2 ms·
> The grading was done based on a distribution where only a certain % of candidates could get each grade in a given exam I don't think that's fair, either. Tha
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
> The grading was done based on a distribution where only a certain % of candidates could get each grade in a given exam
I don't think that's fair, either. That's suitable when you have a ranking and only the top n are accepted (like in admission exams) but IMHO not when the idea is to benchmark against a level of achievement: In which case it does not really matter how well others did, only how well each candidate did against the expectation.
So while I do think exams should be so that only a certain % of candidates usually get top grades, I think that this should be achieved by calibrating exam questions to the appropriate level of difficulty.
For instance, there should be a few stretch questions that are challenging enough that maybe only the top 10% on average are expected to get them right and the grades' thresholds should be set accordingly.
A-levels are ridiculous to the point that when it was becoming evident that too many As were handed a few years back the answer was to create a new A* grade for the "really good ones". But of course inflation did not stop so I fully expect someone to propose A* in a few years.
- candiodari 5y ago> but IMHO not when the idea is to benchmark against a level of achievement. Yeah but the level of achievement required for starting university education has steadily dropped, and university enrollment has risen as a result. I once read an article that claimed to have done the math for this, on math. It claimed that the absolute top grade in 1976 in high school math would have been insufficient to have gotten you into university just 15 years earlier. I believe they assumed you answered all the questions asked correctly and would leave any more advanced questions blank.