2 ms·
I used the Gnome 3.38 desktop for about a year, and it may have been one of my favorite desktop experiences yet. GTK+ felt robust and mature for my needs, stuff
by smoldesu 5y ago
I used the Gnome 3.38 desktop for about a year, and it may have been one of my favorite desktop experiences yet. GTK+ felt robust and mature for my needs, stuff looked pretty and functioned mostly the same way. The guidelines weren't perfect, but years of incremental improvement got it pretty damn close. Gnome 40's "no sacred cows" approach is throwing a lot of that work away, and it ultimately deterred me from staying on rolling-release Gnome. Adding insult to injury, GTK4 support is basically in pre-alpha right now. The widget website and design reference was broken for weeks, and transitioning Gnome 3.38 code to 40 just isn't worth the trouble.
- fmoralesc 5y agoGTK3 isn't deprecated (like GTK2 is), and there is no rush to port things to GTK4 yet. In terms of it being 'pre-alpha' (besides the docs, which in my experience before was always lagging behind), everything in the roadmap is basically done: https://wiki.gnome.org/Projects/GTK/Roadmap/GTK4 https://wiki.gnome.org/Projects/GTK/Roadmap/GTK4 On the other hand, the changes in Gnome 40 were not as massive as the change from 2 to 3, and to me at least the change felt more incremental than disruptive (of course, the transition period is always a bit rough, some non-essential extensions for gnome-shell didn't work for me after the change, but eventually everything I needed was ported--I even dropped some extensions). I feel that saying that 'a lot of the work from 3 was thrown away' is an overstatement.