4 ms·
The real problem is that McDonalds corporate forces franchisees to buy a crappy version of the machine that generates huge income for Taylor, and (most likely)
by ncmncm 5y ago
The real problem is that McDonalds corporate forces franchisees to buy a crappy version of the machine that generates huge income for Taylor, and (most likely) for McD corporate via kickbacks, from weekly service calls. Taylor makes almost-identical machines for other joints that work fine, but franchisees are contractually obligated to buy the crappy one, and to have it "fixed" all the damn time by Taylor techs. It is a racket.
I don't know what would happen if a franchisee bought one of each and put the crappy one in a closet. Probably corporate would notice the lack of kickback revenue and force the issue somehow.
Really, attorneys general should be investigating McD corporate for anti-competitive behavior, and getting restraining orders against corporate taking the kickbacks. (Maybe even prosecute it?) Somehow, enforcement of anti-trust law has been neutered so that it takes extraordinary measures to get even the most basic sort of action against abuse. Racketeering law might be more effective.
Without the kickbacks, corporate will have no incentive to force franchisees to spend thousands of dollars every week on unnecessary "service" work. But corporate should be forced to pay all the franchisees' accumulated service costs that exceed the norm for similar machines. With interest.
Of course, without the machines failing all the time, Kytch won't have a market. So, they actually want McD to keep getting the kickbacks for repairs on the crappy machines, and continue forcing franchisees to depend on them, and just leave Kytch to collect their own piece of the action. None of Taylor's, Kytch's, or corporates' hands are especially clean, but Kytch is making things uncomfortable for entrenched racketeers, so we like to cheer them on.
- gizmo686 5y agoI'm not opposed to regulating the relationship between franchiser and franchisee, but anti trust does not strike me as a good fit. The market here seems to be something like 'franchise rights to a fast service food brand'. McDonalds is far from the only company offering such a thing.
- qeternity 5y agoA Franchisor’s job is to mandate things exactly like this. A McFlurry tastes the same everywhere because it’s the same ingredients prepared the same way on the same machine. There may be some issue, and there may even be fraud as you seem confident of, but this isn’t an anti-trust issue. The fast food biz is incredibly competitive, and franchisees have a number of other options.
- joshuamorton 5y agoOn the other hand, things are not the same everywhere if you cannot order the dish at all because the machine is broken as often as not.
- qeternity 5y agoSure, agreed. Not an antitrust issue.
- gopalv 5y ago> The real problem is that McDonalds corporate forces franchisees to buy a crappy version of the machine that generates huge income for Taylor Wendys also uses the same vendor with a better machine, which is where this starts to look malicious rather than incompetent. The broken machine is one specifically made for McDonalds. In general, this is anti-consumer in two different ways - you don't give me ice-cream with the apple pie and whenever it breaks, you throw away a couple of gallons of the mixture to be safe. There was a deep-dive into this from Johnny Harris[1], which dug through the manuals for the machine, sales projections from Taylor and why McD franchisees are easier marks for this than others (the revenue volume is huge). [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrDEtSlqJC4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrDEtSlqJC4