5 ms·
Who did you switch to? As I assume you are aware Google has already been doing this as well as Facebook. Apple was simply the last of those to start doing it. F
by heavymark 5y ago
Who did you switch to? As I assume you are aware Google has already been doing this as well as Facebook. Apple was simply the last of those to start doing it. Facebook reported 20 million instances of csam to ncmec last year alone.
- zabatuvajdka 5y agoWho says you need any of the above? Cloud storage is overrated. When is the last time you lost files? I have stuff from an old lexar jump drive early 2000s doing just fine. For more sensitive materials back up when the data changes and store in a disaster proof safe. I think the fear of losing things is a problem. People take so many photos anyway and who even looks at all of them? Memories are great and we should cherish them but… this is one of those cases where folks don’t need to rely on big tech.
- dahfizz 5y agoOr, just encrypt your files before sending them to sit on someone else's server.
- 14 5y agoGasp, are you saying anyone worried about getting caught simply could encrypt their photos first and this system won’t work? So an extra step for the bad guy, a system that is invasive for all users, and a system that is easily avoided by the bad guy. What are you doing Apple, this feels like a cheating partner here.
- camillomiller 5y agoThen in this case you could still use an Apple device, considering that if you don't use iCloud Photos, there's no scanning on your device anyway. I think that radical stances and refusing a dialogue, albeit critical, it's something that in this case won't really go anywhere.
- zionic 5y agoNope, Apple announced this tech is coming to 3rd party apps via API. iCloud was just the start, it wasn't the end.
- newbamboo 5y agoNo, someone can still attack you by creating an iCloud account and pushing cp. There is no way to mitigate such an attack after purchasing an apple device as far as I can tell. And, apple pretends their devices are secure so they have incentive to not discover compromised devices (as if they could) even though it’s clearly a problem with Pegasus and probably many other non-consumer grade exploits. I think the only answer is a phone that cannot back up to the cloud at all. Which is what I suppose I have to shop for now. Hopefully this attack hits some senator or apple exec first. I don’t want to backup my phone, and at this point I don’t want a camera or location services. I want security which apple no longer offers.
- camillomiller 5y ago>No, someone can still attack you by creating an iCloud account and pushing cp. There is no way to mitigate such an attack after purchasing an apple device as far as I can tell. Could you elaborate? Totally unclear to me what kind of attack you're talking about.
- kemayo 5y agoI think they're saying that if someone can completely hack your phone so as to have remote control of it, they can sign you up for an iCloud account and add CSAM to it. This seems... implausibly convoluted. If you have full remote control of someone's phone, Apple or not, you could do all sorts of incriminating things "as them", and I don't think Apple's new system noticeably increases your risk from this.
- hughrr 5y agoLinux, dumbphone (sms/calls only) Fastmail, no other cloud services. I’ve been on the verge of doing this for a few years so had my exit strategy well planned.
- ipaddr 5y agoWhy would you use any of these ?
- vineyardmike 5y agoMost HN crowd presumable isn't actually worried about CSAM detection itself - its the local-side scanning where you lose control over your own hardware.
- hughrr 5y agoExactly that.