20 ms·
> Screenshots of Google's internal salary calculator seen by Reuters show that an employee living in Stamford, Connecticut - an hour from New York City by train
by tzs 5y ago
> Screenshots of Google's internal salary calculator seen by Reuters show that an employee living in Stamford, Connecticut - an hour from New York City by train - would be paid 15% less if she worked from home, while a colleague from the same office living in New York City would see no cut from working from home. Screenshots showed 5% and 10% differences in the Seattle, Boston and San Francisco areas.
This makes no sense.
For employees who are required to work in the office it makes sense to pay more at offices in places with higher costs of living. That's because your pool of potential employees is only people who live there or will move there. The company is requiring that employees live in a specific area so must pay based on the costs of that area.
For full time work from home employees the company has no reason to care where the employee lives (other than regulatory--they might not want employees who live in areas where dealing with taxes or regulations are complex or costly). Hence the company should have one uniform rate for full time work at home employees, high enough so that they can get fill all their openings.
If that means that the rate is too low for people in NYC why should the company care as long as they can get enough people from Stamford and other places with lower costs of living than NYC?
- sdevonoes 5y ago> If that means that the rate is too low for people in NYC why should the company care as long as they can get enough people from Stamford and other places with lower costs of living than NYC? Exactly. Google doesn't care, and as any other "good" company out there: money comes first, employees are peons. The thing I hope we are discussing here is: what (Google) employees can do about it? Can they do something at all? And if they can't, well, this basically means that in the near future every IT company out there will be doing the same. Sad, but hey, if we let companies do this sort of things, well, we deserve it.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoIt's fair in the sense that they provide each with the means to live at roughy the same standard-of-life: a Stamford $ has more buying power because local prices are lower, so they need fewer of them. Or, one could simply see it as answering a different question. Not "how much are you worth", but rather "how much do you need". If that sounds unfair, consider that it's close to the principle by which most parents care for their children' needs. Or, more prosaically, the New York employee simply has more options besides Google, and they might chose to work in an office if it means a 15% difference.
- usaar333 5y agoThe problem with COL adjustments is that they are very crude. Different workers consume more (and consume different baskets), so see wildly different impacts. Being "fair" then becomes risky from the point of view of everyone as they'll actually find it unfair. I think it's easier to align on market demand on which case I agree with OP - market rate adjustments by location don't make sense for remote workers.
- dougmwne 5y agoShould companies provide salary adjustments for each child an employee has so they can maintain a certain quality of life? Should the company reduce the salary of employees that have lots of investments so that they don't have a higher quality of life than someone with fewer assets? Should companies pay people with chronic health conditions more than healthy people so they can live a more equal life?
- ridaj 5y agoCost of living adjustments aren't necessarily fair either. Between two office workers who do the same job in the same location, should the one being thrifty by choosing to live in a lower cost area farther away from the office be paid less than the one who lives in a glitzy neighborhood close by?
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Hence the company should have one uniform rate for full time work at home employees, high enough so that they can get fill all their openings. There’s a common misconception that engineers are paid for the value they provide or according to how expensive their cost of living is. It’s not true, though. We’re paid market rate, which is a balance of supply and demand that determines whether or not someone is incentivized to take and keep a job relative to their other options. If someone lives somewhere where they have more local options, it makes sense to pay them more even if they’re working remotely. If you try to push companies to having one WFH rate for everyone, the end result isn’t high salaries for all. The end result is a median salary for everyone that eliminates anyone living in a high cost of living area. The company starts scouring the country and eventually the world for bargain employees who will accept lower and lower salaries. The end result is a much lower fixed salary for everyone. So no, you do not actually want a one-size-fits-all WFH compensation if you live basically anywhere in the US, unless you’re cool with salaries going down to match the much lower global median wages for developers.
- lamontcg 5y agoWages are sticky and employers have gotten used to paying a certain rate for employees and employees have gotten used to be paid that rate. If Google wants to try to cut that rate, its likely that someone else who is hungry for Google engineers (like Facebook which is going full-time WFH) will be willing to pay that rate (also understanding that they have some terrible PR issues and will need to pay a bit higher due to that). That is likely to cap how much Google is actually able to do this if someone can phone up Facebook and get an immediate >20% raise over what Google will "calculate" their pay should be.
- usaar333 5y agoRight, this makes little sense unless there is little market competition. Alternatively, this might just be a morale thing and remote workers in the Bay Area don't actually make financial sense due to productivity losses. Google will placate existing employees, but they won't hire new remote workers at Bay Area rates.
- 5y ago
- jayd16 5y agoEven if Google et al go remote, not everyone will. The NY market will still be more competitive than a suburb. Prices might reflect that.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> This makes no sense. It makes a ton of sense. Salaries are based on supply/demand, like any other marketplace. Workers in LCOL areas have less options for high pay so you can offer them less money and they'll likely accept it.
- tzs 5y agoThe point is that when it comes to full time remote work workers in LCOL areas and workers in HCOL areas are in the same marketplace selling the same product.
- joshuamorton 5y agoAnd the counterpoint is that there are few enough companies offering sv salaries to remote workers in Topeka that it doesn't matter. Put another way, if you live in X location your job market is local jobs + remote jobs. The remote jobs are constant everywhere, so there's a relatively high demand. Unless the remote market absolutely dominates the local market, remote jobs can still compete with local ones.
- Mikeb85 5y agoBut wherever there's an arbritage opportunity, people take it. If you're offering your services for $500k but you live in NY, I can move to say, Ukraine, and charge only $400k, undercutting you to get the job. There's no point holding out for more when I can accept less and give myself a better chance of getting the job.