2 ms·
>>Further, they're not even uploading your photo from your phone (which, again, you've already told them to do if you're using iCloud) for the purpose of analys
by gambiting 5y ago
>>Further, they're not even uploading your photo from your phone (which, again, you've already told them to do if you're using iCloud) for the purpose of analysis; they're reporting a fingerprint
Yes, followed by the actual photo for verification by a human, and if it's indeed a reportable picture it's then sent to authorities. It's very clear from their FAQ that's how it works. That's what I mean by apple "breaking" encryption - the photo is encrypted on the phone, and encrypted on the cloud - except that if their algorithm says it matches(or is just similar to) some hash somewhere, the actual photo will be sent without encryption to them for verification. That's the part I have an issue with. They are not saying to the authorities "hey we found something matching a known hash on this guy's device, do with it what you will"(in which case I'd expect the police to arrive with a search warrant), they do actually analyze, send through to themselves, verify and send to authorities the actual pictures from your phone.
The fact that a permission to store the pictures in iCloud was given before is again problematic, because apple repeatedly says that the iCloud contents are encrypted and they can't see them without a warrant - except in this case here, they can and they will.
>>Many disagree, and would say that reporting child sexual abuse is, in fact, good.
Beyond a doubt, yes, obviously. But the fight against child abuse shouldn't be at all costs, and every technological solution where our privacy is violated should be met with suspicion first. Not to mention the entire discussion about the dangers of this system existing in the first place, Apple saying they will refuse state request to add content detection that isn't related to child abuse doesn't really hold much water, sorry - if doing so is the condition to continue operating in a market large enough, they will absolutely do it and I have zero doubts they would.