3 ms·
> Reading the comments was even more disturbing, as the scrolling arrays of men commenting on the +00+ interspersed with only a few disapprovals from the women
by dpark 15y ago
> Reading the comments was even more disturbing, as the scrolling arrays of men commenting on the +00+ interspersed with only a few disapprovals from the women strong enough to speak out about this in the public forum.
There were quite a few women who commented and did not complain about the picture.
> Corina Newby - Google has always been sexy :)
> Lisa Bimmerz - Well, that's one way to spell "Google"! lol
> Corinne Maloney - I wouldn't consider myself a techie, but I've loved google since I started using it! :)
> Frederika Katuuk - this is sexy..lol
Some did complain, however:
> Diana McQueen - Wow. That a disgusting sexist image. If that's officially from Google, I'm terrible disappointed in them. There should be two women in lab coats standing next to a chiseled guy in a thong. Then maybe.
Of course, the image is disgusting but "a chiseled guy in a thong" would be okay...
I'm all in favor of making software engineering a friendly place for women, but this is not the way to do it. This is a post that someone made on their personal Google+ site. It was not a statement from Google. It was not a Google employee. It was not a conference speech. It was a guy who posted a sexy picture to accompany his thoughts on making Google "sexy". Would it be okay if he had also posted a picture of a guy in a thong?
Trying to tell guys that they can never enjoy sexy images is not the way to fix the gender inequality in the software field. That just breeds resentment.
- marquis 15y agoThis is symptomatic of societal denial that there are serious gender imbalances in the objectification of women. Not long before Tom posted this image there was this public post: https://plus.google.com/117378076401635777570/posts/AQ6Fp44B7VZ https://plus.google.com/117378076401635777570/posts/AQ6Fp44B... How can I, as a woman, read this story and then look back at Google+ and see this image?
- dpark 15y agoHow can you seriously compare a woman choosing to dress in a sexy outfit with women who are forced into prostitution? When Anthony Weiner sends pictures of himself in his underwear, does it cause gender imbalances? Does it cause male objectification?
- marquis 15y agoYes, Weiner's pictures of his underwear is absolutely male objectification - but not in his original context. That was a complicit choice between him and his partners. It become objectification when the media chose to focus on this as a sex issue and deem him unworthy of being in office. And on the comparison to prostitution: why are there prostitutes? Why do men go to prostitutes? Do you think any 7 year old girl says to her parents that she wants to grow up to be a prostitute? It's slavery that is allowed by society because woman are objects (in this context).
- dpark 15y ago> Yes, Weiner's pictures of his underwear is absolutely male objectification - but not in his original context. That was a complicit choice between him and his partners. The woman in this picture chose to wear the outfit. She chose to take a picture with the guys. > It become objectification when the media chose to focus on this as a sex issue and deem him unworthy of being in office. Of course it was a sex issue. He sent nearly-naked photos to a woman he had phone-sex with. I fail to see how it's objectification, though. Why does sex imply objectification? Or does "objectification" just basically have no real meaning? > And on the comparison to prostitution: why are there prostitutes? Why do men go to prostitutes? Do you think any 7 year old girl says to her parents that she wants to grow up to be a prostitute? It's slavery that is allowed by society because woman are objects (in this context). There are prostitutes because there's a market for sex. People generally become prostitutes because they are in poverty. From this particular article, it sounds like the whole area remains a brothel because there's basically no way out for the women there. It's extremely tragic. I frankly find it disgusting that you link attempt to link sexy outfits to forced prostitution and child prostitution. This is far more offensive than anything Tom Anderson posted.
- marquis 15y agoFor you to bring child prostitution into this I believe you did not read the article. >There are prostitutes because there's a market for sex There is a market for sex because women have been legal chattel for centuries, wherein women are traded as objects primarily for the purposes of empowering a certain view of the world. For the record: many organisations specializing in trafficking relief admit that women are equally, if in some cases more at fault, in forcing other women into the prostitution market. I am in no way attempting to blame men for a difficult, millennia-long problem, I just refuse to accept the status-quo while it causes genuine and significant damage.
- erikpukinskis 15y agoThere were quite a few women who commented and did not complain about the picture. This comes up all the time when people call out sexism and it is not a valid rebuttal. Just because someone is a woman does not mean they are an expert in recognizing sexism. Women tend to have more experience with sexism than men, but many deny some or all kinds of sexism, many block it out (often a useful and necessary defense mechanism), many have not spent much time learning about sexism, and many are purveyors of sexism themselves. In addition, the more sexist the subculture, the more it tends to A) attract women who are more sexist, and B) filter out women who are more adversely affected by sexism/lack strong sexism defense mechanisms. "But [my wife/my girlfriend/group of women X] didn't think it was sexist" doesn't necessarily say anything conclusive about whether it is actually sexist. If you are looking for an expert opinion, seek out the opinion of someone who has spent time learning about how sexism works. Your wife/girlfriend/group of women X may or may not be in that category. There are more women than men in that group, but having a vagina does not gain you instant entry.
- dpark 15y ago> This comes up all the time when people call out sexism and it is not a valid rebuttal. It's a perfectly valid rebuttal to someone who tries to make claims about women as a whole. Marquis made a comment about "disapprovals from the women strong enough to speak out". The implication there is that all women are offended and only the strong ones dare to speak out. Clearly it is not true that all women were offended. Many (most?) of the women who commented did not complain, and several commented positively about the picture. > "But [my wife/my girlfriend/group of women X] didn't think it was sexist" doesn't necessarily say anything conclusive about whether it is actually sexist. If you are looking for an expert opinion, seek out the opinion of someone who has spent time learning about how sexism works. Your wife/girlfriend/group of women X may or may not be in that category. There are more women than men in that group, but having a vagina does not gain you instant entry. This is a candy-coated way of saying that we must listen to those most zealous about sexism. We can't listen to the average woman or the opinion of most women. No, we have to listen to those obsessed with finding sexism, even if that means they find it in places it doesn't really exist. Why must sexy always be synonymous with sexist? These are two different things. Lack of sexism does not imply a lack of sexual interest (nor vice versa).
- cowboyhero 15y agoIt's not just "some guy." It's Tom Anderson of mySpace fame, who Techcrunch is working hard to position as some kind of senior statesmen of social media. His articles are getting picked up by Techmeme and are pulling a lot of eyeballs lately. It's irresponsible and immature to attach that image to an article titled "Google is Sexy." If he were 19 years old and posting to Reddit, then yeah, whatever. Nobody would care. But I think anyone who's in any kind of leadership position should know a little better.
- dpark 15y agoIt's still some guy. It doesn't matter that he founded MySpace. He didn't post it there, where it could be seen as a statement from the company. He didn't post it on Techcrunch. He posted it on what is basically a personal blog. If it's irresponsible and immature to attach the image, then shouldn't it simply be irresponsible and immature to call Google "sexy" at all? "Sexy" means inspiring the desire for sex.
- marquis 15y agoWhy are you being defending a position that has clearly upset a number of people, instead of engaging in a debate? This is why so many minorities don't speak up: because we aren't listened to. Time and time again, the majority will defend the status-quo, it's perceived rightful position to impose its will. This entire thread could have simply been: - This makes me feel as if woman are objectified in computing as sexual entities before any other consideration. - I'm sorry you feel that way, what is it about the image in this context that bothers you? - My reply - You reply
- dpark 15y ago> Why are you being defending a position that has clearly upset a number of people, instead of engaging in a debate? I am engaging in a debate. That's what it is when we hold opposing viewpoints and discuss them. It would not be a debate if I simply failed to defend my views. It would just be me surrendering to your opinion. I might just as well ask why you're defending a position that so many clearly disagree with. > This is why so many minorities don't speak up: because we aren't listened to. Time and time again, the majority will defend the status-quo, it's perceived rightful position to impose its will. Very clearly people are listening to you. I am listening. Listening does not require agreement. If you want to debate, then don't accuse others of not listening just because they don't simply bow to your views. > This entire thread could have simply been:- This makes me feel as if woman are objectified in computing as sexual entities before any other consideration.... That's hardly how you started the thread. You began with sarcasm and went straight to accusations of misogyny and then acted as if all the women posting were similarly offended. I have asked why you were offended. In response you compared the image to human trafficking and a culture of forced prostitution. Edit: Dropped the reference to child prostitution because that's apparently not the comparison you were trying to make.