3 ms·
Say you take the one-way ticket to travel to a far off galaxy at 1g acceleration to go mine space-diamonds... What when someone else in a few hundred earth yea
by londons_explore 5y ago
Say you take the one-way ticket to travel to a far off galaxy at 1g acceleration to go mine space-diamonds...
What when someone else in a few hundred earth years invents the 1.1g rocket to go mine those same space diamonds? They will arrive millions of (local) years before you. By the time you arrive, the space diamonds will be all mined and you'll be seen as a cave man.
That reason alone means it's never worth departing on a long journey, because someone else always has an incentive to overtake you and get there millions of years sooner.
- adrianN 5y agoAha, but if everyone thinks that way you will actually be the only one daring enough to embark on that journey and have all the space diamonds for yourself!
- ehnto 5y agoBy that reasoning, no-one ever leaves. If no-one had ever left, you may as well have left and be there already. I think the reason to leave will have to be something other than space-diamonds, or other monetary needs. More like planetary conquest and scientific advancement.
- jusssi 5y agoIn addition, something approacing from opposite direction might already be there when you decide to launch, digging away at the diamonds. Or a local star might have gone nova and vaporized the whole diamond field.
- RavlaAlvar 5y agoOr someone who invented a device that can fold space time.
- vidarh 5y agoQuite a few scifi stories have explored the idea of someone leapfrogged that way. I think it'd be a major concern of sending someone that way. [For one light take on this, the original Marvel "Guardians of the Galaxy" (the year 3000 versions) have Vance Astro, Major Victory, go on a 1000 year journey to Alpha Centauri, only to find other humans got there centuries earlier and were waiting for his arrival]
- est31 5y agoCurrently we are in a phase of rapid scientific progress, but there is no law that this will continue forever. One day we'll hit diminishing returns and instead of discovering new things, science will be about applying the knowledge discovered in the past correctly, as well as not losing it. Thankfully we are still far away from this.
- withinboredom 5y agoNot only that, but whatever star the space diamonds are orbiting probably won’t be there any more.
- mewpmewp2 5y agoIt would be quite a fun expedition though, knowing that when you reach your destination there could already be many others who have reached that point so you can see how everything has advanced. Assuming your goals are oriented more towards curiosity rather than making money. You sacrifice 30 years to see what someone potentially achieved within 1 million years. I'm sure there would be people willing to do that. Let's say I'm an uber billionaire (trillionaire in the future), aged 45, I might think that I have tried already everything there's to try on earth and want to see the future. I would build a ship with more than enough entertainment for following 30 years and invite bunch of other people and just start with the journey. Maybe I could even leave some money behind for other groups to keep building better solutions that would reach the destination much sooner so they can already start building out the destination and have millions of years of time to do that before I reach there. It would be an enormous risk of course, but it could also pay off very well if for example you still own a large proportion of the business you leave behind to build the following spaceships and if it ever should reach the destination was still legally upholding the ownership you have. In fact in this case you could be magnitudes more richer in the new location when you arrive as compared to when you left 30 years ago in your time. Or if something like cryogenic freeze is possible, you could also do that for some of the years if you ever got bored in the ship.
- neartheplain 5y agoThat's also a common Star Trek plot point. Many episodes involve the Enterprise catching up to a ship launched from Earth in the pre-warp era, typically an early colony or exploration vessel. The most of famous of these might be Khan Noonien Singh's "Botany Bay:" https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/SS_Botany_Bay https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/SS_Botany_Bay
- topynate 5y ago> They will arrive millions of (local) years before you. No they won't – in the frame of reference of the galaxy, both you and your pursuer will spend most of the journey traveling at very close to the speed of light. The difference won't be enough to catch up. Put another way, in the frame of reference of the galaxy, you get to Andromeda (2.5 million light-years away) only about two years later than light would. Your pursuer, traveling at 1.1 g, would get there about a year and 9 months after light. So anyone chasing you would have to take off within about three months – and after a year, nothing could catch you. This arrival time delay relative to light is pretty much constant (for fixed g) for any distance over about 1000 light years. For this reason, sci-fi authors who want ships to be overtaken by later models either slow the old ships down to much less than light-speed (i.e. generation ships) or introduce FTL travel.