tenant in February 2020, why would a landlord choose to renew a lease with a tenant who is paying $0? These eviction moratoriums do not just let any tenant stay and pay $0, there are very strict guidelines for what kind of tenants are not allowed to be evicted and for how long. Additionally, during the Great Recession, the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act was passed which required 3 month notice to tenants before beginning the eviction process, so I do think it's fair to blame landlords if they are not able to afford their investment properties when a few months of rent is not paid on time.
- pvarangot 5y ago> now it feels like the government can basically commandeer your property at will Owning property is basically a contract with a whole different kind of "governments" saying they will progressively use their soldiers to defend your property if it gets invaded by different kind of actors. So yeah. Your friend is not the only one that got to see the harsher side of what the government is during the pandemic. People basically had their jobs made "illegal" from one week to the other because they were "unhealthy", like prostitution basically but yeah now suddenly selling luxury clothes on a mall was also like that.
- vb6sp6 5y agowhy would he renew the lease for someone that isn't paying?
- josephcsible 5y agoWhat do you think an eviction moratorium means? If tenants don't want to leave, landlords are powerless to make them, no matter what's in the lease.
- vb6sp6 5y agoare you a landlord?
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoHow is that question relevant?
- _jal 5y ago> now it feels like the government can basically commandeer your property at will. I understand it feels more salient now, but the government basically always could. They will take it over late tax payments amounting to a tiny fraction of the value. They will take it to sell it to developers, who may not ever build anything there. Cops will hound you until you leave if you meet some pre-crime criteria. Or take it outright, if you rent to someone who cultivates illegal vegetation. Or destroy it, chasing someone who might not even be in it, and you will not be reimbursed for this sort of 'taking'. I get that the eviction thing seems new, and the goal is actually somewhat novel. But 'property rights' have never been as strong as a lot of people think. (All of those things have happened fairly recently. I'm not going to spend the time finding a pile of links nearly everyone is just going to skip over.)
- Mandatum 5y agoI think the counter argument is this is used to discourage residential investment properties to the point where you’re either land banking or you sell it because it doesn’t give you the income you want. Hopefully local taxes will discourage the former.